Round 8 Trades

[Mr.Jingles]

I would upgrade Vince ASAP. Yes I think this maybe one of his best games but still... he isnt consistant.

Against the Kanagaz I only saw him in spots..in the Showdown he was every where.

He will be a good pick up next year but get rid of him ASAP

Cheers mate, yeah he is gone for Rob Murphy...could of got Pav, but the fact that 55,600 have him and only 16,000 have Murphy i was more inclined to go that option, having a ripper season and i rekon can match it, if not outclass the pav! well i'm hoping anyway!

 

[Claude Balls]

Option 1 for me.
Corey is my best player in my team..im really happy I have him..but you need to get Miburn so you dont force a 0 in your backline

And you think Swan is a worthy alternative to Corey, for now? What about missing out on S. Browne? Are there any other good mid cc's coming along?

 

[lmaohelp]

one more question before i trade lol

bradshaw or gram - for burgoyne

 

[lynchy23]

hey guys, does anyone have any info on waters? not sure whether to keep him on the pine? i have the chad on the pine already

for me this week

no chad
stokes out
dyson out
waters out
scot thompson out

annoying week

 

[Porps_is_HOT_loz]

And you think Swan is a worthy alternative to Corey, for now? What about missing out on S. Browne? Are there any other good mid cc's coming along?

Yep. Swan is constistant...just doesnt get as many high scores as Corey. I would say Swan is at his cheapest now. Im getting Swan next week.

Dont worry about S.Browne...who knows? Could do crap from now on
I cant really think of any $cows coming along in the midfield..well havent heard of any.

Some might come through out the year

 

[High Ryder]

OUT: Symes
IN: Gilbee



Will be looking to upgrade Rioli, Wona and Tredrea in the near future.

 

[Porps_is_HOT_loz]

Cheers mate, yeah he is gone for Rob Murphy...could of got Pav, but the fact that 55,600 have him and only 16,000 have Murphy i was more inclined to go that option, having a ripper season and i rekon can match it, if not outclass the pav! well i'm hoping anyway!

Rob Murphy is a good choice
Cheaper and could average the same as Pav!
Might be a better option as Freo are doing crap this season...
Good luck!

hmm

yeah i think i mite upgrade symes, i got him for cash and he has done just that, an with his past games an his BE wen he comes bak , if i dont get rid of him now, i wont be able to do nething, i had trouble last year on waiting an im not doin that this year.



with bradshaws BE over 120 i think i mite get rid of him for burgoyne?

is he a good choice ?

Burger is an awesome choice. IMO I would take Stiffy (Johncock) over him if you dont have him already. They are the same position and get the same amount of points (usually) and Stiffy is cheaper (Pretty sure he is any way).


If you already have stiffy..thats a good trade

one more question before i trade lol

bradshaw or gram - for burgoyne

Bradshaw > Gram.

Read above and do that trade (If you wanna) but do it with Gram not Bradshaw!

Good luck!

 

[Porps_is_HOT_loz]

hey guys, does anyone have any info on waters? not sure whether to keep him on the pine? i have the chad on the pine already

for me this week

no chad
stokes out
dyson out
waters out
scot thompson out

annoying week

It sure is
Not for me though...which is good..but bad signs for other peeps like you.

Im telling everyone to downgrade SDT to Myers (If your copping a 0).

Got Myers last week.
Will be handy as an emerg when Cornes and Symsey comes back

 

[Claude Balls]

Yep. Swan is constistant...just doesnt get as many high scores as Corey. I would say Swan is at his cheapest now. Im getting Swan next week.

Dont worry about S.Browne...who knows? Could do crap from now on
I cant really think of any $cows coming along in the midfield..well havent heard of any.

Some might come through out the year

Thanks Porps, the consensus has been to go with option 1, so I'll think I'll do exactly that. Corey can come next week, if I find a suitable rookie to acquire.

 

[Porps_is_HOT_loz]

Thanks Porps, the consensus has been to go with option 1, so I'll think I'll do exactly that. Corey can come next week, if I find a suitable rookie to acquire.

Sounds good.
Havin Corey and Swan in your team in what i'm doing
Corey's BE is 80 so he will only go up a little.

Oh and no problem!
Any time you need help im willing to help

 

[Captain Dreamer]

Question - Do I cope my first 0 on-field for the year?
Have Cornes, Waters and Hartlett at the back.

Planned trades - S.Stevens to Milburn & Bird to Browne

Now, should I consider passing on Browne and going Waters to P.Burg? Was planning on keeping Waters for the season, but he has been avg. Also, its pretty sideways on paper, but otherwise I might have 2 weeks of zero if he and the others don't come back.
Could also keep Stevens for another week and trade Waters for Milburn. Really think Stevens has peaked though. Plus, trades are worth their weight in gold and if I upgrade Waters, that means somewhere down the track, someone else isnt going to be upgraded.

