Rate my SuperCoach team 2012

[The Grover]

my Team, rookie selection driving me nuts without seeing them play.


D: Goddard, Scotland, Deledio, Hargrave, Stratton, Clarke, Mohr ( Morris, Wilkes )

M: Pendlebury, Ablett, Murphy, Barlow, Hayes, Shiel ( Zorko, Mitchell )

R: McEvoy, McIntosh ( Giles, Stephenson )

F: Franklin, Goodes, Fyfe, Dangerfield, Saad, Treloar, Smedts ( Hill, Kerridge )

 

[CobberRodgers]

It is a pretty good team mate, no great surprises.

Maybe keep an eye on Lake, and you could also save some money with downgrading from the more expensive rookies.

Starting a rookie ruck is also a risk but could pay off.

Thanks Mentor.

Will obviously watch Lake during the NAB Cup and also the chosen rookies are all subject to change depending on NAB Cup form and selection round 1. There will be a couple of changes there for sure.

I like Goldy (Nth have dream draw) and I'm pretty sure I'll get game time into a few rookie rucks so will hopefully upgrade to a gun (Mummy, Cox etc on form) later on.

Cobber.

 

[SteeleSide11]

my Team, rookie selection driving me nuts without seeing them play.


D: Goddard, Scotland, Deledio, Hargrave, Stratton, Clarke, Mohr ( Morris, Wilkes )

M: Pendlebury, Ablett, Murphy, Barlow, Hayes, Shiel ( Zorko, Mitchell )

R: McEvoy, McIntosh ( Giles, Stephenson )

F: Franklin, Goodes, Fyfe, Dangerfield, Saad, Treloar, Smedts ( Hill, Kerridge )

The rookie selections will be hard mate as no one will know untill Round 1 but, if you can find out the mature age rookies especially at melbourne GWS GC etc.. then put them in best chance.
Im not a big fan of picking blokes that are coming back from big knee injuries, id get rid of Barlow and Hayes.. Look at (Priddis, Cotchin, Selwood etc) Good Luck

 

[The Grover]

The rookie selections will be hard mate as no one will know untill Round 1 but, if you can find out the mature age rookies especially at melbourne GWS GC etc.. then put them in best chance.
Im not a big fan of picking blokes that are coming back from big knee injuries, id get rid of Barlow and Hayes.. Look at (Priddis, Cotchin, Selwood etc) Good Luck

thanks, yes bit risky. will monitor over NAB.

 

[northeast tiger]

Backs: Buntine - NO MCKernan - NO NO NO. Probably like the MPP option with Smedts but just no. He is terrible

Midfielders: Priddis and Mitchel are DT guns, not SUpercoach guns. I have scoured brisbane's board and see no mention of Dyson having ROund 1 prospects. Same with Gibson from north. MANY better rookies available

Rucks: McIntosh is second banana and not gauranteed a game.

FWDS: At that price Dalhouse needs to turn into a premium and it just isn't going to happen.

There is a bit to work with there though. Keep going

Being that Priddis is the 9th most expensive SC player with a 2011 average of 114, I would suggest you stop giving advice if you have no idea what you are talking about.

 

[MightyMark]

Being that Priddis is the 9th most expensive SC player with a 2011 average of 114, I would suggest you stop giving advice if you have no idea what you are talking about.

Also averaged 104 and 108 in the two previous seasons, topping the ton in 72.7% of games. Pretty sure that can be counted as consistency. GUN!

 

[theduckfan]

Hey All,

After a bit of feedback for my first attempt at a SC team for season 2012.

Cheers

(If image comes up small right click, and select view image.)

