The reward for Carlton tanking and losing all respect

[super_phaser]

The next Josh Fraser and a 25 year old with a stuffed groin

Well done, Carlton. Bringing the game into disrepute, ruining the image of our great game... and all you got was the above mentioned table scraps. You sure give us plenty of ammuniton, you pathetic rabble.



Ratten and Pratt = dumb and dumber

 

[Bluez]

The next Josh Fraser and a 25 year old with a stuffed groin

Well done, Carlton. Bringing the game into disrepute, ruining the image of our great game... and all you got was the above mentioned table scraps. You sure give us plenty of ammuniton, you pathetic rabble.



Ratten and Pratt = dumb and dumber

our great game? who is us? you dont even show who you barrack for...probably not even a member of a club...go watch NBA

 

[super_phaser]

our great game? who is us? you dont even show who you barrack for...probably not even a member of a club...go watch NBA

Melbourne

And a member for 15 straight years

 

[Bluez]

Melbourne

And a member for 15 straight years

rofl

 

[Stig O'Hara]

What more do you pelicans want?

Disband the bloody club?

Christ, we have been down the bottom for years,
admitted we stuffed up,
and now based on a sacked clipboard monitors "feelings",
are conspirators in a major fraud.

11 wins 2 draws in the last 66 games.

Get real.

 

[GETSOMENUTS]

What more do you pelicans want?

Disband the bloody club?

Christ, we have been down the bottom for years,
admitted we stuffed up,
and now based on sacked clipboard monitors "feelings",
are conspirators in a major fraud.

11 wins 2 draws in the last 66 games.

Get real.

Its time for the blues fans on BF to get real. Im not trying to stick the boot in, but all you carlton lot trying to talk this down as a non- issue is pretty ordinary. Im not gonna get on my soap box cause im sure my club did it as well, just saying that everyone knows u blokes cheated your way to land judd and that the word of a bloke in the box carries signifigant weight.

 

[sherb]

The next Josh Fraser and a 25 year old with a stuffed groin

Well done, Carlton. Bringing the game into disrepute, ruining the image of our great game... and all you got was the above mentioned table scraps. You sure give us plenty of ammuniton, you pathetic rabble.

Ratten and Pratt = dumb and dumber

As a new member, it might be of assistance to you to read the forum rules prior to this thread rightfully being moved to Bay 13.

In particular, the bits about the AFL Board, Bay 13 and starting threads re topics already being discussed (point 3).

 

[super_phaser]

As a new member, it might be of assistance to you to read the forum rules prior to this thread rightfully being moved to Bay 13.

In particular, the bits about the AFL Board, Bay 13 and starting threads re topics already being discussed (point 3).

Well they are going to have to change the rules for me

 

[Bluez]

Its time for the blues fans on BF to get real. Im not trying to stick the boot in, but all you carlton lot trying to talk this down as a non- issue is pretty ordinary. Im not gonna get on my soap box cause im sure my club did it as well, just saying that everyone knows u blokes cheated your way to land judd and that the word of a bloke in the box carries signifigant weight.

cheated to get Judd?

prey tell how did we cheat? we cheated by breaking no rules to get the PP and pick one in the draft?
nice try einy

 

[sherb]

Well they are going to have to change the rules for me

Suuuuuuuuure..................

 

[Stig O'Hara]

Its time for the blues fans on BF to get real. Im not trying to stick the boot in, but all you carlton lot trying to talk this down as a non- issue is pretty ordinary. Im not gonna get on my soap box cause im sure my club did it as well, just saying that everyone knows u blokes cheated your way to land judd and that the word of a bloke in the box carries signifigant weight.

Judd wasn't even on the table. He was still limping around for WC.

It really depends on what you define 'tanking' as.

The AFL hasn't, so it is not an issue.

However, if betting is involved then it is Italian soccer time.
and I heard of no significant plunges late last year.