OPINIONS WOULD BE REALLY APPRECIATED AS I'M IN 13TH SPOT AND WOULD LIKE TO STAY THERE!!

 

[FandangoDingo]

And you think Swan is a worthy alternative to Corey, for now? What about missing out on S. Browne? Are there any other good mid cc's coming along?

Cotchin's probably gonna be the next midfield cash-cow express.

Browne looks a ripper, although there's the danger he could have one or two bad games and be out, with Carlton trying various options.

I've got Chornes, Symes, Pfeiffer, Proud & SDT all copping donuts in my backline this week. I'm only going to cover one of these, so I don't miss the Browne train. Here's hoping he makes everyone a stack of loot!

Who would you get rid of first, out of Proud, Pfeiffer & SDT? SDT is the cheapest (so I need to spend more on the upgrade), but he's also coached by Laidley, so he may turn into my Hansen from 07!

Pfeiffer has made the most coin, but he's probably also the most likely out of those to get back into the team. Very disappointed that Proud went from being named on the ball last week for his first game back, only to get dropped this week. Doesn't really augur well for him.

Thoughts?

 

[Glees]

Hey guys, which of the following trades is the better option:

Dyson -> Browne
Hill -> B Johnson

Would cop a 0 in the backline with Cornes, McPhee and SDT out, or

Dyson -> Browne
SDT -> Milburn

I realise SDT still hasn't peaked but am not sure if he will get back in in the near future. At the moment I am leaning towards the Hill/Johnson trade. Any advice appreciated.

 

[Chrisrocks53]

Milburn or Goddard?

who would you do?

 

[T Rick]

Milburn or Goddard?

who would you do?

IT DEPENDS MATE I'D RATHER DO MILBURN BUT GODDARD COULD BE A TIGER IN THE SACK!

 

[lynchy23]

Milburn or Goddard?

who would you do?

definately goddard, number 1 draft pick, plays lose in defence

 

[Chrisrocks53]

Its such a hard choice

I could get Bock, Birchall, Macdonald or Stiffy

But I just cant trust them

 

[Claude Balls]

Cotchin's probably gonna be the next midfield cash-cow express.

Browne looks a ripper, although there's the danger he could have one or two bad games and be out, with Carlton trying various options.

I've got Chornes, Symes, Pfeiffer, Proud & SDT all copping donuts in my backline this week. I'm only going to cover one of these, so I don't miss the Browne train. Here's hoping he makes everyone a stack of loot!

Who would you get rid of first, out of Proud, Pfeiffer & SDT? SDT is the cheapest (so I need to spend more on the upgrade), but he's also coached by Laidley, so he may turn into my Hansen from 07!

Pfeiffer has made the most coin, but he's probably also the most likely out of those to get back into the team. Very disappointed that Proud went from being named on the ball last week for his first game back, only to get dropped this week. Doesn't really augur well for him.

Thoughts?

That's what I'll be telling myself when I pass on Browne, that he may just get dropped if he has a few mediocre games.

The order I'd get rid of those defenders in is, SDT, Proud, Pfieffer. However the revers is pretty much the opposite in terms of how much money they've made, and thus how easy it'll make it for you to do future trades. Still, I think you need to get rid of SDT. You're just dealing with total unknowns and unpreditability where he is concerned.

 

[Claude Balls]

Hey guys, which of the following trades is the better option:

Dyson -> Browne
Hill -> B Johnson

Would cop a 0 in the backline with Cornes, McPhee and SDT out, or

Dyson -> Browne
SDT -> Milburn

I realise SDT still hasn't peaked but am not sure if he will get back in in the near future. At the moment I am leaning towards the Hill/Johnson trade. Any advice appreciated.

Definately get Milburn. There's every chance the gap between Hill and Johnson won't extend too much in the next few weeks, thus enabling you to do that later.

 

[lynchy23]

dyson to browne
hill to pavlich

or

hill to edwards/valenti

dyson to kane cornes or swan?

 

[Grover]

one trade to make this week, cant pick between the two. simple really

Goodes or Kelly?

 

[LemmingMaster]

dyson to browne
hill to pavlich

This one!

 

[doncos01]

Waters >>> milburn or heath shaw. Is milburn gonna come good. Is Shaw woth the extra $86400 over milburn or could that cash be spent wiser??

 

[Beau_Waters for PM]

Milburn or Goddard?

who would you do?

...I could get Bock, Birchall, Macdonald or Stiffy
But I just cant trust them

Made me laugh.

 

[lynchy23]

one trade to make this week, cant pick between the two. simple really

Goodes or Kelly?

definately goodes mate