Riewoldt or Brown

[Stoddy]

i fear jonathan brown

when he is on, he cannot be stopped

i remember he kicked a bag on scarlett a few years ago in a team that got smashed

riewoldt can take all the marks on the wing that he wants, but he's not the type who will win a game off his own boot

brown can and does

that is why he is better

LOL what? i think your thinking of jack not nick riewoldt

not that i can split johno and nick but that statements wrong

 

[LET ME TALK]

This thread is silly... its like debating who won the game while the game is still on! that's IF we are talking career stats.

If we are talking pure football skill?? Brown by the length of the MCG

Thats not going to change.

I admire Browns Skill, Courage and Stature and Leaderhsip.
I admire Riewoldts Courage, athleticism and work ethic.

I wish Riewoldt wouldnt cry on camera... but he is a great captain IMO as good as any to say otherwise is silly.

Just enjoy browns great old school skill, and enjoy Riewoldts work ethic and courage. basically.

 

[Grimreepah]

Don't get me wrong, Brown is a great player, but he's gone missing quite a bit over his career.

When has Brown gone missing?

 

[Pessimistic]

CH 10 had reiwoldt in their "all time" greatest list last night

WHAT A JOKE

How can roo be compared with CHFs in earlier eras because ********s like him simply didnt cut it back then. I reckon Nick holland would be his equal with similar umpiring interpretations

 

[salty parish]

how is that relevant u 'peanut'. Riewoldt has ripped us apart many times also

it is relevant, re-read your original post.You claim Brown has had only 2 good games whereas Riewoldt has been dominating for years!

I would say they both have been dominating for years and you are talking shite about Brown, therefore, you are being a "peanut".

 

[Ricmel]

CH 10 had reiwoldt in their "all time" greatest list last night

Who else was on the list? Who chose it?