Survivor Dream Lineup

[TigerGlory]

If you could theoretically get 18 Survivors from any of the series, and plonk them in three tribes. Who would you get? Can be personal favourites, or who you thought played the best etc. Just make sure you list from which series they are, as we struggle with the earlier ones. Try and keep them seperated too, split the people from the same series up a little. Heres my take;

Tribe 1:
Hatch (Borneo & All Stars)
Steph (Guatemala & Palau)
Jon (Pearl Islands)
Danielle (Panama)
Ozzy (Cook Islands)
Amanda (China)

Tribe 2:
Judd (Guatemala)
Parvati (Cook Islands)
Shane (Panama)
Jenna (Borneo & All Stars)
James (China)
Darrah (Pearl Islands)

Tribe 3:
Terry (Panama)
Danni (Guatemala)
Todd (China)
Jerri (Australia)
Ryan O (Pearl Islands)
Jenna (Amazon & All Stars)

That was actually rather difficult.

Edits:
Ins Jerri (Australia), Darrah (Pearl Islands)
Outs Jessica (Cook Islands), Ami (Vanuatu)

 

[Warrior 89]

Tribe 1 :
Yul (Cook Islands)
Hatch (Borneo)
James (China)
Earl
Terry (Panama)
Jerry (Australia)

Tribe 2 :
Brian (Thailand)
Rob M (All Stars)
Yeo Man
Rob C (Amazon)
Ozzy (Cook Islands)
Amanda (China)

Tribe 3 :
Johnny Fairplay
Todd (China)
Coby (Australia)
Dreamz
Jonathon (Cook Islands)
Jenna (Amazon & All Stars)

I did this from memory (I don't want to look anything up and be spoiled for the current series) so I may have some of the names and series mixed up.

I have a token female for each tribe and I have also tried to make sure each tribe has at least 1 physically dominant player, with the rest of the tribe made up of strategically smart players and a few wildcards like Jerry and Dreamz.

The main guy I would like to see out there again is Brian the used car salesman who was able to win Thailand. He played a very good game and he controlled everything. I also think he was an amateur pornstar and had a really hot wife.

 

[mulhollanddrive]

Awesome thread!!!!

I'll do some refreshing of players and come back with my line up.

 

[mulhollanddrive]

Criteria/role in brackets.

Group 1 -
Todd - China (Mastermind, character value)
Yao Man - Fiji (Mastermind, equal best player to never have won)
Rob M - All-Stars (Just to prove against strong player, he's mediocre)
Parvati - Cook Islands (Good looking and has some character value)
Chris - Vanuatu (Just to prove it was an accident)
Danni - Guatamala (Can she do it again)

Group 2 -
Hatch - Borneo (2nd best player ever imo)
Rob C - Amazon (Mastermind, Best confessionals of all time)
Jonathon - Cook Islands (Misunderstood mastermind)
Aras - Panama (Lets see him keep things smooth in a high concept group)
Amber - Australia (Top level of hottest ever survivors)
Dolly - Vanuatu (ditto, dumb as poo)

Group 3 -
JFP - Pearl Islands (My favourite player ever)
Brian - Thailand (Best player ever imo, Mr Freeze is in the house!)
Courtney - China (2nd best confessionals, crap player, great character)
Jon Robert - China (Just want to get these 2 back together)
Ami - Vanuatu (Villian, but can play the game, 50% hot girl)
Julie - Vanuatu (I hate UTR players, but she is very nice to look at)

 

[dmc333]

I think I'd struggle to come up with a balanced lineup.

Anyway

Tribe 1:
Shane (Panama) I'd have to add him to the Fairplay tribe, it would be gold.
Fairplay (Pearl Islands) Goes without saying
Michael (Australia) He fell in the fire, unstoppable until the accident.
Vecepia (Marquesas) We never saw this season, I add her for curiosity.
Nicole (Pearl Islands) Hottie that was voted out first. Fairplay claimed he was in with a shot at the reunion.
Christy (Amazon) Deaf chick want to see if she'd be treated as badly this time.



Tribe 2:
Robb (Thailand) Robb with 2 B's I always wished he stayed longer, he swung from outright w***er to good guy at times.
Savage (Pearl Islands) Normally my favourites are the ones who cause the most strife, but Savage was an inspiring sort of a guy. I hated Fairplay for the hand he had in his downfall. Though loved the fact when holding up his card he used The Macho Man Randy Savage's voice.
Rory (Vanuatu) An absolute loose cannon. Didn't get on with anyone, but only just missed the jury. I recall him saying something to the effect if he was double crossed "he'd burn the tribe to the ground." I don't doubt he was serious.
Danni (Guatemala) I'm not sure she did a great deal, but was a good competitor in challenges, and I could stand looking at her again.
Twila (Vanuatu) The classic old buzzard. I'd love to see her duke it out with Rory.
Amanda (China) Like to see Danni and Amanda on the same tribe, you don't often get two athletic 5'11 hunnies together.