 

[_Gazza_]

The rookie selections will be hard mate as no one will know untill Round 1 but, if you can find out the mature age rookies especially at melbourne GWS GC etc.. then put them in best chance.
Im not a big fan of picking blokes that are coming back from big knee injuries, id get rid of Barlow and Hayes.. Look at (Priddis, Cotchin, Selwood etc) Good Luck

imo barlow doesnt fit into the same bracket as hayes. for one barlow broke his leg, an injury that is unlikely to reoccur compared to hayes knee injury. furthermore barlow has had a fair few games since thr injury and a strong preseason and as such there is a fair chance he'll at the very least make 50k. this is why he's showing up in a fair few teams. to do well in sc you gotta take risks somewhere and as ar as risks go, barlow is one of the better options

 

[cotter101]

Brendon Goddard, Heath Shaw, Sam Fisher, Pearce Hanley, Marty Clarke, Steven Morris, Billie Smedts
Luke Brown, Beau Wilkes

Scott Pendlebury, Gary Ablett jnr, Dane Swan, Michael Barlow, Adam Treloar, James McDonald
Sam Gibson, Brendan Lee

Dean Cox, Trent West
Jonathan Giles, Tom Derickx

Adam Goodes, Matthew Pavlich, Paul Chapman, Colin Sylvia, Todd Banfield, Israel Folau, Jeremy Cameron
Tommy Walsh, Sam Rowe





Backs: Hanley is primed for time on the wing and was arguably our best on ground in the intra club match. Might be a premium before years end.

Mid: Premiums strong in Pendles, Ablett and Swan, hopefully Barlow can get back and average 100+

Rucks: Cox is the best ruckman in the game and I have no doubt he will be the best ruckman sc wise at the end of 2012. Tossing up between West and Maric as second ruck as both are going to get plenty of gametime.

Forwards: Sylvia will probably be tossed out of my team, Banfield is another who will get game time in the midfield but I might downgrade him and upgrade West/Barlow?

 

[joydivision22]

1st draft of sc 2012! leaning towards rookies this year, would love some advice or tips, cheers.

Backs
'Goddard' 'Grimes, J' 'Lake' 'Roberton' 'Brown N (Coll)' 'Buntine' 'Clarke, M'
'Docherty' 'Wilkes'

Mids
'Ablett' 'Fyfe' 'Hayes' 'Petrenko' 'Coniglio' 'Morabito'
'Wingard' 'Mitchell, T'

Rucks
'Sandilands' 'McEvoy'
'Cordy' 'Stephenson'

Forwards
'Franklin' 'Riewoldt' 'Crameri' 'Higgins' 'Watts' 'Brown' 'Rioli'
'Walsh' 'Kerridge'

Remaining Salary Cap
$36,700

CHEERS!!!

 

[Turly]

Brendon Goddard, Heath Shaw, Sam Fisher, Pearce Hanley, Marty Clarke, Steven Morris, Billie Smedts
Luke Brown, Beau Wilkes

Scott Pendlebury, Gary Ablett jnr, Dane Swan, Michael Barlow, Adam Treloar, James McDonald
Sam Gibson, Brendan Lee

Dean Cox, Trent West
Jonathan Giles, Tom Derickx

Adam Goodes, Matthew Pavlich, Paul Chapman, Colin Sylvia, Todd Banfield, Israel Folau, Jeremy Cameron
Tommy Walsh, Sam Rowe





Backs: Hanley is primed for time on the wing and was arguably our best on ground in the intra club match. Might be a premium before years end.

Mid: Premiums strong in Pendles, Ablett and Swan, hopefully Barlow can get back and average 100+

Rucks: Cox is the best ruckman in the game and I have no doubt he will be the best ruckman sc wise at the end of 2012. Tossing up between West and Maric as second ruck as both are going to get plenty of gametime.

Forwards: Sylvia will probably be tossed out of my team, Banfield is another who will get game time in the midfield but I might downgrade him and upgrade West/Barlow?

Strong team although I'd be dumping Banfield and Sylvia. Other than that I'm a fan! I would also encourage one more change and that would be to have Buddy in the fwds.......He is a must I'd say

My second attempt:

BACKS: Goddard - Deledio - Shaw - Enright - Burgoyne - Clarke - Ellis
(Morris, Sierakowski)

MIDS: Ablett - Swan - Murphy - Hayes - K. Stevens - Shiel
(Treloar, Brown)

RUCKS: Mcevoy - Giles
(Stephenson - Witts)

FWDS: Franklin - Pavlich - Martin - N.Riewoldt - Brown - Saad - Smedts
(Zorko, Cameron)


Burgoyne is a risk I may possibly upgrade to Heppel? And dependant on NAB cup form I may upgrade Hayes to Barlow.

