Spud's SuperCoach Preview (Round 5, Post-ANZAC Day)

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Feb 23, 2008
6,779
1,733
This post
AFL Club
Richmond
Cyril+Rioli+AFL+Second+Semi+Final+Hawthorn+_v18PJmwnDfl.jpg


TWITTER: --- @jamiedmurphy

Friday, April 27
Fremantle v Carlton (Patterson) @ 6:45pm

Saturday, April 28
Western Sydney v Western Bulldogs (Manuka) @ 1:45pm
North Melbourne v Gold Coast (Etihad) @ 4:40pm
Melbourne v St Kilda (MCG) @ 7:40pm
Brisbane v Geelong (Gabba) @ 7:45pm

Sunday, April 29
Hawthorn v Sydney (Aurora) @ 1:10pm
Richmond v West Coast (MCG) @ 3:15pm
Adelaide v Port Adelaide (AAMI) @ 4:10pm

Teams

All the team news as it comes in: http://www.afl.com.au/teams/tabid/16469/default.aspx

Key INs & OUTs

IN: Fyfe (FREM), Walker (CARL), Cameron, Coniglio, Greene, Adams (GWS), Lake (WBD), Horsley (GCS), Sylvia, Grimes (MELB), Smedts (GEEL), Birchall, Hodge (HAW) & Goodes (SYD).
OUT: Sandilands (FREM), Bower, Carrazzo, Yarran (CARL), Mohr, Kennedy (GWS), Giansiracusa (WBD), Goldstein (KANG), Ablett, Hall (GCS) & Gray (PORT). EDIT: Chad Cornes OUT

Captain's Corner

Hopefully you took advantage of the Vice Captain loop-hole that has been available over the partial lockout rounds so far, and gave the VC to Swan or Pendlebury. If not, here are some options for you:

boyd_lesson_a.jpg


Matthew Boyd (WBD) vs Greater Western Sydney
2012 Ave: 107.75
(Scored 131 & 106 vs GCS last year)
Given they play GWS this week, so you can almost guarantee a 130+ to the Bulldogs' skipper. Should rack up possessions at will, as he has done so far this season, averaging 31 touches a game. Ironically, the only thing that might stop Boyd going 160+ might be his team mates; if the Dogs have a stellar game, as they're expected to, it could be a case of points being pinched by the likes of Murphy, Cross, and co. Should be safe for 130+ though.

DalSanto_Rd2009_246a.jpg


Nick Dal Santo vs Melbourne
2012 Ave: 116
Ave vs MELB: 112.5 (Since Rnd 1 2009)
Not surprisingly, while Dal santo represents a silky machine of efficiency, the Saints' midfielder also embodies one of the best SuperCoach scorers of the competition's history. Has a solid record against Melbourne, having scored 120+ in three of his last four games against the Demons. Should replicate his recent form against the Dees, however NDS looks a prime target for mature age recruit James Magner, who has been somewhat successful in the tagging roles he's undertaken the past few weeks.

brendon-goddard-roars-246c.jpg


Brendon Goddard vs Melbourne
2012 Ave: 114.5
Ave vs MELB: 116.25 (Since Rnd 1 2009)
Similar to Dal Santo, Goddard is an example of a fantasy point accumulator. Has a ominous record against Melbourne of late, notching up 127, 135 & 124 in his three most recent outings against them. Should run amok at the MCG this week, despite the return of Sylvia and Grimes.

ART_Buddy4-420x0.jpg


Lance Franklin vs Sydney
2012 Ave: 109.5
Ave vs SYD: 109 (Since Rnd 1 2010)
Scored 89 last week despite kicking 1.6 and giving away seven free kicks in his side's loss to West Coast. It was probably the low-scoring nature of the match that saved his SC score. Buddy had a day out against the Swans last time the teams played, racking up 28 disposals, nine marks and kicking 6.6 for an impressive 146 SC points. You'd have to back him in for another big one, espeically down in Launceston.

