Retired Simon Black (1997-2013)

Remove this Banner Ad

Bengwatkins said:
Indefinitely doesnt sound good at all...

...Although, say...Hes put on the LTI list and decides to retire...Maybe Barlett could get his long awaited debut before the end of the year...?

Not that big of a silver lining, but well, clouds suck.
Click to expand...
I think we've got an unused rookie promo spot open without an LTI.
 
Bengwatkins said:
Clarke was upped at the midseason and didnt we elevate SMichael for Beams? And Wrigleys a rookie...
Click to expand...

Clarke was a pre-season elevation.

Michael was elevated for Beams.

And yes, Wrigley is a rookie.

Not sure when the mid-season window closes...
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Honest I don't think we need Black as much anymore. With Moloney coming in that takes up an inside midfield spot already. Black playing on would just take the spot of guys like Lester (let him develop as a big inside midfielder), Green (who could be a L.Power type) and Docherty (I see him moving to the midfield eventually).
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

PrideIsInstinctive said:
I like the sentimentality but in reality his body isn't holding up this year, what are the chances he can get through another pre-season?
Click to expand...
Nil - it would take a big name to talk him around and there is only one of those - at this stage he will be retired in '14
 
Five talking points: Brisbane Lions v GWS

1. Black is backAfter seven weeks on the sidelines with a groin injury, Simon Black looked like he hadn't missed a beat. The 2002 Brownlow medallist had 10 touches at quarter time and wasn't slowing down there. He finished with 28 for the match and ran rings around his younger Giants opponents. One passage in the second quarter had Black streaming through the middle of the ground looking for targets with his left foot, before baulking, switching to his right and pin-pointing a pass to an open Josh Green. With his future in doubt, Lions fans are lapping up every possession they see from the triple-premiership champion.
black1218.jpg
Click to expand...
 
I posted elswhere but the handball in traffic under pressure to Mayes in space for a goal, encapsulates the way I will remember Black. It's a heady week seeing three of your all time fav's bowing out in indifferent fashion. Despite my misgivings I still want to get to the Cattery to say goodbye, because I'm pretty confident that this is it.
 
Not sure how keen I am for Black to go on next season. His body has really let him down this year and I struggle to see how that's going to improve with yet another year. Also think that in his absence, Rocky, Rich and Reddo really stood up and took control of the midfield and that's what we need. With him, Moloney and potentially Raines all taking midfield spots next year, we'd be robbing another player the development in there that he may need.

Little I hate more than those who just want to play the kids, and I love Blacky as much as anyone, but just think that while he could play on it probably wouldn't be best for the team long term if he did. Well aware that I'm likely alone in this opinion though.
 
PattyKisagun said:
Not sure how keen I am for Black to go on next season. His body has really let him down this year and I struggle to see how that's going to improve with yet another year. Also think that in his absence, Rocky, Rich and Reddo really stood up and took control of the midfield and that's what we need. With him, Moloney and potentially Raines all taking midfield spots next year, we'd be robbing another player the development in there that he may need.

Little I hate more than those who just want to play the kids, and I love Blacky as much as anyone, but just think that while he could play on it probably wouldn't be best for the team long term if he did. Well aware that I'm likely alone in this opinion though.
Click to expand...


Nope. I tend to agree. Body is certainly letting him down, his form is still as good as any in our midfield though. It seems that when one of Moloney/Black or both are playing, it seems to have an affect on one of the younger blokes.

I'd love him as a super sub though. :p
 
It depends. He seems to think that his injuries this year have been caused by a lack of a pre-season. If that holds water and his body is now ok'ish, then it may be a risk worth taking.

I also don't buy the argument that he is stifling other players' development. For every inside player who has less midfield time, there is an outside player getting the benefit of the service he provides. Moreover, competition for spots is never a bad thing. The younger players should earn their spot. I don't think Black would mind playing off half forward if a younger player takes his midfield spot. The fact is that Black is still one of our best 2 or 3 inside mids. Until that changes, then I think we should welcome him wanting to play another year.

Edit - just saw CJ's post. Scrap the above!
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Retired Simon Black (1997-2013)

Similar threads

ZoBlitz
Past Michael McLean (1991-1997)
Replies
1
Views
481
ZoBlitz
ZoBlitz

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top