Would really appreciate thoughts and feedback.

Cheers guys

 

[Probitas_]

Never entered a Supercoach or anything like this before, so looking for whatever feedback I can get.

BACKS: Goddard - Deledio - Shaw - Wilkes - Mohr- Clarke - Ellis
(Morris, Spurr)

MIDS: Ablett - Pendlebury - Murphy - Priddis - Hayes - Shiel
(McDonald, Kerridge)

RUCKS: Cox - Leuenberger
(Stephenson - Giles)

FWDS: Franklin - Goodes - Martin - Brown - Zorko - Treloar
(Walsh, Dick)

Remaining Salary Cap - $2400

Thanks for any advice.

 

[cotter101]

Strong team although I'd be dumping Banfield and Sylvia. Other than that I'm a fan! I would also encourage one more change and that would be to have Buddy in the fwds.......He is a must I'd say

My second attempt:

BACKS: Goddard - Deledio - Shaw - Enright - Burgoyne - Clarke - Ellis
(Morris, Sierakowski)

MIDS: Ablett - Swan - Murphy - Hayes - K. Stevens - Shiel
(Treloar, Brown)

RUCKS: Mcevoy - Giles
(Stephenson - Witts)

FWDS: Franklin - Pavlich - Martin - N.Riewoldt - Brown - Saad - Smedts
(Zorko, Cameron)


Burgoyne is a risk I may possibly upgrade to Heppel? And dependant on NAB cup form I may upgrade Hayes to Barlow.

Would really appreciate thoughts and feedback.

Cheers guys

Nice team I'd get rid of Burgoyne and get marty clarke and use the left over cash elsewhere.

Does this look better?

Brendon Goddard, Heath Shaw, Sam Fisher, Pearce Hanley, Marty Clarke, Steven Morris, Billie Smedts
Luke Brown, Beau Wilkes

Scott Pendlebury, Gary Ablett jnr, Dane Swan, Tom Rockliff, Adam Treloar, James McDonald
Sam Gibson, Brendan Lee

Dean Cox, Matthew Kreuzer
Jonathan Giles, Tom Derickx

Lance Franklin, Adam Goodes, Matthew Pavlich, Paul Chapman, Israel Folau, Jeremy Cameron, Tommy Walsh
Sam Kerridge, Sam Rowe

 

[Evil Toucan]

Never entered a Supercoach or anything like this before, so looking for whatever feedback I can get.

BACKS: Goddard - Deledio - Shaw - Wilkes - Mohr- Clarke - Ellis
(Morris, Spurr)

MIDS: Ablett - Pendlebury - Murphy - Priddis - Hayes - Shiel
(McDonald, Kerridge)

RUCKS: Cox - Leuenberger
(Stephenson - Giles)

FWDS: Franklin - Goodes - Martin - Brown - Zorko - Treloar
(Walsh, Dick)

Remaining Salary Cap - $2400

Thanks for any advice.

Great effort for a first timer!!

A 5 premium midfield does seem a bit too much. There's excellent options from this years batch of midfield rookies. If you do your research there is a few that aren't mentioned on this "rate my team" thread either.

A 4 rookies backline just won't provide enough stability for you mate. The points aren't really there, I know, but you can't risk having donuts (zero's) in your team.

Your forwards are 1 player short?

Rucks, well Cox, Leuenberger and Giles all share the rd 11 bye so you will be in serious trouble here lol. Perhaps Cox's price tag is a bit too much?

Would downgrade Hayes for a Rookie and get an extra premium defender. You could even start a strong 3 prem midfield and have good rookies.

It is important to remember that you need to have the best rookies in your team. You should be working your structure around your rookies. It's not a matter of finding premiums then filling in gaps to meet the budget.

You have your non-negotiable premiums, your must have rookies after watching the NAB cup and researching, and then you see what's left after that.

 

[Turly]

Nice team I'd get rid of Burgoyne and get marty clarke and use the left over cash elsewhere.

Does this look better?

