Game Day Port vs Roos - JLT #2

[DazalenkoUBewty]

Rocky of old right there!

 

[Smithy7]

Duursma really shouldn't be playing round 1. Has got the ball a fair bit today, but I'd like to see him improve his decision making at Sanfl level before he plays AFL.

Duursma made some silly decisions ... but he will learn.

 

[JUSTWORK]

Love seeing Rockliff back to his best, hopefully keeps it up.

Love him as much as everyone else, but when Dixon is back Marshall isn’t anywhere near being best 22.

Butters, Duursma and Rozee all look like they’ll be very good players.

 

[dirty2]

50m was too big a penalty in the first place, so they buffed it!

Typical blizzard... I mean afl

 

[DazalenkoUBewty]

About the 50 m rule what happens if the player with the ball runs so fast that he passes the umpire?

Another 50

 

[x_les_x]

Yeah ill put my hand up Amon was actually good today 3 run down tackles one token mistake but he was good

 

[WHOME]

Watch the game and get back to us, had some horrible moments

Watts 23 disposals. Didn't do anything to horrible from what I remember.

Sent from my HTC 2PS5200 using Tapatalk

On HTC Desire 650 using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[DazalenkoUBewty]

Duursma made some silly decisions ... but he will learn.

Yeah, apart from a few silly mistakes he looks great I reckon.

 

[tribey]

Equally, why should the team who has just won the ball/advantage have to wait for the defense to get all their players back while the big dumb lumbering ruckman takes his time to get back?

If the ‘protected zone’ is a rule, it has to apply to the time that the winner of the free runs the entire 50, as they shouldn’t lose advantage due to gamesmanship from the opponent. It’s up to the defenders to rotate.

Sure, but you shouldn’t be in a position to potentially outrun the umpire whose duty it is to set the mark.

 

[PowerBaz]

Basically if you give away a 50, just stop. It’s for up the ground to worry about.

I’d tell the player who gave it away to just stop

 

[Killer Power]

Of the fringe players / recruits I would be playing round 1 Amon, Butters, Lycett of course.... think we will have to play at least one of Rozee / Burton / Duursma. Probably Burton for me.

 

[NEGAN]

Typical blizzard... I mean afl

Unless you're Mercy

 

[WHOME]

Duursma made some silly decisions ... but he will learn.

Absolutely he will learn, but we don't want him costing us AFL games while he does

On HTC Desire 650 using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Far Kern]

About the 50 m rule what happens if the player with the ball runs so fast that he passes the umpire?

So, where is the mark and who sets it? Nobody knows.

 

[DazalenkoUBewty]

Basically if you give away a 50, just stop. It’s for up the ground to worry about.

I’d tell the player who gave it away to just stop

It looks like that's what will have to happen. But then you're a man down ahead of play. A 50 and a man down...

 

[chiwigi]

Typical blizzard... I mean afl

It’s the Paladin of rules!

 

[HighBudget]

Duursma really shouldn't be playing round 1. Has got the ball a fair bit today, but I'd like to see him improve his decision making at Sanfl level before he plays AFL.

Hartlett or Broadbent will replace him I reckon

 

[Andre]

It’s the Paladin of rules!

Lawful stupid!

 

[Janus]

No problem with the second 50m penalty.

If you look at the Clurey non-call, he didn't get pinged because he was running as fast as he could back to the mark, where as Westhoff hesitated, then started to jog before beginning to sprint once he saw the North player was trying to get in front of him, and in doing so denied him the opportunity of playing on at any time.

The player conceding just has to get on their bike if they give away a 50m penalty. It means that a 50 is more punitive but that's what it was originally before the players became that much fitter.

 

[PowerBaz]

Better that than 100 m away, basically a goal.

Stupid rule they should can.

 

[Doctor Feel]

Marshall I think we just need to persist with.

 

[Macca19]

I'm hard as a rock right now. Can't wait to see a replay!

 

[Schulzenfest]

This new 50 metre penalty rule is the dumbest thing the AFL Rules Committee have ever come up with, and that's a very competitive field. Just scrap it tonight and forget about it forever before it ruins a real game of football.

 

[PowerBaz]

No problem with the second 50m penalty.

If you look at the Clurey non-call, he didn't get pinged because he was running as fast as he could back to the mark, where as Westhoff hesitated, then started to jog before beginning to sprint once he saw the North player was trying to get in front of him, and in doing so denied him the opportunity of playing on at any time.

The player conceding just has to get on their bike if they give away a 50m penalty. It means that a 50 is more punitive but that's what it was originally before the players became that much fitter.

It will make the AFL look like amature hour on TV and cost someone a final. Over officiated rubbish.

 

[PowerBaz]

Marshall I think we just need to persist with.

The G will suit him round 1