The 2013 'Which Player Should I Start On The Field?' Thread (TWPSISOTFT)

[lmach]

I'll kick it off...

B.Goodes v Stevenson?

 

[toxic]

I'll kick it off...

B.Goodes v Stevenson?

Stevenson.

omeara v viney??

 

[Suma Magic]

Stevenson.

omeara v viney??

OMeara.

My bench decisions:

D6: Goodes
B: Pittard, Stevenson

M6-8: Whitfield, Wines, OMeara
B: Viney, Mitchell

R2: Smith
B: Blicavs, Currie

F6: Macaffer
B: Neade, Rowe

 

[hodge = gun]

Wines (?) v Kommer (60)? I could use the partial lockout loophole.

 

[VSTone]

Wines (?) v Kommer (60)? I could use the partial lockout loophole.

76 for wines in the pre-season game agst the dees

 

[Krujan]

76 for wines in the pre-season game agst the dees

Dees had like only 3-4 players that are playing today.

 

[Krujan]

The only 2 starting spots I'm still grappling with is

Jones v Viney v Rampe
Macaffer v Dwyer v Neade

Have Jones & Dwyer ATM as I think they would score the best but both would be sub candidates...thoughts?

 

[VSTone]

Dees had like only 3-4 players that are playing today.

yeah - good point, i'm not going with wines so it doesn't bother me too much anyway.

 

[VSTone]

The only 2 starting spots I'm still grappling with is

Jones v Viney v Rampe
Macaffer v Dwyer v Neade

Have Jones & Dwyer ATM as I think they would score the best but both would be sub candidates...thoughts?

going Macaffer and Omeara here with Kommer (emg)

 

[Crawb]

2 out of Pittard, Stevenson and Goodes.

Goodes and Stevenson have been more consistent over the NAB Cup and look like a safe bet for 60-70 type score. Pittard seems to have the higher ceiling...but I don't think he'll be producing a 100 too often...and the rest of his NAB scores weren't great.

 

[CrozaN]

2 out of Pittard, Stevenson and Goodes.

Goodes and Stevenson have been more consistent over the NAB Cup and look like a safe bet for 60-70 type score. Pittard seems to have the higher ceiling...but I don't think he'll be producing a 100 too often...and the rest of his NAB scores weren't great.

I'm going Goodes and Pittard.

 

[Keystone agony]

76 for wines in the pre-season game agst the Casey scorpions

Edit for accuracy

 

[CrozaN]

Edit for accuracy

lold

 

[Keystone agony]

Deleted.

 

[Krujan]

I'm going Goodes and Pittard.

I'm starting Goodes, Pittard & Stevenson (Heath (E), Colquhoun)

LOL 4 Port players in my team, which is more Port players than I've had in the previous 3 years combined.

 

[pillager]

Look who hes picking everyone

The guy who is a spud and he will not touch. That lasted long obviousily another rash/late decision he has made.

Why not go Patton if hes such a spud (macaffer) or why not just have 6 non forward rookies playing if hes such a spud (macaffer)

????

Can the mods please deal with this guy?

The Red Festival is calling you Keystone.

 

[VSTone]

Can the mods please deal with this guy?

The Red Festival is calling you Keystone.

play on i reckon - he gives a touch better than he gets...

 

[Keystone agony]

Can the mods please deal with this guy?

The Red Festival is calling you Keystone.

Only pointing out facts he said he woul .in no way pick.macaffer and than.he did because he was a spud. i offered alternatives to the macaffer pick aswell is this okay SJ

 

[Krujan]

Ended up starting Dwyer over Macaffer...may live to regret it, the way my round has gone so far.

 

[FlowersByIrene]

Stevenson.

omeara v viney??

Did you start Goodes??

 

[toxic]

Did you start Goodes??

Started both, plus some more rookies

 

[Jessbek]

Lol at the title.

Two out of O'Meara, Embley and Viney.

 

[Krujan]

Lol at the title.

Two out of O'Meara, Embley and Viney.

I too would like thoughts on this conundrum.

 

[Jessbek]

I too would like thoughts on this conundrum.

My first thoughts were Embley and Viney.. yours?

 

[Krujan]

My first thoughts were Embley and Viney.. yours?

Same sir