Sydney Swans Board POTY 2008 - Voting Thread - Round 4 vs West Coast

Remove this Banner Ad

5. ROK
4. Ablett
3. Moore
2. Jack
1. McVeigh

Honourable mentions to everyone. We all played well, though some awful clangers made by Brennan and oh... Bazza. :mad:
 

Log in to remove this ad.

5. ROK (tapered off but was on fire early when it mattered)
4. MOL (Magic at his best)
3. Teddy (Playing with confidence)
2. Jack (Shut down job fantastic on Kerr)
1. Goodes (Showing signs - watch out!)
 
ROK didnt do it for me tonight. Really good marking prescence and leading up around the ground but his conversion rate this season is borderline embarrasing, we shouldnt be embracing mediocrity in front of goal.
 
5 Tadhg
4 Goodes
3 MOL
2 McHack (he's gonna hack you into pieces :))
1 Ryan

*Changed it a little because I just watched the replay.
 
SouthSwans said:
ROK didnt do it for me tonight. Really good marking prescence and leading up around the ground but his conversion rate this season is borderline embarrasing, we shouldnt be embracing mediocrity in front of goal.
Click to expand...


Agree, howwever he was still fantastic ain all other aspects including his contested amrks and other contesed football. He was still pretty good.

5 T.Kennelly
4 B.Kirk
3 R.O'Keefe
2 M.O'Louglan
1 K.Jack

Apologies to Mattner, Richards, J.Bolton and Goodes.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

What a fantastic bloody game to watch.

5. Kirk - leads the rest of the team by example with fantastic work at the contests
4. Kennelly - surely with the addition of Mattner we are the best rebounding team in the competition now
3. Jack - crucified Kerr, isn't he such an important part of the side now
2. O'Loughlin - used his body brilliantly to kick important goals
1. O'Keefe
 
bedford said:
5.mattner
4.goodes
3.kennelly
2.jack
1.o'keefe

a lot of apologies
mchack needs to hold a tackle,great team effort very hard to give votes
Click to expand...

mcvague was good again, but yeah, just a few little things to iron out
but i can't fault his application and workrate, he's going in much harder than he ever has
mattner did some great, brave things but he still gives it up with poor disposal from time to time (not as bad as brennan)
marty's very strong, though
kirk was outstanding again, and yes, ROK's kicking for goal is bad but he's a sensational player
 
5 Kennelly - purposeful run and delivery from the backline
4 Goodes - not vintage but some excellent, goal creating work at times
3 Teddy - super game on Hansen
2 Jack - cutting Kerr's influence out almost completely and contributing himself
1 Micky O - not dominant but took his chances well

Unlucky - Leapin' Leo, Jolly, McVeigh, Kirk
 
5. Tadgh (Ran off HB all night).
4. Jack (9 tackles & a goal - took Kerr right out of the game - brilliant).
3. Big Ted (Loving his work at the moment).
2. Micky O (Made the most of opportunities and got us off to a great start).
1. ROK (would have liked to see 4 goals 1 rather than 1 goal 4)!

Apologies to Mattner - was great but foot skills hurt a bit at times.
 
5. Goodes
4. Tiger
3. Teddy
2. Jack (high numbers, killed Kerr most of the night AND scored a goal!!!)
1. Magic
 
I was at the game. Haven't seen a replay or read any reviews, but from my seat at ground level:
5- Goodes. Looked brilliant. The dominant player on the ground.
4 - O'Keefe. Took a heap of contested marks again. Gives us a real avenue to goal.
3 - Richards. Beat his man pointless and was fearless backing into contests.
2 - Jack. Kerr was invisible so he must've played well.
1 - Kennelly. So fast, composed and elusive.

Luke Brennan started well and did some good things, although the young eagle forward kicked some goals on him. He and Grundy are virtually interchangable it would seem. Nothing between them.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top