Goodes_NABrd209_246a.jpg


Adam Goodes vs Hawthorn
2012 Ave: 106.67
Ave vs HAW: 132.4 (Since Rnd 1 2009)
Will be looking to make amends for missing last week, and has produced some hefty scores against the lads from Glenferrie in the past, pumping out 183 and 166 in 2009. Normally an upgrade option in SuperCoach, given he typically finishes strongly most seasons, however Goodes start to 2012 has been impressive with a pair of 115s and 90 coming from his first three games. The Swans are undefeated, and should be a strong chance in Tasmania this week. Goodes improves their chances of leaving the Apple Ilse with a 'W'.

TRADE CENTRE

723497-gary-ablett.jpg


Gary Ablett
Whether you're going for league wins or overall ranking, my advice would be to keep Ablett in your team. From memory, the little genius has an amazing recovery rate from injuries, and I was particularly heartened by this tweet:

GazTweet.jpg


Bottom line, I believe Ablett may miss just a single week. DT Talk's Calvin made some excellent points in their weekly live vlog last night (7:45 - 10:00):

[YOUTUBE]ctIQcZ4TcV4[/YOUTUBE]

With Magner, Sheil and McDonald scoring well, and Green & Coniglio back in this week, most teams should have decent bench cover. Bottom line: KEEP ABLETT, because a) he could be back as early as next week, and b) It'll be difficult to get him back into your side without using at least 2-3 trades.

sp00050179-image.jpg
sp00026851-image.jpg


Shane Mumford/Aaron Sandilands
Five rounds in, and it feels like I've been thrown into Doc Brown's Delorean and sent back to 2010 - the year I burnt about five trades on my ruck division. First Mumford misses with a bizarre back infection; now Sandilands' metre long calf muscle starts giving him greif. Now if you've rolled with a two-premium ruck strategy and you think you can survive with Giles at R2, perhaps you're best advised to simply bench Mummy or Sandi until we learn a bit more about their condition. However, if you're like me and are sticking with the three-rookie-ruck approach, my advice would be;

For Mumford owners, trade away. As much as I love him, the 'snag-man' is set to miss 3-4 games whilst recovering from back surgery, and those 3-4 zeros will hurt both your chances at success, in terms of league and overall prospects. McIntosh looks like a great option at $432,300. He seems to have taken over the #1 ruck mantle at Arden St, to the point where Goldstein, the most improved SC player of 2011, has been dropped. You'll also pocket a cool $178,000 should you decide to bring in 'Big H'.

For Sandilands owners, I think holding Sandilands, despite the zero you may cop this week, is the best option. Given Ross Lyon's comments, I've got hope of a Round 6 return for Sandilands:

Ross Lyon said:
"We were confident he (Sandilands) would get up this week. It didn't quite happen, so we're confident he'll get up next week.'
'Aaron's one that would push himself through, but certainly he's not right to go. I mean we could leave it until tomorrow and all those things, but we've got real confidence in Jon Griffin."

Source: Sandilands blow for Freo - Sky News

My advice? Hold Sandi for at least this week until we know more about his condition. If you're desperate to trade, Ryder, McIntosh, Nic Nat or Cox are viable options.

ROOKIE WATCH

art-353-james-20mcdonald-200x0.jpg


James McDonald (MID, GWS) - $106,600
2012 Average: 89 (100 & 78)
Priced just a tick over $100 large, McDonald looks to have continued where he left off at Melbourne in 2010. In his two games for GWS, he's averaged 19 disposals, four marks and 8.5 tackles per game. I'm still bewildered that he didn't play for the Dees last year, given he was ranked in the top three in a few key statistics at the club (contested possessions, tackles, etc). One of your trades this week simply HAS to be used to bring JMac in if you don't have him.

840159-adam-treloar.jpg


Adam Treloar (MID/FWD, GWS) - $113,200
2012 Average: 73
Another GWS young gun who has hit the ground running, having notched up a pair of 73s in his first two games, in addition to providing useful DPP ability. Averaged the third most contested possessions for the Dandenong Stingrays in the TAC Cup (2010), while last year he was able to average 19 disposals and four I50s per game in the NEAFL (Courtesy of AFL Prospectus). If you can spare a trade this week amidst the Ablett/Mumford/Sandilands carnage, you've got to bring him in.

