Trades Round 2 Trades

[VSTone]

I'm in a tricky position, have Perryman I have to get rid of so unsure whether to upgrade or downgrade him. Trying my hardest to resist doing Brayshaw > Rockliff as I seriously love Brayshaw as a fantasy player. But then I want Rocky pretty badly... dilemma.

I'm downgrading Perryman to Markov but Cumming might come in also as another option i'd consider.

 

[Sixpence]

I've nailed round 1 for on field players (except Dunks/Ruck) but the bench i did not.

Which option is better:

Option 1: Scrimshaw (bench) to Wilkie and Gibbons (bench) to Constable
Option 2: Scrimshaw (bench via dpp) to Schultz and Balta (bench) to Petruccelle

Option 1 brings in potentially more cash, Option 2 solves the Balta problem

TIA

Scrimshaw > Wilkie and Balta > Schultz is what I've done. Atm

Scrimshaw to Wilkie is an odd trade. Unless you're desperate for the 20k price difference.

Reckon Scrimshaw's potential is higher.

 

[Gunf]

What are peoples thoughts regarding Rozee,Taylor,Balard and Powell

 

[bebji]

I'm downgrading Perryman to Markov but Cumming might come in also as another option i'd consider.

I wanted to go Perryman --> Markov and Balta --> Worpel but fell 9k short... wish I could take a small loan for a week to make up the difference.

Now thinking Billings --> Worpel and Perryman --> Newman and deal with Balta next week. Thoughts??

 

[Neale4brownlow]

I wanted to go Perryman --> Markov and Balta --> Worpel but fell 9k short... wish I could take a small loan for a week to make up the difference.

Now thinking Billings --> Worpel and Perryman --> Newman and deal with Balta next week. Thoughts??

Unless Perryman is 100% out this week I'd stick by him. He was going ok till he was KOed.

 

[VSTone]

Unless Perryman is 100% out this week I'd stick by him. He was going ok till he was KOed.

punctured lung and out for a couple is my understanding.

 

[Aussie_boy]

Unless Perryman is 100% out this week I'd stick by him. He was going ok till he was KOed.

The chances of him playing are pretty low I’d say. Listed on the GWS site as TBC with a ‘lung’.

 

[Quazza]

Hope we send Ed Curnow straight to Rocky this week......

 

[Aussie_boy]

Hope we send Ed Curnow straight to Rocky this week......

We need to crowdfund 5k or something to send to Bolton to say something similar in his press conference. At least then it would’ve scared people off if he goes big again.

 

[JDWCE]

Hope we send Ed Curnow straight to Rocky this week......

Or does he go to Boak?

 

[JDWCE]

Unless Perryman is 100% out this week I'd stick by him. He was going ok till he was KOed.

Punctured lung. May be a juicy down grade option once he comes back though!

 

[androidtommy]

I think i'm fixing rookies this week. Balta to Schultz and Collins to Wilkie
Other option would be something like Zerret out to someone, but I don't want to write him off yet

 

[VSTone]

Punctured lung. May be a juicy down grade option once he comes back though!

Bingo.

 

[Neale4brownlow]

Punctured lung. May be a juicy down grade option once he comes back though!

Will probably drop in price too for atleast his first week back.

 

[Spider Klein]

Not a biggie, but Dane Swan is the original pig

We are forgetting Joel Bowden.

 

[C_Turn]

Keeping it simple, planned trades so far (subject to teams) and i'm sure i won't be the only one

Balta - Parker
Collins - Wilkie

Then only stuck with Burgess in my fwd line in terms of rookies spudding it up (for now)

 

[Yellow Feathers]

We are forgetting Joel Bowden.

Sir, you're forgetting the OG pig. Captain Dunstall vs Richmond in 1992 was a Fantasy masterstroke.

 

[PAFC27]

Scrimshaw to Wilkie is an odd trade. Unless you're desperate for the 20k price difference.

Reckon Scrimshaw's potential is higher.

Probably but if both Wilkie and Schultz are named then it's what has to be done to get Balta out. Really didn't like the look of Scrim when watching the game, either

 

[Spider Klein]

Sir, you're forgetting the OG pig. Captain Dunstall vs Richmond in 1992 was a Fantasy masterstroke.

Agreed, But I feel Bowden was the first to acknowledge fantasy and the chip +6 publicly and become a fantasy know Pig.

Dunstall was an amazing player and had big games cos he was good not necessarily because he pigged out on chips to the pocket.

The reason I don't consider Ablett a pig. He was just awesome and scored well accordingly.

Just my opinion on the pig title.

 

[JDWCE]

Agreed, But I feel Bowden was the first to acknowledge fantasy and the chip +6 publicly and become a fantasy know Pig.

Dunstall was an amazing player and had big games cos he was good not necessarily because he pigged out on chips to the pocket.

The reason I don't consider Ablett a pig. He was just awesome and scored well accordingly.

Just my opinion on the pig title.

Ablett was the little master

 

[Coasters7]

Just fixed my rookies this week
Balta >> Parker
Burgees >> Wilkie

Scored 2252 with a few of my premos under preforming. As much as I wanted to trade Billing’s > Kelly/Boak, I originally picked Billing’s for a reason so gonna keep him for a bit longer. Also going to watch closely to see if Heeney will play that deep forward role, if so, seeya later.
Very surprised to see people already trading Cripps and Brayshaw out etc.

Think a lot of people are only jumping off those two because they realised they made a mistake with structure. Also they’ll both stay relatively the same price for the short term while there’s undeniable value in Rocky/Worpel/Mid rooks. Don’t really want to be taking a gamble that there will be breakout players or high scoring rookies popping up mid season so grab them now. That’s my point of view at least.. Constable and Worpel/Newnes/Rocky on field is better than Brayshaw and Parker.. especially if the one you pick becomes a keeper. In saying that though.. my plan last week was to save cash to fix rookies so I’m trying to stay strong on that and sideways the spuds to the good looking ones. If I miss Worpel so be it.

 

[Jozzy]

There’s three blokes I really want Rocky, Worpel & Treloar.

I’m pretty set on trading out Dustin Martin for Tom Rockliff.

I just cannot work out what to do with the second trade.

Higgins -> Worpel OR Brayshaw to Treloar.

If love to know what people would think is the better trade??

 

[happy_eagle]

Asked this yesterday, still toying over it. Merrett and Balta are gone this week to either

Taranto and Schultz/Markov
or
Sheed and J.Clark

Which one ?

 

[PAFC27]

Asked this yesterday, still toying over it. Merrett and Balta are gone this week to either

Taranto and Schultz/Markov
or
Sheed and J.Clark

Which one ?

Flip a coin. Can't go wrong

Option 1 for me, just

 

[Atavistic]

There’s three blokes I really want Rocky, Worpel & Treloar.

I’m pretty set on trading out Dustin Martin for Tom Rockliff.

I just cannot work out what to do with the second trade.

Higgins -> Worpel OR Brayshaw to Treloar.

If love to know what people would think is the better trade??

Higgins to Worp IMO.