Sacred Hearts B&F 2005

[The Glass Lake]

Now the season is at end, who do you believe will be the worthy winner of the best and fairest for Sacred Heart

 

[coldfish99]

there is absolutely 100% no question to who will win the Sacred Heart College 1st 18 Best and Fairest. his name is Irwin Swinny, and that is all there is to say. C-Fish99

 

[The Glass Lake]

My predictions....

1st Sam McDonald
2nd Lachlan Button
3rd Cail Harris
4th Craig Fitzgerald
5th Phil Raymond

Best Team Man - Cameron Hromin
Best Defender - Michael Cilento
Best Forward/Goalkicker - Phil Raymond
Best 1st Year - Lachlan Button
Best Midfileder - Sam McDonald
Most Consistant - Dillion Montgomerie
2005 Drafties - Sam Elliott, Phil Raymond, Craig Fitzgerald (rookie)

 

[Scottroo]

My predictions....

1st Sam McDonald
2nd Lachlan Button
3rd Cail Harris
4th Craig Fitzgerald
5th Phil Raymond

Best Team Man - Cameron Hromin
Best Defender - Michael Cilento
Best Forward/Goalkicker - Phil Raymond
Best 1st Year - Lachlan Button
Best Midfileder - Sam McDonald
Most Consistant - Dillion Montgomerie
2005 Drafties - Sam Elliott, Phil Raymond, Craig Fitzgerald (rookie)

I don't know if Elliot will get picked up, hes a good player, but hes a vanilla midfielder..plenty of them going around, however he seems like a decent kid and goes bout his footy the right way

 

[Flying Joey]

I don't know if Elliot will get picked up, hes a good player, but hes a vanilla midfielder..plenty of them going around, however he seems like a decent kid and goes bout his footy the right way

have just proved wat everyone else thinks... u kno nothing... prob worst comment in big footy history... well don knob

 

[The Glass Lake]

I don't know if Elliot will get picked up, hes a good player, but hes a vanilla midfielder..plenty of them going around, however he seems like a decent kid and goes bout his footy the right way

Your an absolute idiot.

 

[colin custard]

its obviously a bias comment saying that 3 of your players will get drafted. shc could easily not have one player drafted.
i agree with scottroo, elliot is a very good player, but he has got nothing speical about him that midfielders need to have to get picked up in this day and age. obviously he has his good points such as: exceptional in close, strong over the footy, good composure, but in contrast, he has numerous downsides to his game such as: not quick, not great skills, not great aerobic capacity, which are things a player of his size has to have to get drafted.
in saying that, i still think he is a very good player who is a good chance of being drafted, but not a certainty.

 

[Scottroo]

have just proved wat everyone else thinks... u kno nothing... prob worst comment in big footy history... well don knob

How have i proven I know nothing? all I stated is Elliot is a vanilla midfielder...if you dont agree you know nothing about the game...

 

[RooDog]

have just proved wat everyone else thinks... u kno nothing... prob worst comment in big footy history... well don knob

i think this is one of the worst comments ive read, what scott has to say is true and i think you boys are a little blinded by your SHC love for Elliot. The guy is a fantastic footballer dont get me wrong but i wouldnt be surprised if he is over looked, he doesnt have any stand out abilities like blokes like a Jace Bode who can kick the ball 60m and is a very solid boy already...

 

[Scottroo]

i think this is one of the worst comments ive read, what scott has to say is true and i think you boys are a little blinded by your SHC love for Elliot. The guy is a fantastic footballer dont get me wrong but i wouldnt be surprised if he is over looked, he doesnt have any stand out abilities like blokes like a Jace Bode who can kick the ball 60m and is a very solid boy already...

Correct, he reminds me of adam bentick from carlton...he captained calder cannons to a premiership in 2003, everyone thought he'd get picked up but got overlooked and was picked up via the rookie draft

 

[RooDog]

Correct, he reminds me of adam bentick from carlton...he captained calder cannons to a premiership in 2003, everyone thought he'd get picked up but got overlooked and was picked up via the rookie draft

exactly. no one said he wont get rookied we are talking about getting taken in the actual draft.

 

[Scottroo]

Now the season is at end, who do you believe will be the worthy winner of the best and fairest for Sacred Heart

Nick Forster is God thread....

 

[the double brews]

Nick Forster is God thread....

hey scottroo how about u blow just a bit more sunshine up adam forsters ****.

 

[shooter#9]

its obviously a bias comment saying that 3 of your players will get drafted. shc could easily not have one player drafted.
i agree with scottroo, elliot is a very good player, but he has got nothing speical about him that midfielders need to have to get picked up in this day and age. obviously he has his good points such as: exceptional in close, strong over the footy, good composure, but in contrast, he has numerous downsides to his game such as: not quick, not great skills, not great aerobic capacity, which are things a player of his size has to have to get drafted.
in saying that, i still think he is a very good player who is a good chance of being drafted, but not a certainty.

couldnt have put it better colin, elliot is gun, but there are so many like him out there eg hurley, davey, smith....if elliot went to a different school he wouldnt get half the hype he does, having said that he is a top bloke

 

[shooter#9]

My predictions....