Brendon Goddard, Heath Shaw, Sam Fisher, Pearce Hanley, Marty Clarke, Steven Morris, Billie Smedts
Luke Brown, Beau Wilkes

Scott Pendlebury, Gary Ablett jnr, Dane Swan, Tom Rockliff, Adam Treloar, James McDonald
Sam Gibson, Brendan Lee

Dean Cox, Matthew Kreuzer
Jonathan Giles, Tom Derickx

Lance Franklin, Adam Goodes, Matthew Pavlich, Paul Chapman, Israel Folau, Jeremy Cameron, Tommy Walsh
Sam Kerridge, Sam Rowe

Marty Clarke is already in my defence lol....

 

[cotter101]

Marty Clarke is already in my defence lol....

, I'd still downgrade Burgoyne for a rookie who is likely to get games(You will need to watch the NAB Cup) Then you need to upgrade mcevoy to say mumford? and use the money to upgrade other players.

 

[Griff19]

Hi all, any help or thoughts would be appreciated.

Goddard, Deledio, Shaw, Grimes, Sheppard, Clarke, Tomlinson - (Morris/Wilkes)

Pendles, Ablett, Selwood, Barlow, Caddy, Hampton - (Shiel/Mitchell)

Leuenberger, Kreuzer - Rowe/Stephenson

Buddy, D.Martin, N.Riewoldt, S.Johnson, Porplyzia, Zorko, Treloar - (Smedts/T.Walsh)

 

[Billy1]

Hi all, any help or thoughts would be appreciated.

Goddard, Deledio, Shaw, Grimes, Sheppard, Clarke, Tomlinson - (Morris/Wilkes)

Pendles, Ablett, Selwood, Barlow, Caddy, Hampton - (Shiel/Mitchell)

Leuenberger, Kreuzer - Rowe/Stephenson

Buddy, D.Martin, N.Riewoldt, S.Johnson, Porplyzia, Zorko, Treloar - (Smedts/T.Walsh)

I really wanna pick Grimes, I just know the year I don't pick him he will play every game... for now though I have left him out.

My team...

Goddard, Enright, Birchall, Broughton, Clarke, Ellis, Smedts (Morris, Brown)

Ablett, Murphy, J. Selwood, Deledio, Wingard, Shiel (Kerridge, Mitchell)

Leuenberger, Kreuzer (Giles, Stephensen)

Franklin, Chapman, Martin, Zaharakis, Brown, Pfeiffer, Treloar (Zorko, Walsh)

Salary cap remaining: $1,700

Have tried to allow for DPP by having Kerridge in the mids as a mid/fwd and Deledio as a mid/bck. Not sure if I should be worrying too much about that though and haven't even looked at the byes yet.

 

[ShueyIsAGun]

Being that Priddis is the 9th most expensive SC player with a 2011 average of 114, I would suggest you stop giving advice if you have no idea what you are talking about.

So I have no idea? All my other advice is terrible as well? Granted I did not know he was 9th most expensive but I think for the money you spend on Priddis you can do better. Yes he always racks up possessions but his disposal efficiency is a little low and he doesn't kick enough goals. I am a West Coast fan so watch every game he plays. I know there is love out there for him as a unique pick but if you are starting four premiums in midfield for Supercoach I think there are better options. Namely Pendles, Swan, Ablett, Judd and Murphy.

Its only advise anyway mate. If you disagree with my views on Priddis that's fine, just say so. To say I have no idea what I am talking about is a bit rich. I assume Priddis is in your starting midfield?

 

[Buzz/Sticks/bryce]

Priddis, A swallow and S Thompson are coming into consideration due to the bye structure. On a level playing field you would take the Ablett, Murphy, pendlebury, Swan combo first every time

 

[chiapants226]

hey guys, just did my draft supercoach team, be good to see what you guys think!

Backs
"Goddard, B" "Enright, C" "Suckling, M" "Selwood, A" "Dawson, Z" "Buntine, M" "Clarke, M" "Morris, S" "Wilkes, B"

Mids
"Ablett, G" "Fyfe, N" "Deledio, B" "Hayes, L" Ebert, Brad" "Coniglio, S" "Wingard, C" "Zorko, D"

Rucks
"Kreuzer, M" "Hale, D" "Giles, J" "Stephenson, O"

Forwards
"Franklin, L" "Pavlich, M" "Watts, J" "Brown, J" "Rohan, G" "Butcher, J" "Porplyzia, J" "Pfeiffer, D" "Rowe, S"

Remaining Salary Cap
$23,200

 

[_Gazza_]

hey guys, just did my draft supercoach team, be good to see what you guys think!

