MVP Round 6 Votes v Collingwood

[KO_KO]

5. LeCras
4. Lycett
3. NicNat
2. Shuey
1. Hill / Redden

 

[Dark Sharks]

5. Naitanui
4. Lycett
3. McGovern
2. Shuey
1. Lecras

Going to need to watch Reddens game again, i thought he was solid without being spectacular. Gave off some handballs just for the sake of handballing at times when he should have put it on the boot. Don't think he dominated by any stretch of the imagination.

 

[boondy]

Watching the stoppages on replay Redden is never the go to for the tap . He negates then very quickly sensing eagles have possession spreads to be pro active .

 

[wce4premiership]

Yeah well those people probably frequent the WCE Facebook page. After watching the game last night Jetta was hardly useless. Was quiet through the second and third but he was hardly an only child there. Agreed he needs to get more of the ball but it appears to be a lack of understanding of the game plan as opposed to effort. Pressure was good in the first and last quarters.

Don't try discredit them by linking them to facebook pages. He didn't attack the ball, was very fumbly, tried to be cute instead of doing the hardwork. Nobody is questioning his disposal. Fact is he went missing, so did Cripps, both played in patches.

I expect more from him, I've watched the replay and I now think Hill was actually fairly good yesterday given his efforts and defence, still disagree with Jetta though. When they were challenged he was mostly useless. Maybe he is lost out there, that's not an excuse though, that contributes to the uselessness, it's still him doing it.

Compare him to Gaff, yes they're outside players but Gaff will direct himself at a ball and try and go get it when it's in dispute. Jetta would try move sideways and backwards or go with one hand and fumble.

Also, I'm happy to persist with him, I know he's a better player than that but he wasn't great.

 

[Matera LeNui]

5. LeCras. Must have tuned into big footy during the week, backing it up is a must.

4. Natanui. The quality of the hit outs was huge.

3. Lycett. A lot to like about his past few games.

2. McGovern. Back into gear last 2 games.

1. Kennedy. Kicking was a nightmare but working hard.

 

[Quinz]

Actually **** it, I've decided to give five votes to myself. LeCras obviously reads my stuff, last year I made a thread about him never kicking a goal against the Swans and he broke that, then I opened the changes thread saying he should be dropped and he plays his best game in a long time.

#motivator

NN is shit, Shuey is a crab, Kennedy couldn't kick his way out of a wet paper bag and Eric Mackenzie might as well be Mitch Brown at this point.

 

[Biggie]

LET IT ALL OUT Quinz

 

[fidstar]

Clear two best...

5. Nic Nat
4. Lecras

The remaining votes could have gone to a bunch...

3. Shuey
2. Redden
1. Hurn

 

[wirra44]

5. Naitanui
4. Shuey
3. LeCras
2. McGovern
1. Redden

 

[frenchconnection]

Clear two best...

5. Nic Nat
4. Lecras

The remaining votes could have gone to a bunch...

3. Shuey
2. Redden
1. Hurn

Everyone to their own but don't think Hurn was all that crash hot - just a serviceable game in my opinion and could have done better, particularly as captain to set the example.

 

[RookiePick]

Hurn serviceable is a lot better than the stinky version of Hurn we have seen too much of recently

 

[Matera LeNui]

Interesting Shep made the team of the week, something we missed? Thought he had an okay game 3/5?

 

[bUCKET__]

Interesting Shep made the team of the week, something we missed? Thought he had an okay game 3/5?

I thought he looked like 2015 Shep (TM), won a few important contests, took important intercept grab and used it well. I had him in my votes. He obviously loves having Wellingham back. But I have a massive Shepboner, was still surprised to see him get a mention on the afl site.

 

[avishka5]

hurns been getting a bit of the ball latley but hasnt been that overly great. got a lot of the ball against the swans and was average. back in the day when bunga got 17+ disposals he was extremly dangerous and would cut sides in half. we need a lot more of that.

 

[erbenz]

5. LeCras
4. NN
3. Shuey
2. Lycett
1. Sheppard

HM: Duggan, Redden, Cripps, McGovern

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Shuey is a crab

Yeah but crabs are delicious right...

 

[fidstar]

Everyone to their own but don't think Hurn was all that crash hot - just a serviceable game in my opinion and could have done better, particularly as captain to set the example.

I thought the last 3 could have gone to any of about 8 or so players. I gave one to Hurn. Thought he was pretty good when needed.

 

[eagles rule]

5)Naitanui
4)Lecras
3)Shuperman
2)Sheppard
1)Duggan

 

[Belltower]

Not a lot of love for McGovern, don't really understand that. Clearly top 5

 

[eaglespremiers]

Not a lot of love for McGovern, don't really understand that. Clearly top 5

Lol, what?
Naitanui, LeCras and Shuey are the three players "clearly top 5" for mind.
Then a whole host of other players were good including Redden, Lycett and McGovern.
I'm not sure how it's clear.

 

[Belltower]

Lol, what?
Naitanui, LeCras and Shuey are the three players "clearly top 5" for mind.
Then a whole host of other players were good including Redden, Lycett and McGovern.
I'm not sure how it's clear.

Took quite a few crucial marks when required, back to his best with his intercept marking. 4th best imo

 

[eaglespremiers]

Took quite a few crucial marks when required, back to his best with his intercept marking. 4th best imo

I'm not arguing that he wasn't 4th best for us.
I'm simply not agreeing with you that he MUST be 4th or 5th best for us.