Trades Round 2 Trades

[Dupogi]

Lockhart vs Wilkie?

 

[Saints2001]

Dang, moved Balta out for Schultz...after his showing last week I figured he wouldn't be back for a while ha. If it is Brouch out, that would be great, would make my move to Rocky a lock (got $300k in the bank for the moment).

 

[redrex94]

late changes announced 90 mins prior to game start

Thanks mate.

Assuming the worst and B Crouch doesn't play, are people going to keep him and play someone like (as much as it pains me to say) Gibbons, Atkins etc or do you think trades will happen?

And we wait...

 

[VSTone]

Thanks mate.

Assuming the worst and B Crouch doesn't play, are people going to keep him and play someone like (as much as it pains me to say) Gibbons, Atkins etc or do you think trades will happen?

And we wait...

Make that decision when the time comes.

 

[lmach]

Hmm, not sure you want to dump either of those. Who else is in your midfield?

My midfield is currently Coniglio, Cripps, Brayshaw, Sheed, Rockliff, B.Crouch, Liberatore, Walsh.

Cripps, Brayshaw or Cogs are the only ones I can trade to generate enough cash for Lloyd and I’m not trading Cogs.

My theory is I would rather Lloyd + Scott instead of Cripps/Brayshaw + Scrimshaw.

 

[Dupogi]

Thanks mate.

Assuming the worst and B Crouch doesn't play, are people going to keep him and play someone like (as much as it pains me to say) Gibbons, Atkins etc or do you think trades will happen?

And we wait...

If its a hammy would be thinking more than 1 week with his injury history?

 

[Ohh Ok]

Thanks mate.

Assuming the worst and B Crouch doesn't play, are people going to keep him and play someone like (as much as it pains me to say) Gibbons, Atkins etc or do you think trades will happen?

And we wait...

I’m thinking if it’s Brouch they’ll be extra cautious, especially at this point in the season. Would be hoping he’s back next week, and holding. More people jumping off brings his ownership down, but will have to wait and see. I’d like to know if it was 100% an out confirmed on the radio. You’d think we’d know by now who it was if they were out, makes me think they are still making up their minds

Edit: either that or they’re trying to not let too much into sydney

 

[Trav 20]

Well looks like I'll have to trade out Markov next week, what a waste of a trade that was.

Yes, I had the misfortune of inviting Oleg into my team. One of the softest players I think I've seen. I hope my round can recover.

Higgins was the cherry on top.

That said, I have $368K in the kitty to make a couple of corrections over the next two rounds and I had a decent round 1.

 

[Aussie_boy]

Yes, I had the misfortune of inviting Oleg into my team. One of the softest players I think I've seen. I hope my round can recover.

Higgins was the cherry on top.

That said, I have $368K in the kitty to make a couple of corrections over the next two rounds and I had a decent round 1.

Similar boat to me then, unless B Crouch is a late out where I’ll can him rather than Brayshaw. At least Balta will be back in, one positive.

 

[Trav 20]

Similar boat to me then, unless B Crouch is a late out where I’ll can him rather than Brayshaw. At least Balta will be back in, one positive.

I have Crouch also, as well as his Brother, but I also have Scott as an emergency. If it is Brad I think I'll leave him on the bench this week and make a decision before round 3.

 

[Sixpence]

My midfield is currently Coniglio, Cripps, Brayshaw, Sheed, Rockliff, B.Crouch, Liberatore, Walsh.

Cripps, Brayshaw or Cogs are the only ones I can trade to generate enough cash for Lloyd and I’m not trading Cogs.

My theory is I would rather Lloyd + Scott instead of Cripps/Brayshaw + Scrimshaw.

Lloyd and Scott is probably better for team balance. Problem is both Cripps and Brayshaw could go large. Maybe Brayshaw if I had to pick one of the two to trade?

 

[guero]

Thanks mate.

Assuming the worst and B Crouch doesn't play, are people going to keep him and play someone like (as much as it pains me to say) Gibbons, Atkins etc or do you think trades will happen?

And we wait...

If it’s one of the Crouches I’ll reverse my Libba to Rocky trade and trade the hamstrung offender instead. I’m not interested in ****ing around with injured players so early in the season

 

[VSTone]

If it’s one of the Crouches I’ll reverse my Libba to Rocky trade and trade the hamstrung offender instead. I’m not interested in ******* around with injured players so early in the season

more likely to be Gibbs - "Groin soreness" read on supercoach forum injuries & suspensions, good chance of Balta getting a gig again with JRoo out for a bit now.

 

[amazingjoshy]

Thanks mate.

Assuming the worst and B Crouch doesn't play, are people going to keep him and play someone like (as much as it pains me to say) Gibbons, Atkins etc or do you think trades will happen?

And we wait...

I'll trade if its him. With his injury history could quite easily turn into much longer.

Either down to Constable (who I missed) or sideways to Sheed. Just means I have to keep Hore for a week

 

[Coasters7]

Thanks mate.

Assuming the worst and B Crouch doesn't play, are people going to keep him and play someone like (as much as it pains me to say) Gibbons, Atkins etc or do you think trades will happen?

And we wait...

Reckon you have to keep him for this week at least (depends how long he’s out for obviously) and sort it out next week. Everyone’s going to be in the same boat so it’s a matter of if you’re going to be playing Constable/Gibbons/Atkins.. Constable on my bench atm so he’ll come straight in for a week, and if Crouch is out for multiple I guess I’ll just swap him out next week, Scully and Adams the possible targets.

 

[kozi]

Currently gone McCarthy > Worpel but considering Powell + 200k instead. Worp could very well be top 6 but having funds to upgrade Z Williams next week could be a great way to get ahead. Inside top 1k and keen to hold, which way should I go?

 

[Spider Klein]

This could be the only week the trades thread is relevant. After last nights game the trades thread should just be titled.

'Which Collingwood player are you bringing in for +6s?'

 

[Mordecai]

Just curious what others would do here.

I'm thinking atkins to constable and collins to wilkie.

 

[staffa002]

A few guys on twitter saying its gibbs thats out and not brouch. We can breathe a little easier now.

 

[Coasters7]

Yes, I had the misfortune of inviting Oleg into my team. One of the softest players I think I've seen. I hope my round can recover.

Higgins was the cherry on top.

That said, I have $368K in the kitty to make a couple of corrections over the next two rounds and I had a decent round 1.

Is there a point where you put a never again line through an entire club? Because Richmond is fast becoming that side for me haha. Between Balta, Higgins, Markov and Dusty, I’ve seen enough over 2 rounds not to ever pick a rookie, mid pricer or premo from them no matter how much they get talked up

 

[staffa002]

This could be the only week the trades thread is relevant. After last nights game the trades thread should just be titled.

'Which Collingwood player are you bringing in for +6s?'

They r playing tye eagles next week and they wont allow them to do that. Best just to wait after that game then get them in.

 

[Spider Klein]

View attachment 644015

Just curious what others would do here.

I'm thinking atkins to constable and collins to wilkie.

Team looks good,

I would

Hore > Lockhart/Wilkie
Atkins/Butters > Constable

Unless you are trying to chase Rockliff

 

[Bobby Sands]

Will Schultz play?

 

[Mordecai]

Team looks good,

I would

Hore > Lockhart/Wilkie
Atkins/Butters > Constable

Unless you are trying to chase Rockliff

Would love to go hore to wilkie and atkins to constable. don't have the cash. butters was alright i thought but that might be a good idea..... thank you.

hore--> wilkie.
butters--> constable.

keep atkins and collins.

 

[VSTone]

Will Schultz play?

we'll know soon enough