News Taylor Adams coming to Pies? Hine: "Yeah, I think so"

What do you reckon about this drawn out trade?


  • Total voters
    45

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
What is your rationale and have you watched a lot of Adams?

I've gone back and watched a fair few GWS games from this year and everything I watch is top notch. Really really excited by the prospect of him joining the team.

My rationale is that I don't rate him very highly and yes, I have watched a lot of GWS games this year.
I don't think he is anything worth going for.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Barrett just mentioned a "spanner in the works" in the Adams to Pies deal.. But didn't elaborate.
I'm sure it will come up shortly.

Oh boy...Dave going to flip his $hit!!!!!!!!!!
 
We have GWS by the balls, we can keep Shaw if worst came to worst, GWS risk losing ADams to the draft, there will be some pissed off people if GWS pass up a reasonable trade and end up getting nothing considering all the concessions they've been given.
 
We have GWS by the balls, we can keep Shaw if worst came to worst, GWS risk losing ADams to the draft, there will be some pissed off people if GWS pass up a reasonable trade and end up getting nothing considering all the concessions they've been given.

Geelong want him as well. Best case scenario for him :)
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Was mentioned earlier on. Barrett has stated Pies are holding the deal up as we are insisting on a straight swap or we want extra.
Wouldn't that mean GWS are stalling the deal as they want more?

If we want extra then that would be great negotiating as we can then begrudgingly drop our demand and accept a straight swap.
 
Barrett just mentioned a "spanner in the works" in the Adams to Pies deal.. But didn't elaborate.
I'm sure it will come up shortly.

What is the Ambulance Chaser Barret Have?

Could it be the Deal that we are doing with West Coast? or Adams has Changed his Mind and Wants to go to Geelong:(
 
I'm over this. I would be happy to keep Shaw then get the pick 6 and Jesse White trades done tonight.

The Giants would look like idiots if we did that.
 
Wouldn't that mean GWS are stalling the deal as they want more?

If we want extra then that would be great negotiating as we can then begrudgingly drop our demand and accept a straight swap.

Barrett will always take the anti Pies stance - he said it as though he thinks we are being unreasonable.
 
GWS seem to be labouring under the impression that they have the only game in town :rolleyes:

This REEKS of Sheedy's B/S

So screw him and them if they dig their heels in, send Shaw to Geelong and take the 15 and go to the draft for another inside mid.

Then they can go to the AFL AND their sponsers AND their 25 fans and explain how they managed to screw up a perfectly reasonable trade for a player they desperately needed who actually WANTED to come to thier shit stain of a club :mad:

Lol rant over, the board will probs tell Sheedy to pull his ugly head in and the deal will go through :cool:
 
GWS seem to be labouring under the impression that they have the only game in town :rolleyes:

This REEKS of Sheedy's B/S

So screw him and them if they dig their heels in, send Shaw to Geelong and take the 15 and go to the draft for another inside mid.

Then they can go to the AFL AND their sponsers AND their 25 fans and explain how they managed to screw up a perfectly reasonable trade for a player they desperately needed who actually WANTED to come to thier shit stain of a club :mad:

Lol rant over, the board will probs tell Sheedy to pull his ugly head in and the deal will go through :cool:
Do you really think sheedy runs our list management?
 
Geelong want him as well. Best case scenario for him :)

I wasn't fussed if we got him or not before today, I thought it was either going to be Adams or pick 9 for Shaw, now pick 9s gone Adams for Shaw is the best case scenario for us IMO, unless we keep Shaw of course.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top