1st Sam McDonald
2nd Lachlan Button
3rd Cail Harris
4th Craig Fitzgerald
5th Phil Raymond

Best Team Man - Cameron Hromin
Best Defender - Michael Cilento
Best Forward/Goalkicker - Phil Raymond
Best 1st Year - Lachlan Button
Best Midfileder - Sam McDonald
Most Consistant - Dillion Montgomerie
2005 Drafties - Sam Elliott, Phil Raymond, Craig Fitzgerald (rookie)

to the SHC guys is michael cilento the guy i played on for a while (did most of the kicking in) and y the hell is sam elliot or jed kenny in that top 5, they are both better than all of those guys bar maybe button

 

[The Mole]

to the SHC guys is michael cilento the guy i played on for a while (did most of the kicking in) and y the hell is sam elliot or jed kenny in that top 5, they are both better than all of those guys bar maybe button

Both missed alot of footy during the year due to u'18 commitments and injury. For what its worth, heres my top 5 for the b&f.

1st. Lachlan Button - can't remember a game when he hasn't been in the best
2nd. Craig Fitzgerald - absolute class in the forward line
3rd. Sam McDonald - tough, couagous midfielder
4th. Ben Mader - really excelled in a half back role this year
5th. Cail Harris/Phil Raymond - could be either. Both had good solid years

 

[The Glass Lake]

Nick Forster is God thread....

Suck me off... u and roo dog (adam forster) have probabaly never played a game of footy in your life therefore go make up an umpires thread and talk yourselves up abit more. Noone cares what u think.

 

[RooDog]

Suck me off... u and roo dog (adam forster) have probabaly never played a game of footy in your life therefore go make up an umpires thread and talk yourselves up abit more. Noone cares what u think.

haha scott made his a grade amatuer debut at 15, i played all through school, at least im not hiding who i am, you are probably some mass hack that rates himself highly like 90% of shc.

 

[coldfish99]

Suck me off... u and roo dog (adam forster) have probabaly never played a game of footy in your life therefore go make up an umpires thread and talk yourselves up abit more. Noone cares what u think.

gotta agree with the glass lake, A Forster only umpires because he cant play footy to save his llife, so he comes on here to pay out others because hes jealous he wont have nearly as much skill as most people who post on here. **** off to an umpires thread and leave the footy talk to actual footy players

 

[RooDog]

gotta agree with the glass lake, A Forster only umpires because he cant play footy to save his llife, so he comes on here to pay out others because hes jealous he wont have nearly as much skill as most people who post on here. **** off to an umpires thread and leave the footy talk to actual footy players

pretty hypocritical comment considering i played the same level of school footy as you so perhaps you shouldnt comment either then....

 

[The Mole]

pretty hypocritical comment considering i played the same level of school footy as you so perhaps you shouldnt comment either then....

You played 1st 18 and 2nd 18????????????

 

[Flying Joey]

i think this is one of the worst comments ive read, what scott has to say is true and i think you boys are a little blinded by your SHC love for Elliot. The guy is a fantastic footballer dont get me wrong but i wouldnt be surprised if he is over looked, he doesnt have any stand out abilities like blokes like a Jace Bode who can kick the ball 60m and is a very solid boy already...

why does jace bode wear his hat backwards???
so adam forster doesnt get sunburnt..

u pump up bode almost as much as ur bro

 

[Flying Joey]

i think this forum especially harbours some people with wat is called tall poppy syndrome... let me explain.. one of the SA best college footy players, irrespective of wat school he attends, is being made out to be some hack talked up by his mates... remember, this player has been invited to draft camp, played sanfl reserves wen availiable, captained the best team in the state this year, played all year with a dodgy ankle and shoulder, won the b&f as a year 11 (only person since pavlich to do so). there is more that could be said... so before all u knockers click that "post reply" button to have a crack at him, think to urself "am i as good as him?". if ur answer is yes, then go for it and get stuck rite in. if its no, then ease off the pay outs, many unfounded, because it makes u look silly.. wen someone who quit football after school gets stuck into someone on his way to do great things in his career (whether for sanfl or afl, rookie or national draft) it gives the impression this person needs to bring down ppl better than him to make him feel adequete. sure, critisize within reason, but stupid rash comments are not needed on a discussion forum..

Sincerely,
Sir Bob Geldoff

 

[The Mole]

i think this forum especially harbours some people with wat is called tall poppy syndrome... let me explain.. one of the SA best college footy players, irrespective of wat school he attends, is being made out to be some hack talked up by his mates... remember, this player has been invited to draft camp, played sanfl reserves wen availiable, captained the best team in the state this year, played all year with a dodgy ankle and shoulder, won the b&f as a year 11 (only person since pavlich to do so). there is more that could be said... so before all u knockers click that "post reply" button to have a crack at him, think to urself "am i as good as him?". if ur answer is yes, then go for it and get stuck rite in. if its no, then ease off the pay outs, many unfounded, because it makes u look silly.. wen someone who quit football after school gets stuck into someone on his way to do great things in his career (whether for sanfl or afl, rookie or national draft) it gives the impression this person needs to bring down ppl better than him to make him feel adequete. sure, critisize within reason, but stupid rash comments are not needed on a discussion forum..

Sincerely,
Sir Bob Geldoff

Post of the year. Here Here! People like Adam Forster who played at the lowest level at SHC have no right to bag people like Sam Elliott. Mate stop posting on a school football forum, as you have no idea and no one cares about you. You left SHC in 2002 and since then you have been hanging on for dear life, just to try and be a part of the SHC football scene and social scene. Stop living off the successes of you brother and build a life for yourself. Move on, please. For all peoples sake

 

[The Glass Lake]

haha scott made his a grade amatuer debut at 15, i played all through school, at least im not hiding who i am, you are probably some mass hack that rates himself highly like 90% of shc.

From what i heard, from a very reliable source is that scottroo played something like div 10 C grade......hardly amatuer football. You may well have played all through school but at what grade...5th XVIII...just what i thought. You are a hack, a dud, a joke so go start an umpires thread so noone can know anything about ya.