450258-billie-smedts.jpg


Billie Smedts (DEF/FWD, GEEL) - $113,200
2012 Average:
Hasn't exploded into the 2012 season like many thought he would, scoring 46 and 42 in his first two games, albeit against quality opposition in Fremantle and Hawthorn. Does offer multi-position capabilities being listed as a defender-forward, but you should ensure you've got Treloar & McDonald before considering this future Geelong star.

VIDEO OF THE WEEK

[YOUTUBE]xGDyTe85Nkk[/YOUTUBE]

Lest we forget.

As usual, any feedback is welcome, preferably via this thread, or twitter (@jamiedmurphy)
 
Great review as always Spud. I have Mummy and want to trade him out but is H the best option? The cash and his current scoring is enticing but will he perform all year?
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Thanks Spudregus_87


Is Sandi 100% out?

I need a captain for my Pendlebury loophole out of the following:
Sandi, Dempsey, Smedts, Winmar < maybe the pick of the bunch

Also who is better out of Redden and Orren Stephenson to pick as the emergency?
 
"you're a full blown toss" LOL'd so hard.

Looking forward to Smedt's long awaited price rise this week, and as always great preview spud :thumbsu:
 
Great review as always Spud. I have Mummy and want to trade him out but is H the best option? The cash and his current scoring is enticing but will he perform all year?

Given that Goldstein has been dropped, I'd be backing HMac in for the year.

Only thing stopping him would be injury.

Thanks Spudregus_87

Is Sandi 100% out?

I need a captain for my Pendlebury loophole out of the following:
Sandi, Dempsey, Smedts, Winmar < maybe the pick of the bunch

Also who is better out of Redden and Orren Stephenson to pick as the emergency?

Sandi 100% out, so feel confident in using him to exploit the loophole.

Stephenson's listed as an emergency (so he's still a slight chance), compared to Redden who isn't even named :( So give Orren the emg then just cross those fingers!

I'm Chaddered. Completed trades already, tucking into a beer and chips.... Then I read Spuds preview...... :eek:

Sorry mate :(

I reckon the non-reversable trades after ANZAC Day would've caught a few out.

"you're a full blown toss" LOL'd so hard.

Looking forward to Smedt's long awaited price rise this week, and as always great preview spud :thumbsu:

Cheers man.

Great write up yet again.
I herd/seen on sc activity feed prob just the normal bull$hit.That Giles is out someone herd on bullshower radio aka SEN.

Geez I hope not. If Giles misses, I'll have no rucks.

Hopefully just the typical SEN caller though, so nothing to worry about.
 
Sandi 100% out, so feel confident in using him to exploit the loophole.

Stephenson's listed as an emergency (so he's still a slight chance), compared to Redden who isn't even named :( So give Orren the emg then just cross those fingers!


From what I read on the Geelong AFL site, Orren is playing in the curtain raiser tonight against the Bendigo Gold :eek: so all good there.
 
Another 'coach' here who enjoys your previews, Spud. :thumbsu:

Great write up yet again.
I herd/seen on sc activity feed prob just the normal bull$hit.That Giles is out someone herd on bullshower radio aka SEN.

That would be insane. Has anybody been sacrificing GWS rookies to the SC Gods? Why are they so angry!?
 
@#%@ thought i had traded in Swanny for Ablett but i forgot i picked Swallow in as a POD and is my C also it allowed Barlow to come into my team arghh kicking myself.
Fyfe, Barlow and Murphy tonight hopefully make up for it.
 
