Tankthorn

[peetoo]

Irrelevant to Vic Clubs. WOnder what a combined 22 would look like - 11 from each Club

Back in the crazy merger days, the other clubs really arced up at merged clubs having unlimited choices from the two donor teams

 

[Grand Uncle Horace]

Back in the crazy merger days, the other clubs really arced up at merged clubs having unlimited choices from the two donor teams

But now a combined Norf/Hawf could not beat mid ranked rubbish like Blews and Pomdogs

 

[peetoo]

But now a combined Norf/Hawf could not beat mid ranked rubbish like Blews and Pomdogs

I completely dispute that, of course. In fact not improbable either could beat either

 

[Grand Uncle Horace]

I completely dispute that, of course. In fact not improbable either could beat either

Interesting exercise... Need a school yard taking turns exercise to select the combine. You could do Hawf and uh oh ... There is always a shortage of Norf fans

 

[peetoo]

Interesting exercise... Need a school yard taking turns exercise to select the combine. You could do Hawf and uh oh ... There is always a shortage of Norf fans

Would sheils and Howe get a game?

 

[Grand Uncle Horace]

Would sheils and Howe get a game?

Lucky I was not swallowing coffee when I read that.

 

[peetoo]

Lucky I was not swallowing coffee when I read that.

You were the one suggesting any two combined lists wouldn’t be competitive. They would dominate.

 

[Grand Uncle Horace]

You were the one suggesting any two combined lists wouldn’t be competitive. They would dominate.

Apologies. I thought you were being funny.

Why don't you come up with a combined team you think would beat Carlton. You can't select more than 11 Hawfs and must also select 11 Norf players. Good luck with the latter.

 

[peetoo]

Apologies. I thought you were being funny.

Why don't you come up with a combined team you think would beat Carlton. You can't select more than 11 Hawfs and must also select 11 Norf players. Good luck with the latter.

Carlton? I give hawthorn a good chance of beating them anyway,

I’m saying the combination would be a top 4 team. Winning week after week

 

[Grand Uncle Horace]

Carlton? I give hawthorn a good chance of beating them anyway,

I’m saying the combination would be a top 4 team. Winning week after week

You are a legend. Give us this combined team

 

[HairyO]

Would sheils and Howe get a game?

Is Clarko or Mitchell the coach?

Clarko would have Shiels on the bench.

 

[HairyO]

Backs- Sicily, Logue, McKay, Scrimshaw, CJ, Hardwick

Mids- LDU, Sheezel, Amon, Newcombe, Simpkin Goldy

Forwards- Lewis, Larkey, Zurhar, Breust, Stephenson, Moore

Int- McDonald, Reeves, Worpel, Shiels/Cunnington

Very unlucky: Powell, Ward, and probably 2 or 3 others.

Pretty sure the big holes in the Roos team are filled by Hawks, and the big holes in the Hawks team are filled by Roos.

2 teams where we dont really share strengths and weaknesses so the combined is massively greater than the separate.

 

[peetoo]

I don’t know or care about north players much, but looked at fantasy points and sheils is fairly high up there

I’m saying a combined team from any two would be a top 4 candidate…beating carlton is too easy a benchmark.

A top 4 team would expect to use 30 or so players.

So I’m taking hawthorns best 22 plus sheezel, LDU, Goldstein, zurharr, Larkey, MacDonald, Cunnington, hall, greenwood McKay


But really it’s anything in the salary cap era…that’s the point. 1930s saints and hawks combined aren’t doing much but throw the best after parties

 

[Feraligatr]

Can you accuse a team of tanking if they are genuinely rubbish?

 

[Footy Is The Win]

Can you accuse a team of tanking if they are genuinely rubbish?

You can be both.

 

[crazywildhorse]

Because any team can go from 17th to a prelim without handouts if they're good enough.

If the land the greatest father/son of all time in the draft

 

[Footy Is The Win]

Last two mins: Crows come up clutch to edge brave Hawks

Enjoy the thrilling final moments between Adelaide and Hawthorn in Launceston

www.afl.com.au

Keep on Tanking