Tribe 3:
Rocky: (Fiji) The king of straight out aggression, couldn't keep the trap shut.
Rafe: (Guatemala) The king of passive aggression and the first gay mormon.
Coby: (Australia) I love this bloke like Andy Maher loves Luke Hodge (ok not that much) I don't think he was all that exciting, but I want to see him again.
James: (China) This is purely a tribe dynamic to put James and Coby together, then have Rocky as a small big man trying to strut his stuff.
Boston Rob: (Marquesas + Allstars) Ok I'm playing funny buggers here, but I think this tribe is like dynamite, it could destroy everyone, or destroy itself.
Ami: (Vanuatu) Nothing would make me happier than to see Ami stuck on a tribe with all men, you'd have a hard time voting them all off, eh bitch?

 

[TigerGlory]

I thought Danni was the best female survivor of them all.

Great strategist, she was literally 5-1 down, and ended up winning.

Good at challenges, great mind. Top stuff imo.

 

[Smell The Glove]

If it had Jonny Fairplay, Richard Hatch and Boston Rob, it wouldnt really matter who else there is. There is your entertainment value right there.

 

[TigerGlory]

If it had Jonny Fairplay, Richard Hatch and Boston Rob, it wouldnt really matter who else there is. There is your entertainment value right there.

Judd is better than all three of them combined.

For those that arent familiar with Juddy...

[YOUTUBE]7XWrbjPWvRE[/YOUTUBE]

Thats where he got voted out, classic.

 

[raskolnikov]

I tried to make it even, girls and guys, as much as possible.

Tribe 1
Richard Hatch(Borneo)
Colby Donaldson(Australia)
Kim Powers(Africa)
Jon Dalton(Pearl Islands)
Jerri Manthey(Australia)
James(China)

Tribe 2
Kelly Wiglesworth(Borneo)
Ethan Zohn(Africa)
Yau Man Chan(Fiji)
Sandra Diaz-Twine(Pearl Islands)
Amber Brkich(Australia)
Terry Deitz(Panama)

Tribe 3
Susan Hawk(Borneo)
Lex van den Berghe(Africa)
Shi Ann Huang(Thailand)
Rupert Boneham(Pearl Islands)
Rob Mariano(Marquesas)
Amanda(China)

 

[dmc333]

After reading this, I decided to go look up Marquesas on torrents.

Just watched the first episode. Looks promising, more excitement than a lot of recent first episodes. A lot more interesting characters. The location looks good too.

I can already see why Boston Rob made Allstars. Straight up he's trying to get it on with the hot chick, cracking funnies and chasing chickens around the place.

I need to add Sarah to my list, great eye candy.

The first guy to go reminded me of David Koresh. Freaky smile and wild eyes, sounded like he was getting ready to convert people.

Anyway just thought I'd add that and it's out there available if anyone wants to d/l it.

 

[dmc333]

Judd is better than all three of them combined.

For those that arent familiar with Juddy...

[youtube]7XWrbjPWvRE[/youtube]

Thats where he got voted out, classic.

Haha man I still remember rolling around with laughter man when that happened man, what a bunch of scumbags man.

Funniest thing was, 2 minutes earlier he's sayng "someone's going home, you just have to deal with it, part of the game... blah blah"

 

[mulhollanddrive]

This is mostly accurate, but I'm sure there is the odd error. Thought I'd keep an up to date tally.

5 (out of 5) - JFP
4 - Hatch, Amanda, Rob M, James
3 - Terry, Danni, Ami, Jonathon, Todd, Colby, Yao Man.
2 - Amber, Ozzie, Parvati, Shane, Jenna M, Jerri, Brian, Rob C.
1 - Stephanie, Danielle, Judd, Jenna L, Jessica, Ryan, Twila, Yul, Earl, Dreams, Michael, Vecepia, Nicole, Christie, Robb, Kelly, Ethan, Savage, Rory, Rocky, Rafe, Kim, Sandra, Susan, Lex, Shii Ann, Rupert, Dolly, Aras, Chris, Courtney, Jon Robert, Julie.

I think every player with 2 votes or more has a great case for deserving to be there. (Although I don't get the Amanda love, glorified Becky/Danielle).

Also Rob C and Brian criminally underrated!!! Rob C is the best combination of strategist and entertainer, while Brian is the Michael Hussey of survivor, bloody got the job done without giving a single chance.

I'm glad that Rupert didnt get many votes, even though I'm biased because I love JFP, he is the most overrated character player in the history of survivor. And they gave him 1m for it too.. BOOOO.