Backs
"Goddard, B" "Enright, C" "Suckling, M" "Selwood, A" "Dawson, Z" "Buntine, M" "Clarke, M" "Morris, S" "Wilkes, B"

Mids
"Ablett, G" "Fyfe, N" "Deledio, B" "Hayes, L" Ebert, Brad" "Coniglio, S" "Wingard, C" "Zorko, D"

Rucks
"Kreuzer, M" "Hale, D" "Giles, J" "Stephenson, O"

Forwards
"Franklin, L" "Pavlich, M" "Watts, J" "Brown, J" "Rohan, G" "Butcher, J" "Porplyzia, J" "Pfeiffer, D" "Rowe, S"

Remaining Salary Cap
$23,200

backs: first 3 good and rookies good as well. selwood often plays a tagging role which isnt suited to supercoach, i dont see him improving on his average this year. the same can be said for dawson, he's never scored that well and i dont see any way he can improve, there are better options

Mids: fyfe and delideo in mids is a mistake imo. they are more valuable in the fwd and def as it is harder to find consistant premiums in thee areas. essentially they are taking spots away from players like selwood, swan, murphy etc. without these players you will not perform to the level of other teams. btw i understand you have done this for the mpp option but imo this should be done with rookies and not the premiums

ruck: rookies good, kruezer is showing solid form in preseason so good choicd. hale however needs to go imo. with the return of roughhead hales role could change and hawks may not go with the three big men (roughead, bailey, hale)

forwards: imo i dont see watts getting enough big scores yet to justify selection. have a look at pav in the preseason games, you may find he's spending less time in the midfield under lyon. i would downgrade one of brown or porps and use the extra money to replace watts with another premium. a straight swap of pav with fyfe will give you the money to get a midfeild superstar in

hopes this helps you

 

[coryne]

Had a quick go at making a team, and ended up with


Backs. Goddard, Deledio, Shaw, Fisher, M Clarke, Ellis, Mohr
EMG Buntine, Morris

Centre. Pendlebury, Ablett, Gibbs, Montagna, K Stevens, Shiel
EMG Hampton, Mitchell

Rucks. Mumford, Kreuzer
EMG. Ceglar, Stephensen

Forwards. Franklin, Fyfe, Rioli, Martin, Zorko, Smedts, Treloar
EMG Saad, Rowe


It's all fairly rough, and will change 10 times before it is settled, but thats where I sit ATM ...............

 

[BlueGibbs2011]

Had a quick go at making a team, and ended up with


Backs. Goddard, Deledio, Shaw, Fisher, M Clarke, Ellis, Mohr
EMG Buntine, Morris

Centre. Pendlebury, Ablett, Gibbs, Montagna, K Stevens, Shiel
EMG Hampton, Mitchell

Rucks. Mumford, Kreuzer
EMG. Ceglar, Stephensen

Forwards. Franklin, Fyfe, Rioli, Martin, Zorko, Smedts, Treloar
EMG Saad, Rowe


It's all fairly rough, and will change 10 times before it is settled, but thats where I sit ATM ...............

Nice team Coryne. Gibbs/Montagna interesting PoD. If they fire to superpemium level which is not out of the question, your side will kill it.

No Yarran in defence - I'm shocked! He should pick up another 10+ point ave increase which puts him in fisher's league at a much cheaper price.

Your other three prem backs absolutely rock!

 

[GotTheGoodes]

And whoever picks right will have a big advantage. If Scott doesn't pick McIntosh to play in ROund 1 then Goldstein might be the way to go. Mumford is injury prone despite having the ability to post big scores...At least Sandi has put together a couple of full high scoring seasons and Lyon might have him fit and firing. McEvoy might be an option as he has little competition and started clunking those contested marks.

The SA lead rucks in Jacobs and whatshisface from Port might be sneaky second ruck choices.

I think if Sandi is fit for round 1 you go with him though...if he goes down then bite the bullet and trade

Ahhhh.... Huh? Suspension prone maybe...