Opinion 2024 Fantasy - Player X vs Y vs Z

[Anzac16]

Touk + Salem vs Wines + Sheezel

I think the first goes bigger and has more upside but Wines and Sheezel feels much safer given the early byes.

I'm really keen on Touk getting back to a 110 average this year.

 

[Pure Grunt]

Touk + Salem vs Wines + Sheezel

I think the first goes bigger and has more upside but Wines and Sheezel feels much safer given the early byes.

I'm really keen on Touk getting back to a 110 average this year.

Keen on Touk for round 4
I’d go Sheez & Wines

 

[Anzac16]

Keen on Touk for round 4
I’d go Sheez & Wines

Thanks yeah probably leaning more that way now.

Another one in playing around this morning -

Newcombe + Campbell (Lazzaro on field)
vs
Jackson + Windsor (Roberts on field)

Like getting the DPP flex in the mids and Roberts on the ground. Jackson should score well the first four weeks.

But really like Newcombe to break out and is more a season keeper than Jackson.

 

[Gumby2Hurley]

Down to the last 2 positions i'm unsure with.
currently have:
NWM and Houston
i could get Sheezel and Young if i turn Cadman into a 200k utility that excludes campbell.

 

[Pure Grunt]

Thanks yeah probably leaning more that way now.

Another one in playing around this morning -

Newcombe + Campbell (Lazzaro on field)
vs
Jackson + Windsor (Roberts on field)

Like getting the DPP flex in the mids and Roberts on the ground. Jackson should score well the first four weeks.

But really like Newcombe to break out and is more a season keeper than Jackson.

Understand the flexibility need but I think it’s Newcombe.
You don’t want to plan to burn trades early when loads of issues will come.
Some good commentary says Jackson trade will be in rookie upgrade season
Would go Jackson on if you got Grawndy combo.

 

[Pure Grunt]

Down to the last 2 positions i'm unsure with.
currently have:
NWM and Houston
i could get Sheezel and Young if i turn Cadman into a 200k utility that excludes campbell.

I’d go Sheez/Young. Fwd 200k in Mannagh & D. Jones
May not be named Rd1 but will be.

 

[hjckr]

Down to the last 2 positions i'm unsure with.
currently have:
NWM and Houston
i could get Sheezel and Young if i turn Cadman into a 200k utility that excludes campbell.

Can get Sheez and Young if you go for McMullin? Sub risk but he's looked good and might get to play a full game with Ward out.

 

[The Golden Glenferrie]

D'Ambrosio and Luke Jackson
Or
George Hewett and Yeo

Hewett and Yeo

Sheezel + Z.Williams + L.Jackson
or
Whitfield + Budarick + Heeney

Option 1 means bye players of 1/2/4/3
Option 2 means bye players of 0/4/5/3

Option 1

Can’t decide if downgrading 3 players to upgrade to one Uber premo and reducing my bye players is worth it?

1: Z Williams, Gawn, Jackson, Lazzaro
2: Coffield, English, Rankine, Cadman (Wilson move onfield).

Points wise I think it will be quite similar but option 2 perhaps a greater risk.

Benefit is getting English but is it worth the expense?

yes, he's worth it

L Jackson and Robert’s on field

Or

Crouch and Windsor on field

LJ and Robs

Touk + Salem vs Wines + Sheezel

I think the first goes bigger and has more upside but Wines and Sheezel feels much safer given the early byes.

I'm really keen on Touk getting back to a 110 average this year.

Took and Salem

 

[The Golden Glenferrie]

Bonner + McMullin

vs

McKercher and Lazzaro

 

[Gumby2Hurley]

Can get Sheez and Young if you go for McMullin? Sub risk but he's looked good and might get to play a full game with Ward out.

yep it has to be a 200k player, used every dollar. cheers

 

[Pure Grunt]

Bonner + McMullin

vs

McKercher and Lazzaro

Assuming all onfield. B
Less risk imo.

 

[The Golden Glenferrie]

Assuming all onfield. B
Less risk imo.

Sorry, assuming makes an ass of u and me

McKerch on field, Laz bench (ATM)

Bonner on field, mcmuffin bench

 

[Pure Grunt]

Sorry, assuming makes an ass of u and me

McKerch on field, Laz bench (ATM)

Bonner on field, mcmuffin bench

A for cash gen & loop option
B for early points
Dependant on the Bacon n Egg

 

[Shaunn]

Still contemplating playing Roberts onfield for 3 mid rookies and downgrading a Wines/Crouch to Xerri at R3. basically will be losing 20-30 points a round but make alot of cash and gain back abit of it over rounds 5 and 6, just not sure how much.

 

[Pure Grunt]

Still contemplating playing Roberts onfield for 3 mid rookies and downgrading a Wines/Crouch to Xerri at R3. basically will be losing 20-30 points a round but make alot of cash and gain back abit of it over rounds 5 and 6, just not sure how much.

At a guess he should be + 180k by then
Priced at 65 then averages 85
Every 10 pt ave = 90k

 

[DukeX]

Purely for arguments sake:
Wines & Butters vs Crouch & Newc?

 

[Shaunn]

At a guess he should be + 180k by then
Priced at 65 then averages 85
Every 10 pt ave = 90k

I think if Roberts goes 65-70?, Wines 90-95 i'd be losing 25 points a round for 4 rounds = 100. the two rounds Xerri plays over a 50 score just say for 2 rounds we make back 55-65 i think? Could be abit less.

So we're losing 35-45ish points till round 6 but making cash from an extra rook and Xerri.

I feel like that could be worth it if im calculating it correctly.

 

[Shaunn]

Bont and Crouch
or
Dawson and Amon

 

[bettingonbetts]

Bont and Crouch
or
Dawson and Amon

Dawson Amon

 

[whattagun07]

Crouch and Jordon (fwd)

Or

Jackson (fwd) and Jordon/Bonner (mid)

 

[Catastrophe!]

Hypothetically:


Whitfield and Fyfe

vs

Butters and Budarick

 

[whattagun07]

2: Bont+Wines(+~5k) or Newcombe+Steele(+~40k)

bont wines for mine

 

[Wels Eicke]

Hypothetically:


Whitfield and Fyfe

vs

Butters and Budarick

I like Whitfield and Fyfe. Whitfield looks like he could be a top three defender this year, injury dependant of course.

My question: Libba vs Rozee. I would pick both, but Gulden would have to make way. Not sure I want to do that though.

 

[bettingonbetts]

I like Whitfield and Fyfe. Whitfield looks like he could be a top three defender this year, injury dependant of course.

My question: Libba vs Rozee. I would pick both, but Gulden would have to make way. Not sure I want to do that though.

Get rid of Gulden. He’s gonna drop significantly and he’s got a bye. However, he’s a pretty unique pick now so stick to it if you want

 

[Milo Cyrus]

Crouch and Jordon (fwd)

Or

Jackson (fwd) and Jordon/Bonner (mid)