Rate My Team for 2010

[Joshen]

Corey Enright
Andrew Embley
Sam Fisher
Luke Hodge
David Myers
Rick Ladson
Tadhg Kennelly

Phil Davis
Kyle Hardingham

Joel Selwood
Scott Pendlebury
Brent Prismall
Rhys Palmer
Tom Scully
Dustin Martin

Ryan Bastinac
Mitch Banner

Paddy Ryder
Matthew Kreuzer

Matthew Lobbe
Jackson Trengove

Brett Deledio
Jonathan Brown
Angus Monfries
Robbie Gray
Jack Ziebell
Jack Trengove
Ben Cunnington

Luke Tapscott
Scott Gumbleton

Just a quick fix on a few problems in my team. What do you guys think?

I think it looks pretty good.

If I were you and wanted to do something to help protect against doughnuts and trade out Embley and put Ryder in your backs. Replacing him in the rucks with Tippet (or someone like that). Which enables you (with the new positional change rule) to: in case of an injury in your rucks to swap the positions of Ryder and Trengrove meaning you cover that zero with Ryder and covering his absence in the backline with someone who would probably score more than Lobbe or Trengrove.

I hope that makes sense.

 

[anf06]

I think it looks pretty good.

If I were you and wanted to do something to help protect against doughnuts and trade out Embley and put Ryder in your backs. Replacing him in the rucks with Tippet (or someone like that). Which enables you (with the new positional change rule) to: in case of an injury in your rucks to swap the positions of Ryder and Trengrove meaning you cover that zero with Ryder and covering his absence in the backline with someone who would probably score more than Lobbe or Trengrove.

I hope that makes sense.

I know see the positional change's worth.
I probably have enough cash spare to keep Embley and upgrade Myers to Ryder if i were to do this...

This new rule will make me think some...
Cheers for that

 

[Wooju]

Backs
Goodwin
Carratzo
Hodge
Ellis
Ladson
Kennelly
either Myers/Buckley/Drum/J Hunt/Waters (all around same value)

Hardingham
Davis

Mids
Bartel
Pendelbury
Prismall
Green / C Morton
Palmer / Masten / Swift
D Martin

M Farmer
J Kayler-Thompson

Rucks
Sandilands
Kreuzer

Trengrove
Lobbe

Forwards
Delidio
Pavlich
B Harvey
A Walker
Dangerfield
Trengrove
Cunnington

Bastanic
Dennis-Lane

Thoughts?

I think the structure is fairly balanced, tried to go for premiums who have a history of durability (a couple had probs last year but historically i.e B Harvey they have played 20+ games per year). Prismall is only punt in this area. Taken risks on some lower valued players with injury probs, if some don't come off will be an upgrade anyways.

Tried to exploit value in lower priced defenders and on the cusp premium mids (Pendelbury / Prismall etc).

So far gone for mature aged rookies on bench as last couple of years has proved fruitful - but most bench positions could obviously change after NAB.

My estimate is 12 keepers with 4/5 potentials.

 

[Jonny27]

^^ Nice team, like the pick of Prismall.

 

[roodav]

Early side, tend to start with lots of North players and whittle them down to one or two.

Hodge
Shaw
Drummond
Ellis
Guerra
Scott D Thompson
Dempsey
Sheppard
Davis

Bartel
Pendlebury
Deledio
Wells
Scully
Martin
Blease
Bartlett

Jolly
Tippett
Trengove
Cordy

Pavlich
Harvey
Gray
Zeibell
Dangerfield
Wonnaeamirri
Trengove
Bastinac
R Tarrant

Rough outline anyway

 

[360noscope]

Early side, tend to start with lots of North players and whittle them down to one or two.

