Round 17 Trades

Remove this Banner Ad

Mar 17, 2005
3,486
3,298
Perth
AFL Club
Fremantle
Other Teams
Rockets
Thinking of going Barlow -> Jobe this week.

Barlow plays GWS, Essendon have a tough run home and it's a complete luxury trade, but I can live with having 6 trades left. Probably end up reversing it though, have a whole week to ponder it. Barlow just seems to have gone backwards in the last couple of weeks.

Scott Thompson is also a tasty alternative... Though he'll almost certainly get the Crowley tag in first week of finals and he couldn't handle it last time.
 
Is anyone thinking of Marc Murphy? 400k and only one bad score of 68 or so with an injury effected score pulling him down. Can anyone confirm his break even - looks to be around 170? Could be even more attractive next week. With Judd set to miss a few weeks I reckon this looks like a winner. I'm thinking of straight swapping him for Masten this week or next, depending on whether I think I can win this league game with Masten.

I'm also still considering Hargrave for Yarran... Hargrave shouldn't play another game but if he holds his spot it may be a wasted trade. Yarran is still reasonable value.
 
Is anyone thinking of Marc Murphy? 400k and only one bad score of 68 or so with an injury effected score pulling him down. Can anyone confirm his break even - looks to be around 170? Could be even more attractive next week. With Judd set to miss a few weeks I reckon this looks like a winner. I'm thinking of straight swapping him for Masten this week or next, depending on whether I think I can win this league game with Masten.

B/E 144, predicted to be $380k next week if he scores his projected 79, but realistically should drop to just under $400k....
 

Log in to remove this ad.

got 2 trades left and still not sure if a should trade waters.
i got darley and shaw cover, and the other defenders don't really interest me. Before this weekend i was contemplating MJ or Suckling, but now very reluctant. i think i will trade him to avoid a zero, but if i have cover, i will leave him on the pine
 
no trades this week unless james mcdonald is back or aaron hall gets another game then will prob downgrade to tom couch.
if giles doesnt play then will upgrade him to maric.

if so, fielded team will look like....

deledio - suckling - scotland - carazzo - birchall - goddard - h. shaw (spurr, townsend)
boyd - thompson - ablett - swan - pendlebury - hayes (couch - gibson)
cox - maric (orren - campbell)
sidebottom - beams - robinson - dangerfield - cyril - taylor adams (buddy - hall)

would be pretty happy with that side with 6 trades left,
only possibly upgrades would be hayes and cyril
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Rd17
Franklin > Murphy (will move Beams from mids to forward line)
Ziebell > Pendlebury

Will leave me with not much money & 2 trades left.
 
No trades this week only got 3 left so gonna hang onto them for abit. I saw on the news there was good news for beau waters injury but didnt hear it. Did anyone else see it on channel 10
 
tossing up whether i should do hargrave to jack grimes or goddard for my 6th. thinking grimes this week then in a couple of weeks goddard when he drops a little bit more cash. but wow there arent many defence options at the moment
 
just heard also tht marics carrying a groin and should play but will probably not train for the rest of the year. Its got me a bit worried with only 3 trades left. Richmond should have a chance to play finals so i dont think they will rest him again but hopefully it doesnt get worse.
 
tossing up whether i should do hargrave to jack grimes or goddard for my 6th. thinking grimes this week then in a couple of weeks goddard when he drops a little bit more cash. but wow there arent many defence options at the moment
goddard is the much safer option as most team have him, so even if he produces a really poor score, everyone is dt is going down with that ship. Also i never like trading in players near the end of the season whose respective team has not chance in making the 8. THEY DO SOME CRAZY THINGS!!!. Much safer to go god.
But if you are sitting in the 9k overall, then why not make it interesting and trade in grimes. You are not going to move up the rankings by doing what everyone is doing/done. Grimes is in good form, and if you can afford to take the punt then do it.
Side note: grimes is very injury prone and if he picks up a niggle, melbourne may shut him down for the year.
 
Really appreciate any advice on my situation.

My team as it stands

BAC: Deledio, Hanley, Birchall, Heppell, Carrazzo, Yarran & Fisher (Spurr & Tynan)
CTR: Boyd, Thompson, Mitchell, Redden, Selwood & Pendlebury (Goddard & Gibson)
RUC: Cox & Roughead (Giles & Stephenson)
FWD: Sidebottom, Robinson, Lewis, Cloke, Martin, Zorko & Sylvia (Franklin & Pattinson)

Trades left: 6
Cash Remaining: $67,600

Now the plan was to next week trade in Dangerfield & Couch for Spurr & Gibson to finish my team.

However is it worth trading Stephenson to a spud and picking up Beams instead?
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Round 17 Trades

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top