- Banned
- #1
Who is better right now and who will end up the better player?
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Rioli or Selwood?
- Thread starter Hodgepodge
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Copulator
Club Legend
Might've been a good idea to attach a poll.
Selwood now... and possibly forever... but Cyril can do things on the footy field that nobody else can. He is an amazing mix of Freaky skills and amazing balance and athletic ability.
- Thread starter
- Banned
- #6
Selwood now, Rioli will end up the better player imo.
Turbo Abe
Debutant
That is a silly comment from a Carlton supporter. Rioli is every bit as talented as Murphy and Gibbs - and unlike them - is a proven big game player. But I am happy to admit either of them may end up better players.
You shouldn't make such early predictions of such amazing talents...
- Jul 11, 2007
- 10,821
- 82
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
Had a feeling the OP would be humbled by the poll from neutral supporters.
Selwood now, and Selwood in the future.
That's taking nothing away from Rioli though who is a gun for his age, and will continue to be a gun in the future.
Selwood now, and Selwood in the future.
That's taking nothing away from Rioli though who is a gun for his age, and will continue to be a gun in the future.
00Stinger
100 - 7
Dude why do you even waste your time with this stupid poll.
Selwood by an absolute mile
Selwood by an absolute mile
- Sep 22, 2000
- 62,351
- 41,703
- AFL Club
- Geelong
- Other Teams
- Ford
Did you bother reading the options before trolling ?
fishbowl is asking for a prediction you dill.
Level_Headed
Team Captain
Selwood now and Selwood at the end.
Rioli is a freak for sure but i think he will lack the overall consistency of Selwood.
Rioli is a freak for sure but i think he will lack the overall consistency of Selwood.
Selwood by the length of 100 nebulas. And he will end up the better player to. He in my opinion is the next Chris Judd. Rioli, hmmm he shows flashes of brilliance but his consistency is something that he lacks unlike Selwood.
Firstly I think Selwood now however as he has a year on Junior what the future holds could be anything. Probably Selwood but would easily go the other way.
Secondly Have you even watched any of the Hawthorn games recently? Junior is Hawks most consistent player at the moment and is improving dramatically with every game he plays.
selwood by a country mile, now and forever, doesnt mean riolis not gonna be a great player, but selwood will definatly have a brownlow before his careers over, dont know if you can say that about ciril
- Banned
- #18
Watch Cotchin...
Goedy
Club Legend
How can anyone even think Rioli is better than Selwood now or ever, they should never be mentioned in the same sentence.
That would be an interesting comparison, Cotchin vs Selwood. IMO Cotchin would destroy Selwood. That guy is just a class above in a very average team in his first year. Selwood on the other hand is just another great player in a team full of stars.
My prediction:
Selwood, e a s i l y.
Selwood, e a s i l y.
Rioli is obviously a blue-chip talent, but it's impossible to go past Selwood. He's already verging on champion status -- though playing in the Geelong midfield doesn't hurt.
- Thread starter
- Banned
- #23
Hardly making shit up as I go along. Just quoting Herne Hill Hammer, a Geelong forumite.
- Thread starter
- Banned
- #24
Nobody accelerates or tackles like Cyril.
Taking a one-handed overhead grab. Haven't seen that for a while.
And then there's stuff like this
[youtube]Khh9zOM3hC4[/youtube]
It's not even like he's a flashy inconsistent player either, he's probably leading our BnF count at the moment.
Wow...what a huge achievement, right there!
Similar threads