Hodge
Shaw
Drummond
Ellis
Guerra
Scott D Thompson
Dempsey
Sheppard
Davis

Bartel
Pendlebury
Deledio
Wells
Scully
Martin
Blease
Bartlett

Jolly
Tippett
Trengove
Cordy

Pavlich
Harvey
Gray
Zeibell
Dangerfield
Wonnaeamirri
Trengove
Bastinac
R Tarrant

Rough outline anyway

Apart from the seven players I highlighted your team looks OK

Drummond- Look, everyone has been burnt by this guy sometime. He may just pay off. But someone like Enright or Carrazzo are probably safer, more durable options

Guerra- Will play on the small forwards this year with Birchall and Ellis playing HBF, wing roles. Dont expect an average of much more than 70.

Scott D Thompson - He is the Roos full back whick for me pretty much means dont consider straight away but he does play a DT friendly role. But expect those scores of 40 or so every few weeks.

Deledio - Pick him in the forwards.

Blease - Hasn't got an AFL ready body and Melbourne will play Scully, Trengove and co before him you would think.

Woneamirri - isn't he injured. If not a nice cheap selection.

There's my 2 cents

 

[360noscope]

B BAC $417,100 22 89.7 22 86.9 96.5
Corey Enright
Andrew Carrazzo B BAC $395,800 14 85.1 21 93.9 103.1
Sam Fisher B BAC $394,700 21 84.9 22 90.0 84.9
Luke Hodge C/B BAC $388,000 19 83.5 17 96.4 97.2
David Myers B BAC $199,900 6 43.0 8 60.4 40.7
Rick Ladson C/B BAC $195,900 3 52.7 22 75.6 53.8
Tadhg Kennelly B BAC $183,800 0 20 65.9 50.3

Jimmy Bartel C CTR $508,000 21 109.3 22 113.2 109.4
Bryce Gibbs C CTR $497,200 22 107.0 21 87.3 101.9
Adam Cooney C CTR $419,800 20 90.3 22 92.4 99.9
Callan Ward C CTR $327,100 19 70.4 6 41.0 77.4
Rhys Palmer C CTR $293,800 5 79.0 20 87.5 65.5
Tom Scully C CTR $158,700 0 0 46.4

Kurt Tippett R/F RUC $337,900 22 72.7 18 43.1 68.4
David Hille R RUC $200,800 5 54.0 20 86.0 0.0

Matthew Pavlich C/F FWD $428,400 19 92.2 19 99.3 79.1
Shaun Higgins F/C FWD $411,500 17 88.5 4 47.8 84.5
Lance Franklin F FWD $375,400 21 80.8 22 96.5 103.1
Cyril Rioli F/C FWD $354,300 19 76.2 22 66.4 78.4
Jack Ziebell F/C FWD $302,200 10 65.0 0 56.4
Patrick Dangerfield C/F FWD $244,400 19 52.6 2 26.0 70.3
Trent Dennis-Lane F FWD $90,700 0 0 35.3

Matt Maguire B BAC $91,300 0 4 32.8 29.3
Phil Davis F/B BAC $90,700 0 0 39.1
Dustin Martin C CTR $150,700 0 0 44.2
Luke Shuey C CTR $90,700 0 0 46.4
Robert Warnock R RUC $128,000 0 9 45.9 25.6
Matthew Lobbe F/R RUC $90,700 0 0 38.1
Luke Tapscott F/C FWD $90,700 0 0 37.8
Scott Gumbleton F FWD $90,700 0 0 34.7

After Trengove, Walker and Cunnington have been named mids only I have had to edit my team a bit.