Btw, I'm guessing if you're posting here, you're a hardcore fan, does any here post on survivorsucks?

 

[TigerGlory]

This is mostly accurate, but I'm sure there is the odd error. Thought I'd keep an up to date tally.

5 (out of 5) - JFP
4 - Hatch, Amanda, Rob M, James
3 - Terry, Danni, Ami, Jonathon, Todd, Colby, Yao Man.
2 - Amber, Ozzie, Parvati, Shane, Jenna M, Jerri, Brian, Rob C.
1 - Stephanie, Danielle, Judd, Jenna L, Jessica, Ryan, Twila, Yul, Earl, Dreams, Michael, Vecepia, Nicole, Christie, Robb, Kelly, Ethan, Savage, Rory, Rocky, Rafe, Kim, Sandra, Susan, Lex, Shii Ann, Rupert, Dolly, Aras, Chris, Courtney, Jon Robert, Julie.

I think every player with 2 votes or more has a great case for deserving to be there. (Although I don't get the Amanda love, glorified Becky/Danielle).

Also Rob C and Brian criminally underrated!!! Rob C is the best combination of strategist and entertainer, while Brian is the Michael Hussey of survivor, bloody got the job done without giving a single chance.

I'm glad that Rupert didnt get many votes, even though I'm biased because I love JFP, he is the most overrated character player in the history of survivor. And they gave him 1m for it too.. BOOOO.

Btw, I'm guessing if you're posting here, you're a hardcore fan, does any here post on survivorsucks?

I stay off the official and forum sites because they'll spoil the current series for me. I got mine off Wikipedia, without glancing at China.

Personally, there arent many actual good female players. Danni and Steph from Guatemala are the only good players imo. The ones i added were there for entertainment purposes rather than strategist.

Rob C is a poor mans Todd imo. He was a good strategist but went about the wrong way, would not stand a chance at winning from Jury votes. And was pretty poor at challenges. Toddy is an all round good player, and has a good shot at winning.

Agree about Rupert though, were plenty of players from Pearl Islands that deserved an All Stars berth ahead of him. Rhino and JFP should have been considered ahead.

 

[TigerGlory]

Haha man I still remember rolling around with laughter man when that happened man, what a bunch of scumbags man.

Funniest thing was, 2 minutes earlier he's sayng "someone's going home, you just have to deal with it, part of the game... blah blah"

I was spewin cos i was a big fan of Judd. But his confessional was great.

"Im just really pissed off, i was lied to, betrayed. And thats one thing i didnt do in this game, lie to anybody man. So i truly think your all a bunch of scumbags, and i cant wait till the final 2 man"

 

[mrs_richo]

I was spewin cos i was a big fan of Judd. But his confessional was great.

"Im just really pissed off, i was lied to, betrayed. And thats one thing i didnt do in this game, lie to anybody man. So i truly think your all a bunch of scumbags, and i cant wait till the final 2 man"

Id definitely be voting for Colby from the australian series - and Savage (cant remember what series he was on but he was the one that wore the tux). Am so over the Rob and Amber thing its sickening. Hatch is in the slammer so he wouldnt be on it. For entertainment value, ya gotta have Big Tom.

 

[TigerGlory]

Id definitely be voting for Colby from the australian series - and Savage (cant remember what series he was on but he was the one that wore the tux). Am so over the Rob and Amber thing its sickening. Hatch is in the slammer so he wouldnt be on it. For entertainment value, ya gotta have Big Tom.

Big Tom was alright, but we've seen him in an All Stars series already.

I think there are more entertainment personalities from the series post All Stars. A tribe of Judd the angry man and Shane the nutcase would keep me entertained for weeks.

Is Hatch really in the slammer? Thats a bummer. I wonder if it was for public nakedness.

 

[mrs_richo]

Big Tom was alright, but we've seen him in an All Stars series already.

I think there are more entertainment personalities from the series post All Stars. A tribe of Judd the angry man and Shane the nutcase would keep me entertained for weeks.

Is Hatch really in the slammer? Thats a bummer. I wonder if it was for public nakedness.

Yeah for not paying tax on his million dollar win on survivor.

 

[windyhill]

Rupert.
The Great Man.

 

[TigerGlory]

Yeah for not paying tax on his million dollar win on survivor.

That really is stiff lol.

