Preview Round 3 v Sydney MCG Sunday March 31st 4pm

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

Let's just hope if when we do get our first win under ooze we continue winning and gain confidence just like GWS did last year.
would be on 2 wins now if not for umpires
 
Also Dimma lost 10 in a row. As long as we win before then, we are in front.
Dimma's team early on got smashed by a lot of teams but we saw improvement,especially the tackling.

Tackling,the one thing the umps rort us with like a fine tooth comb and Weazle Whateley made "state of the game" comments about.

But it's fine if Tom Stewart KO's a player into next Sunday.
 
Also Dimma lost 10 in a row. As long as we win before then, we are in front.
Dimma had Dusty and Cotchin and Riewoldt and Rance at his disposal for the future.
****en mods
 
This week we front up against a red hot Sydney side who are sitting top 2 on the ladder with a 3-0 record and have looked mighty impressive this year in all their games. They come into the game with a midfield brigade that is firing on all cylinders, their back line is playing well conceding less than 80 points a game, while they score over 100 a game on average. Of all our games so far this will be our toughest test.

On Sunday against Port, we played well enough to hang with Port for about 2.5 quarters, where they had a surge at the start of the 3rd and then again in the last to firstly rundown a 2 goal lead and to then open up a 5 goal lead that they comfortably held until the final siren.

This week we should be strengthened by the returns of Broad & Young to the back line, however Hopper will be missing again, so it will be interesting to see just how we go with team selection for this week. Last week we gave opportunities to a few more kids and for the most part they all played well. The exceptions being Banks who was subbed out again and Dow who has struggled to deliver on preseason promise so far. Both could make way for the returns of Broad and Young with some shuffling of the team to perhaps move say Daniel and Short up the ground to get them more involved around the play.

However, what I'd prefer is we drop a couple of under performing senior players in Grimes and McIntosh with Broad and Young coming in to replace them. I'd also like to see McAuliffe and Sonsie brought in to reward their good form through the summer and keep putting development into the next generation of talent.

Out: Grimes McIntosh Dow Banks Lefau
In: Broad Young Sonsie McAuliffe M.Rioli

B: Broad Miller Young
HB: Trezise Vlastuin Brown
C: D.Rioli Taranto Short
HF: Campbell Bolton Mansell
F: Balta Martin Lynch
R: Nankervis Ross Baker
INT: Pickett M.Rioli McAuliffe Sonsie Clarke

With this side I feel we address some areas of concern. Firstly the move of Short and Daniel to the wings, gives us outside options with pace and skill to aid in our desire to play with quick ball movement through the middle of the ground. We've been winning or at least breaking even at clearances, but we seem to be missing that outside speed away from the contest to really open the game up. Getting that up and going, will only aid our forward line to function better as we'd be getting the ball into Lynch & Balta quicker allowing them to compete more 1-1 than in pack situations.

Down back we're quite sound with Miller and Young to take on the Swans key forwards in McDonald and Amartey, while Broad Vlastuin Brown and Trezise are all quite good intercept players who can work together to help Miller and Young in the air, while also being good enough at ground level to use the footy well coming out of D50. Short and Rioli being on the wings, can also push back to give us that run and carry rebound from D50 as well.

Up forward we look dangerous with Lynch and Balta as the marking options, while Martin and Bolton can do damage at ground level or in the air. Campbell is playing solid footy so far this year and gets himself in position to hit the scoreboard, while Mansell & Maurice both provide pressure defensively, while also being threats when the ball hits the ground. As I said above if we can get the ball in their quickly before the Swans back line get set up defensively we could certainly cause them some problems.

In the midfield we're going to have Nankervis going up against Grundy whose form has been a bit up and down, he's played well at the SCG, but struggled a bit in his game at the MCG albeit against his former team in Collingwood, who'd have known how to best combat him. Where we really need to step up is against the Swans midfielders in Heeney Warner & Gulden who have been great to start the season. With a relatively young and inexperienced group of Taranto Ross Baker starting we're going to need to be right on our game to stop them from getting off to a fast start. It may even be worth starting Taranto Martin & Bolton in the middle to try and set the time and then rotate the kids through later in the quarter when a bit of the sting has gone out. Last thing we want to see happen is another first half like the Suns game where our midfield could do a thing to stop the Suns

As far as the game goes I don't see us winning this one, in fact even the most one eyed supporter would concede we're up against it this week. What we should be focusing on is ensuring that we're bringing the same effort and intensity that we did against Carlton and in the first half last week, but hopefully we can do so for a bit longer than a half. It's all about the long term goals rather than short term success and while a win would be a great reward for the last couple of weeks, it would seem unlikely.

Verdict: Swans to cruise a 4-6 goal win
Would love to see that side,
but for Cumberland over MRJ. Cumberland's pressure was very good in the VFL as was his all-round game, including kicking goals and goal assists, something MRJ doesn't do. Besides the Swans kick the ball very short and well, so Rioli's chasing the ball round won't be much use.

I would be very surprised if there was no Grimes, especially with such a young backline. Perhaps Broad might not get up, one week calf issues are pretty rare.

Short and Dan Rioli on the wings would be exciting, and I think it would help guard against the Swans neat kicking game as both are experienced readers of the play and quick enough to add pressure, and very dangerous if they turn the ball over. If the backline is under too much pressure, Trezise could swap on the wing.

Pickett for sub. Let Clarke have a real crack.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

all comes down to sydney kicking straight.. Papley will have a day out!!!
this could be a hiding in the making
bring Sonsie and MCauliffe in
and prepare to be reamed by the ump's once again (who will be cheering for a richmond hiding)
 
Has he put on a bit more muscle as he was easily out contested in marks last year. His deficiency is he’s hopeless one on one and likes to play the loose man in the BL.
Maybe so but when you get as many injuries as we do sometimes you don't have a choice but throw these kids in to help us out, anyway he doesn't look any better or worse that tyler young to me
 
Maybe so but when you get as many injuries as we do sometimes you don't have a choice but throw these kids in to help us out, anyway he doesn't look any better or worse that tyler young to me
You’re probably right with the replacements, but look at LeFau he was way off the mark. Then Kosi who’s been in the system for awhile now. You don’t want to end up with a forest full of dead trees.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Preview Round 3 v Sydney MCG Sunday March 31st 4pm

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top