 

[WeninRome]

B BAC $417,100 22 89.7 22 86.9 96.5
Corey Enright
Andrew Carrazzo B BAC $395,800 14 85.1 21 93.9 103.1
Sam Fisher B BAC $394,700 21 84.9 22 90.0 84.9
Luke Hodge C/B BAC $388,000 19 83.5 17 96.4 97.2
David Myers B BAC $199,900 6 43.0 8 60.4 40.7
Rick Ladson C/B BAC $195,900 3 52.7 22 75.6 53.8
Tadhg Kennelly B BAC $183,800 0 20 65.9 50.3

Jimmy Bartel C CTR $508,000 21 109.3 22 113.2 109.4
Bryce Gibbs C CTR $497,200 22 107.0 21 87.3 101.9
Adam Cooney C CTR $419,800 20 90.3 22 92.4 99.9
Callan Ward C CTR $327,100 19 70.4 6 41.0 77.4
Rhys Palmer C CTR $293,800 5 79.0 20 87.5 65.5
Tom Scully C CTR $158,700 0 0 46.4

Kurt Tippett R/F RUC $337,900 22 72.7 18 43.1 68.4
David Hille R RUC $200,800 5 54.0 20 86.0 0.0

Matthew Pavlich C/F FWD $428,400 19 92.2 19 99.3 79.1
Shaun Higgins F/C FWD $411,500 17 88.5 4 47.8 84.5
Lance Franklin F FWD $375,400 21 80.8 22 96.5 103.1
Cyril Rioli F/C FWD $354,300 19 76.2 22 66.4 78.4
Jack Ziebell F/C FWD $302,200 10 65.0 0 56.4
Patrick Dangerfield C/F FWD $244,400 19 52.6 2 26.0 70.3
Trent Dennis-Lane F FWD $90,700 0 0 35.3

Matt Maguire B BAC $91,300 0 4 32.8 29.3
Phil Davis F/B BAC $90,700 0 0 39.1
Dustin Martin C CTR $150,700 0 0 44.2
Luke Shuey C CTR $90,700 0 0 46.4
Robert Warnock R RUC $128,000 0 9 45.9 25.6
Matthew Lobbe F/R RUC $90,700 0 0 38.1
Luke Tapscott F/C FWD $90,700 0 0 37.8
Scott Gumbleton F FWD $90,700 0 0 34.7

After Trengove, Walker and Cunnington have been named mids only I have had to edit my team a bit.

higgins, hille and gumby are massive injury ocncerns..dangerfield to some extent.

starting dennis lane? maybe a bit short there.

 

[jackoisno1]

who is everyone going to replace Trengove with?

 

[banana_hammock]

who is everyone going to replace Trengove with?

Well, he was on my field, so i had to upgrade him to Lindsay Thomas for the moment. And i put Davis and Gumby on the bench

 

[banana_hammock]

B BAC $417,100 22 89.7 22 86.9 96.5
Corey Enright
Andrew Carrazzo B BAC $395,800 14 85.1 21 93.9 103.1
Sam Fisher B BAC $394,700 21 84.9 22 90.0 84.9
Luke Hodge C/B BAC $388,000 19 83.5 17 96.4 97.2
David Myers B BAC $199,900 6 43.0 8 60.4 40.7
Rick Ladson C/B BAC $195,900 3 52.7 22 75.6 53.8
Tadhg Kennelly B BAC $183,800 0 20 65.9 50.3

Jimmy Bartel C CTR $508,000 21 109.3 22 113.2 109.4
Bryce Gibbs C CTR $497,200 22 107.0 21 87.3 101.9
Adam Cooney C CTR $419,800 20 90.3 22 92.4 99.9
Callan Ward C CTR $327,100 19 70.4 6 41.0 77.4
Rhys Palmer C CTR $293,800 5 79.0 20 87.5 65.5
Tom Scully C CTR $158,700 0 0 46.4

Kurt Tippett R/F RUC $337,900 22 72.7 18 43.1 68.4
David Hille R RUC $200,800 5 54.0 20 86.0 0.0

Matthew Pavlich C/F FWD $428,400 19 92.2 19 99.3 79.1
Shaun Higgins F/C FWD $411,500 17 88.5 4 47.8 84.5
Lance Franklin F FWD $375,400 21 80.8 22 96.5 103.1
Cyril Rioli F/C FWD $354,300 19 76.2 22 66.4 78.4
Jack Ziebell F/C FWD $302,200 10 65.0 0 56.4
Patrick Dangerfield C/F FWD $244,400 19 52.6 2 26.0 70.3
Trent Dennis-Lane F FWD $90,700 0 0 35.3