 

[raikkonen]

If you could theoretically get 18 Survivors from any of the series, and plonk them in three tribes. Who would you get? Can be personal favourites, or who you thought played the best etc. Just make sure you list from which series they are, as we struggle with the earlier ones. Try and keep them seperated too, split the people from the same series up a little. Heres my take;

Tribe 1:
Hatch (Borneo & All Stars)
Steph (Guatemala & Palau)
Jon (Pearl Islands)
Danielle (Panama)
Ozzy (Cook Islands)
Amanda (China)

Tribe 2:
Judd (Guatemala)
Parvati (Cook Islands)
Shane (Panama)
Jenna (Borneo & All Stars)
James (China)
Darrah (Pearl Islands)

Tribe 3:
Terry (Panama)
Danni (Guatemala)
Todd (China)
Jerri (Australia)
Ryan O (Pearl Islands)
Jenna (Amazon & All Stars)

That was actually rather difficult.

Edits:
Ins Jerri (Australia), Darrah (Pearl Islands)
Outs Jessica (Cook Islands), Ami (Vanuatu)

Id love to do this, but I can never remember the players from the many series by name!

And a good edit there. I was in love with Darrah

 

[TigerGlory]

Id love to do this, but I can never remember the players from the many series by name!

And a good edit there. I was in love with Darrah

Wikipedia is good for this, because unless you go searching through the Survivor China page, you wont be spoiled.

It has a list of every series, and you can go through there and roughly look at the players. They normally come to mind after you hear there name.

 

[CowboyFromHell]

Criteria/role in brackets.

Group 1 -
Todd - China (Mastermind, character value)
Yao Man - Fiji (Mastermind, equal best player to never have won)
Rob M - All-Stars (Just to prove against strong player, he's mediocre)
Parvati - Cook Islands (Good looking and has some character value)
Chris - Vanuatu (Just to prove it was an accident)
Danni - Guatamala (Can she do it again)

Group 2 -
Hatch - Borneo (2nd best player ever imo)
Rob C - Amazon (Mastermind, Best confessionals of all time)
Jonathon - Cook Islands (Misunderstood mastermind)
Aras - Panama (Lets see him keep things smooth in a high concept group)
Amber - Australia (Top level of hottest ever survivors)
Dolly - Vanuatu (ditto, dumb as poo)

Group 3 -
JFP - Pearl Islands (My favourite player ever)
Brian - Thailand (Best player ever imo, Mr Freeze is in the house!)
Courtney - China (2nd best confessionals, crap player, great character)
Jon Robert - China (Just want to get these 2 back together)
Ami - Vanuatu (Villian, but can play the game, 50% hot girl)
Julie - Vanuatu (I hate UTR players, but she is very nice to look at)

Are you saying that Chris winning Vanuatu was an accident? Apart from the very first immunity challenge when he stuffed up he dominated from start to end. He knew EXACTLY what he was doing. No accident.

 

[Magnum27]

I'll have a crack at this. I'm not pickiny any past winners becuase they wouldn't stand a chance.

I'm also going for 2 teams of 11 rather than 3 small teams.


TEAM 1

Rob C - Amazon / Strategist up there with the best of them
Jean Robert - China/ Thinks he's a strategist,and would interesting to see how he and Rob interact
Terry- Panama / Uncomprising and would mix well with Clay
Clay - Thailand / Old schooler do things my way or no way, would sy what he thinks regardless of the consequences.
Shane - Panama / Crazy guy who constantly lost the plot, i'm sure him and Courtney would go well together.
James- Palau/ Just didn't deal well with people, and like Clay wouldn't hold back
Coutrney- Panama / She of the rock garden, absolute nutter on the show.
Amy- Vanuatu/ Angry female who didn't mind conflict and would get that here.
Peigh Gee- China / Whilst she annoyed me, at least she'd provide a spark
Eliza- Vanuatu / Fiery little minx who's always up for an arguement
Stephanie- PaluaGuatemala / Maybe her and Peigh gee could compare notes about losing rewards all the time.

TEAM 2

Bobby Jon - Palau
James- China
Clarence - Africa
Jonathon- Cook Islands
Judd- Guatemala
Rory- Vanuatu
Amanda - China
Darrah- Pearl Islands
Danielle- Panama
Jamie- China
Jennifer- Palau

In this team you have 3 males that would try and out do each other physically, ( Bobby Jon/James and Clarence). Three guys that would fire up at the drop of the hat ( Jonathan/Rory and Judd). Whilst all the ladies are tidy to look at, they all went quite deep into the game, and being all decent looking couldn't use that to advantage with the guys.

 

[wce4premiership]

Never really watched it before.

But if they had some of the following people i would:

Amanda bynes
jennifer hawkins
mila kunis
britney spears (comedic value)
emily scott
dannny green
anthony mundine (just to see if anything happens)
jennifer aniston
angelina jolie
brad pitt
rachel bilson

 

[Power21]

Are you saying that Chris winning Vanuatu was an accident? Apart from the very first immunity challenge when he stuffed up he dominated from start to end. He knew EXACTLY what he was doing. No accident.

I agree, one of the great wins.