Oppo Camp The Non-North Footy Discussion & Matchday Chat Thread V

[muttley45]

You know umpiring is bad when Darcy and Ling are saying it, multiple times, Razor's last appearance for the year surely.

 

[astrovic]

No, it's not against the rules, especially what they were actually doing, they weren't striking him, they were just grabbing at his arm.

If he steps back out on the field he's saying he's good to go. Can't be officiated to different rules than other players

No, that line applies to a player who makes himself available for selection (if you put your hand up for selection, you’re good to go), not a player injured mid match who grits the teeth and gets back out there.

Cameron isn’t “good to go”, he’s toughing it out. Good on him.

 

[DarkPhoenix]

No, that line applies to a player who makes himself available for selection (if you put your hand up for selection, you’re good to go), not a player injured mid match who grits the teeth and gets back out there.

Cameron isn’t “good to go”, he’s toughing it out. Good on him.

You don't get officiated to different rules if you're injured.

Frees must still be officiated to an equal level.
If a strike to the arm requires to be a 5 on a scale of 1-10 for a free, that doesn't suddenly get lowered to a 2 for someone who has an arm injury.

If you decide to go back out there, you're agreeing to be umpired to the same rules.

 

[giantroo]

 

[SpiderBurton22]

View attachment 746143

So the umpire is correct.

 

[DarkPhoenix]

View attachment 746143

It wasn't unreasonable or excessive contact is the issue.

It was an arm grab that players receive 100 times a match

 

[sutcliffe's hotel]

So the umpire is correct.

Was that changed following the Brisbane player at the Gabba ramming into the injured shoulder of Riewoldt?

 

[Boomerfan99]

F&$$ you Cameron.

 

[koshari]

Green takes on 2 tacklers and drops ball, play on, brisbane player gets tackled where the tackle dislodges the ball.... gone.

 

[Devington]

Green takes on 2 tacklers and drops ball, play on, brisbane player gets tackled where the tackle dislodges the ball.... gone.

Looked to me like Green actually got a kick of sorts off.
And generally I'm loathe to defend the bloke.

 

[Ry009]

Wasn't Darcy the one who lynched Scooter for his niggling of Barry Hall, a player who was in no way injured?

 

[rooboyy]

Terribly umpired game. Brisbane getting a lot of ‘nothing’ frees.

 

[koshari]

Still waiting for the continuation of the "rayner is built for finals" malarky.

 

[rooboyy]

View attachment 746143

On this unreasonable or unnecessary contact rule, My understanding/logic would be if the player has just been injured and is with doctors, is laying on the ground injured or running off to go and get treated and contact is made then that’s fair but if you get treated and come back on you are considered not injured.

 

[Boomerfan99]

Terribly umpired game. Brisbane getting a lot of ‘nothing’ frees.

So are GWS.

 

[rooboyy]

So are GWS.

Brisbane ‘fans’ complaining about every free though, making out they are hard done by.

 

[astrovic]

You don't get officiated to different rules if you're injured.

Frees must still be officiated to an equal level.
If a strike to the arm requires to be a 5 on a scale of 1-10 for a free, that doesn't suddenly get lowered to a 2 for someone who has an arm injury.

If you decide to go back out there, you're agreeing to be umpired to the same rules.

Including the rule that says you can’t make unreasonable contact with an injured player.

The unreasonable part is targeting the injured body part. No one is saying he should be untouchable, that he can’t be tackled or hit hard in a marking contest, but whacking his injured arm while running back to position is targeting the injury and unreasonable.

 

[Reagan Smash]

'Everybody look at me'
Ray Chamberlin

 

[Reagan Smash]

Go Manly !

 

[Hojuman]

Go Manly !

Better choice outta two bad choices RS.

It's the Roosters to lose after Storm effort this afternoon.

 

[SpiderBurton22]

Toby Greene is a stupid campaigner, learn your ****ing lesson.

 

[Hearts to hearts]

Go Manly !

Never never never never never Manly. Imagine Collingwood and Carlton had a bastard child. Big and rich and hideous.

 

[rooboyy]

How was that deliberate out of bounds? and that was just a throw not a handball which set up hipwoods goal.

 

[SpiderBurton22]

Umpires have been whistle happy all night. Watch them put it away with 5 minutes to go and let a blatant free go unpenalised.

 

[Devington]

Toby Greene is a stupid campaigner, learn your ******* lesson.

Glad to know I didn't imagine it. How ****ing dumb is he to do that after being pinged just last week.