Matt Maguire B BAC $91,300 0 4 32.8 29.3
Phil Davis F/B BAC $90,700 0 0 39.1
Dustin Martin C CTR $150,700 0 0 44.2
Luke Shuey C CTR $90,700 0 0 46.4
Robert Warnock R RUC $128,000 0 9 45.9 25.6
Matthew Lobbe F/R RUC $90,700 0 0 38.1
Luke Tapscott F/C FWD $90,700 0 0 37.8
Scott Gumbleton F FWD $90,700 0 0 34.7

After Trengove, Walker and Cunnington have been named mids only I have had to edit my team a bit.

Not fussed that Myers did his hammy again?

Pretty good apart from that

 

[360noscope]

Only out for 3 weeks in the PS. If it gets any worse I could possibly trade him out.

 

[Clonkers]

All right heres the squad i just made, trying to be a little different(emphasis on trying).

Backs:
Enright
R.Shaw
Hodge
S. Selwood
Kennely
Ladson
Hunt(or anyone around that 200k area)

Subs: Davis, Davies

Mids:
Bartel
Pendlebury
C. Morton
Palmer
Trengove
Cunnington

Subs: Shuey, Banner

Rucks:
Sandi
Kreuzer

Subs: Lobbe, Sullivan

Forwards:
N. Riewoldt
Harvey
Franklin
Tippet
Ziebell
Danger
Vespremi

Subs: TDL, Taspcott

RED: Keeper Bit over 100k left over
Blue: Potential Keeper

Any criticism would be appreciated.

 

[banana_hammock]

Only out for 3 weeks in the PS. If it gets any worse I could possibly trade him out.

Fair call

 

[Ben the Gooner]

Only out for 3 weeks in the PS. If it gets any worse I could possibly trade him out.

What is this trading you speak of?

I thought your squad had to be finalised before it opens. At least, that's the way everyone's acting ATM.

 

[Jonny27]

All right heres the squad i just made, trying to be a little different(emphasis on trying).

Backs:
Enright
R.Shaw
Hodge
S. Selwood
Kennely
Ladson
Hunt(or anyone around that 200k area)

Subs: Davis, Davies

Mids:
Bartel
Pendlebury
C. Morton
Palmer
Trengove
Cunnington

Subs: Shuey, Banner

Rucks:
Sandi
Kreuzer

Subs: Lobbe, Sullivan

Forwards:
N. Riewoldt
Harvey
Franklin
Tippet
Ziebell
Danger
Vespremi

Subs: TDL, Taspcott

RED: Keeper Bit over 100k left over
Blue: Potential Keeper

Any criticism would be appreciated.

Nice team. Not interested in Martin though?

 

[Smashed Box]

Andrew Carrazzo
S, fisher
L,hodge
J,mc Donald
S, buckley
R,ladson
T,kenelly


G, ablett
R,palmer
M,mcveigh
C,young
J, trengrove
D,martin

Coxs
M,kreuzer

N,riewoldt
J,brown
B, Harvey
R,gray
R,douglas
J,ziebell
P,Dangerfield

Bench
A,smith
P,davis

J,bollenagen
R, harwood

M,lobbe
J,trengrove

S, rusling
R,tarrent

Frist one any help welcomed thank u

 

[Smashed Box]

Andrew Carrazzo
S, fisher
L,hodge
J,mc Donald
S, buckley
R,ladson
T,kenelly


G, ablett
R,palmer
M,mcveigh
C,young
J, trengrove
D,martin

Coxs
M,kreuzer

N,riewoldt
J,brown
B, Harvey
R,gray
R,douglas
J,ziebell
P,Dangerfield

Bench
A,smith
P,davis

J,bollenagen
R, harwood

M,lobbe
J,trengrove

S, rusling
R,tarrent

Frist one any help welcomed thank u

 

