Research Small questions that don't require a whole thread

Remove this Banner Ad

West Coburg played the entire Essendon DFL Division 1 home and away season with a perfect 18-0 record. They then got belted by Deer Park in the Grand Final by 96 points AND got in the news for further wrong reasons thanks to Jordan Gloury's cowardly right hook.

Has there ever been a more humiliating defeat margin-wise in a Grand Final by a team who had a perfect H&A record (West Coburg wasn't perfect before the Grand Final since Deer Park had already thrashed them by 70 points in the semi final), or perfect record into Grand Final day?
India in the 2023 World Cup.
 
This covers VFL/AFL venues very well: AFL Tables - All Venues

There was a game at the Gabba in 1981:
View attachment 1865594
Thank you.

While I don't follow the SANFL very much these days, I absolutely doubt they would have played a game at Flemington in 1999, and suspect the same regarding a game at Bunbury. Most likely there was a 'glitch' or two on that otherwise excellent site!

Oh... that's a bit of a let down. The idea of an incursion into VFL territory, even if the "war" was over, was fascinating to me. Pretty disciplined from all state associations then, across codes too. I'm fairly certain before 1988, Rugby League, both Queensland and NSW, didn't even attempt "propaganda" (excepting the ACT with the NSW RL Canberra Raiders from 1982).

It makes the VFL venturing up to the Sydney and Brisbane a real nice niche.
 
I have a question (that probably doesn't require a whole thread of its own):

When did the player positions become formalised (back pocket, back flank etc) and did the terminology evolve from early days to the more stabilised form of the game by the time of the VFL -to early 1920's.

(I would also note, that the current usage of the term 'Substitute' in the modern game is an affront. Such a player is a Reserve and should be referred to as such. :))
Although it (starting in positions) had been suggested many times it was not until November 1890 it was included in the amended rules for the 1891 season.
 
Last edited:

Log in to remove this ad.

Thank you.



Oh... that's a bit of a let down. The idea of an incursion into VFL territory, even if the "war" was over, was fascinating to me. Pretty disciplined from all state associations then, across codes too. I'm fairly certain before 1988, Rugby League, both Queensland and NSW, didn't even attempt "propaganda" (excepting the ACT with the NSW RL Canberra Raiders from 1982).

It makes the VFL venturing up to the Sydney and Brisbane a real nice niche.
There's also the Rugby League Tables site, which may be of interest if you're not aware of it: Rugby League Tables & Statistics
 
Can you tell me who this Cf james (essendon player from 1890s) is


The article was from 1930, and said he played senior football 30 years earlier for Essendon. So it should be more like 1900 when he played. It could well be he was with the Essendon Association team, and this chap might be some sort of a possibility, though this is from 1908:
1714537586649.png
1714537693258.png
This chap was in the right area at the right time to have been that player, born in 1885 which would be reasonable, and obviously a good match for a C. F. James:
1714542142591.png
I can't see anything that suggests he was working/living in the northern parts of Australia at any stage, and the article suggests the footballer should have been doing that from c. 1918-1930 at least.
 
Last edited:
Could someone please explain the difference between "Centre" and "followers" (excl. ruck) in present day, and also the original purpose of the Ruck-Rover?

I always assumed the player in the middle of the scrimmages doing the heavy tackling (i.e. Kirk/Rowbottom) was the centre as they covered the least amount of ground of the three. I would have thought Chad was the rover, Heeney (being slightly taller) the RR and Rowbottom the Centre, But lately I've noticed Rowbottom is often named as the Rover. So how does it work?
 
Looking for Teams that finished last during minor round but won Grand final

Fitzroy Maroons 1916
Mowanjum Hawks 1991...

Goldfields FL (as a four team league)

Railways - 1931
Boulder City - 1935


There were dozens of leagues pre-WWII in WA that had either three or four clubs participating. It was a rare occurrence but not unique.
 
Of course.

In order for it to happen the ball must be in flight when the siren sounds.

A slight twist came in the 1980 Escort Championships Grand Final.

The ball was in transit between Malcolm Blight's hands and feet when the siren sounded. The ball was kicked from inside the centre square and was marked by Kerry Good.

Good kicked a goal with a set shot. The siren had been rung continuously for 31 seconds at the moment Good kicked the ball.

The goal was scored as a result of two kicks after the siren.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

I remember watching a game in the mid-2000's with the Bombers playing. I believe it was James Hird taking a set shot from about 50 out. He hit the post, but what made it special was that it didn't just hit the post, he landed it dead on top of the post. It got a good WTF out of the crowd.

I remember it being a night game with Quartermain commentating, which led me to Round 17, 2006, but I can't find the full game footage. I'm sure someone here has a similar memory.

My question is, has any other player in the VFL/AFL managed to land their kick right on the top of the post, and do you have video to back it up?
Sav Rocca was a coach for my son’s junior team and achieved this at the end of training one night (wasn’t deliberate!)

Sorry no video but it’s etched into my mind!
 
Has a team ever started with a scoreless first quarter with the other team scoring only 9 points from 10 shots in a grand final then coming from 14 points down at 3/4 time to win the match by 6 points.
Attached is the wind direction for the game at Narrandera on Saturday View attachment Screen_Recording_20240917_110039_BOM Weather.mp4

Sent from my SM-G975F using Tapatalk
 
Has a team ever started with a scoreless first quarter with the other team scoring only 9 points from 10 shots in a grand final then coming from 14 points down at 3/4 time to win the match by 6 points.
Attached is the wind direction for the game at Narrandera on Saturday View attachment 2113113

Sent from my SM-G975F using Tapatalk
Other interesting statistics for any history person from this grand final.
Note: Year in brackets when last time.
1) Ganmain Grong Grong Matong (GGGM) was undefeated (2018) coming into this game. 2011 was the last time a team went through the whole season, and that was them;
2) GGGM and Collingullie - Wagga (C-W) dominated the season with C-W only losing to GGGM (1979 in South West District Football League);
3) Lowest score equal winning score, which was C-W 7.6 - 48 to GGGM 5.12 - 42 in 2022 it was GGGM 6.12 - 48 to Collingullie Glenfeild Park 4.7 - 31;
4) Last time, a team went into a grand final undefeated and lost was Ariah Park - Mirrool in 1979. For Collingullie, to defeat a team in this situation was in 1982 in Riverina District Football League, which returned to the name of Farrer Football League in 1995.

Sent from my SM-X210 using Tapatalk
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Research Small questions that don't require a whole thread

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top