QUARTER TIME

CARLTON

Bryce Gibbs 36
Ed Curnow 35
Marc Murphy 35
Shaun Hampson 31
Matthew Kreuzer 30
Kade Simpson 25
Chris Judd 24
Heath Scotland 24

Jordan Russell 24
Eddie Betts 21
Bret Thornton 19
Jeff Garlett 18
Andrew Walker 16
Zach Tuohy 16
Lachie Henderson 15
Dennis Armfield 14
Mitch Robinson 14
Nick Duigan 12
Aaron Joseph 11
Michael Jamison 10
Jarrad Waite 9
Kane Lucas 0

FREMANTLE

Jonathon Griffin 36
Paul Duffield 35
Greg Broughton 33

Stephen Hill 28
Nathan Fyfe 23
Zac Dawson 23
Adam McPhee 22
Tendai Mzungu 22
Matthew Pavlich 20
David Mundy 19
Hayden Ballantyne 19
Chris Mayne 18
Garrick Ibbotson 17
Luke McPharlin 11
Ryan Crowley 11
Michael Barlow 10
Matt De Boer 8
Clancee Pearce 6
Michael Johnson 4
Zac Clarke 3
John Anthony 1
Lachie Neale 0
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

HALF TIME

CARLTON

Bryce Gibbs 60
Marc Murphy 60

Kade Simpson 55
Ed Curnow 50
Lachie Henderson 50
Andrew Walker 49
Heath Scotland 49
Jarrad Waite 45
Chris Judd 44
Shaun Hampson 44
Mitch Robinson 39
Eddie Betts 36
Jordan Russell 35
Bret Thornton 34
Matthew Kreuzer 31
Aaron Joseph 27
Jeff Garlett 27
Michael Jamison 24
Zach Tuohy 23
Dennis Armfield 19
Nick Duigan 13
Kane Lucas 0

FREMANTLE

Paul Duffield 67
Greg Broughton 62
Michael Barlow 60 (50 point quarter)

David Mundy 58
Jonathon Griffin 56
Nathan Fyfe 52
Matthew Pavlich 51

Tendai Mzungu 50
Chris Mayne 48
Stephen Hill 47
Hayden Ballantyne 44
Clancee Pearce 38
Garrick Ibbotson 33
Zac Dawson 27
Adam McPhee 26
Matt De Boer 23
Luke McPharlin 21
Michael Johnson 18
Ryan Crowley 18
Zac Clarke 14
John Anthony 9
Lachie Neale 0
 
Broughton lucky not to get a few frees given away then but ill take it :D Fyfe appears to be an sc fave, that late critical error didn't really effect his score amazingly. Got Pav as well, couldve had a couple of goals if not for a couple of dodgy bounces.
 
One impact of Fyfe's shoulder:he's unlikely to lay ANY tackles until his shoulder is fixed. They had to play him as a pure midfielder.
 
FULL TIME

CARLTON

Kade Simpson 127
Marc Murphy 114
Bryce Gibbs 112
Heath Scotland 111

Mitch Robinson 101
Lachie Henderson 92
Chris Judd 90
Andrew Walker 85
Ed Curnow 82
Jordan Russell 77
Jarrad Waite 71
Shaun Hampson 70
Michael Jamison 68
Matthew Kreuzer 63
Bret Thornton 62
Eddie Betts 59
Jeff Garlett 55
Dennis Armfield 53
Nick Duigan 51
Aaron Joseph 50
Zach Tuohy 41
Kane Lucas 5

FREMANTLE

David Mundy 109
Jonathon Griffin 105
Michael Barlow 104
Tendai Mzungu 100
Greg Broughton 99
Nathan Fyfe 97
Matthew Pavlich 91
Paul Duffield 91

Clancee Pearce 88
Luke McPharlin 83
Stephen Hill 82
Chris Mayne 81
Garrick Ibbotson 80
Adam McPhee 71
Michael Johnson 63
Hayden Ballantyne 61
Zac Dawson 59
Ryan Crowley 58
Matt De Boer 51
Zac Clarke 33
Lachie Neale 26
John Anthony 12
 
How is Courtney Dempsey doing all? Old Greg is averaging 100 over the past 3 :p

Good start to the week, sitting on 695/4(C)
 
Expected Duffield to do better considering how much he dominated the first half.

Would have loved a bigger score from Pav, but the delivery he has been getting leaves something to be desired.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top