[happy_eagle]

Andrew Carrazzo
S, fisher
L,hodge
J,mc Donald
S, buckley
R,ladson
T,kenelly


G, ablett
R,palmer
M,mcveigh
C,young
J, trengrove
D,martin

Coxs
M,kreuzer

N,riewoldt
J,brown
B, Harvey
R,gray
R,douglas
J,ziebell
P,Dangerfield

Bench
A,smith
P,davis

J,bollenagen
R, harwood

M,lobbe
J,trengrove

S, rusling
R,tarrent

Frist one any help welcomed thank u

 

[Hirdy_5]

Mark Mcveigh is suspended for the first 2 games IIRC.

 

[WeninRome]

my updated team following position changes

Enright
Carrazzo
Hodge
Ladson
Waters
Hunt
Kennelly

Davis
Smith

Swan
Selwood
Green
Swift
Trengove
Martin

Shuey
Cunnington

Sandilands
Kreuz

Lobbe
Trengove

Brown
Buddy
Pav
Dangerfield
Douglas
Gray
Polkinghorne

Tapscott
Dennis lane.

 

[bombers own]

First crack, looking like another midpriced team this year

B; Carazzo, Fisher, Hodge, Ellis, Myers, Waters, Ladson (Hardingham, Maguire)
C; Swan, Bartel, Vince, Young, Trengove, Martin (Shuey, Blease)
R; Brennan, Kreuzer (Lobbe, Trengove)
F; Brown, Franklin, Rioli, Lecras, Gray, Dangerfield, Veszpremi (Gumby, Johnstone)

- Nine definite premiums
- Five that i'm 95% sure will be at least keepers, barring injury
- Six lower/bargain picks, would be happy if say 2 became lower end keepers
- Two more expensive rookies who should score reasonably well
- 90k reserves, whoever i think is most likely to play at the time

Also ive been away for a while, so if anyones injured/shouldnt be picked for whatever reason, let us know

 

[Virgil]

First crack, looking like another midpriced team this year

B; Carazzo, Fisher, Hodge, Ellis, Myers, Waters, Ladson (Hardingham, Maguire)
C; Swan, Bartel, Vince, Young, Trengove, Martin (Shuey, Blease)
R; Brennan, Kreuzer (Lobbe, Trengove)
F; Brown, Franklin, Rioli, Lecras, Gray, Dangerfield, Veszpremi (Gumby, Johnstone)

- Nine definite premiums
- Five that i'm 95% sure will be at least keepers, barring injury
- Six lower/bargain picks, would be happy if say 2 became lower end keepers
- Two more expensive rookies who should score reasonably well
- 90k reserves, whoever i think is most likely to play at the time

Also ive been away for a while, so if anyones injured/shouldnt be picked for whatever reason, let us know

Myers has recently done a hammy. I think he might be touch and go for the first NAB cup game at this stage.

Young has done very little of the pre-season from what I understand, and may not be available come the start of the season. I'm not entirely sure about Waters but I think he has had a similarly-interrupted pre-season.

LeCras will be played as a forward this season and not as a midfielder like most of us had hoped for, though he may still be a pretty good pick anyway.

 

[bombers own]

Myers has recently done a hammy. I think he might be touch and go for the first NAB cup game at this stage.

Young has done very little of the pre-season from what I understand, and may not be available come the start of the season. I'm not entirely sure about Waters but I think he has had a similarly-interrupted pre-season.

LeCras will be played as a forward this season and not as a midfielder like most of us had hoped for, though he may still be a pretty good pick anyway.

OK thanks heaps

 

[pauldrc]

Sorry in advance if this question has already been raised and answered....

Is it better to spend all your $$$$ on the best team you can, or keep say 100K plus or minus for your first trades/upgrades??