 

[GETSOMENUTS]

cheated to get Judd?

prey tell how did we cheat? we cheated by breaking no rules to get the PP and pick one in the draft?
nice try einy

Sorry I will clarify-
cheating= tanked
tanking= guarenteed priority pick
guarenteed priority pick= upper hand in judd trade talks.
As I said Bluez I am not trying to sink the boot in or get on my high horse just saying that blues fans on BF are very quick to talk this stuff down as a non-issue.

 

[Bluez]

Sorry I will clarify-
cheating= tanked
tanking= guarenteed priority pick
guarenteed priority pick= upper hand in judd trade talks.
As I said Bluez I am not trying to sink the boot in or get on my high horse just saying that blues fans on BF are very quick to talk this stuff down as a non-issue.

The AFL rules permit a team to tank..unless they change it it will continue to happen, therefore thats not cheating..its minipulising the draft..like what has been stated before..Carlton are not the only team to have tanked.
edit: if anything, blame the AFL

 

[Kochie 16]

Well they are going to have to change the rules for me

I would pay for tickets to see you tell that to Chief

 

[GETSOMENUTS]

Judd wasn't even on the table. He was still limping around for WC.

It really depends on what you define 'tanking' as.

The AFL hasn't, so it is not an issue.

However, if betting is involved then it is Italian soccer time.

You are naive if you think Judd wasnt in carltons sights at that stage. Swann talked him into coming home to melbourne the season before when Swann was still with Collingwood. Judd even stated at his Carlton press confrence that a major reason for his decision in choosing carlton was greg swann. Make of that what u will.

 

[Ebert80]

The AFL rules permit a team to tank..unless they change it it will continue to happen, therefore thats not cheating..its minipulising the draft..like what has been stated before..Carlton are not the only team to have tanked.
edit: if anything, blame the AFL

Anyone got a dictionary?

 

[Cruiser23]

Sorry I will clarify-
cheating= tanked
tanking= guarenteed priority pick
guarenteed priority pick= upper hand in judd trade talks.
As I said Bluez I am not trying to sink the boot in or get on my high horse just saying that blues fans on BF are very quick to talk this stuff down as a non-issue.

I don't understand how any supporter can have pot shot at our for BENDING the rules, for the last time, we never cheated. What we did, was exactly what most clubs have done in the past including your club. As many knowledgeable people has said, people like you should be aiming their frustration at the AFL. Your team would have done the same put in our situation.

 

[Bluez]

Anyone got a dictionary?

manipulising....that better Mr Spellcheck?

 

[Stig O'Hara]

You are naive if you think Judd wasnt in carltons sights at that stage. Swann talked him into coming home to melbourne the season before when Swann was still with Collingwood. Judd even stated at his Carlton press confrence that a major reason for his decision in choosing carlton was greg swann. Make of that what u will.

Sunshine, i knew what was going on.

How many times do you think Ben Ruttens phone has rung in the last 48 hours? Everyone is up for grabs no-matter what people read.

The sad thing for your lot, is that our presentation was better than yours,
and 2 other prominent Melbourne based clubs, and Judd named us,
and a deal was made.
so we must have done something right.

What is your point?

 

[Beloved]

The next Josh Fraser and a 25 year old with a stuffed groin

Well done, Carlton. Bringing the game into disrepute, ruining the image of our great game... and all you got was the above mentioned table scraps. You sure give us plenty of ammuniton, you pathetic rabble.



Ratten and Pratt = dumb and dumber

Still on with the Judd not being able to play due to a groin injury eh? Bottom of the barrel mate, it's been cleared 100 times.

 

[Ninja]

The next Josh Fraser and a 25 year old with a stuffed groin

Well done, Carlton. Bringing the game into disrepute, ruining the image of our great game... and all you got was the above mentioned table scraps. You sure give us plenty of ammuniton, you pathetic rabble.



Ratten and Pratt = dumb and dumber

so let me guess.....................still just a little miffed about missing out on Juddy?

suffer moron

and by the way, when did you ever respect Carlton (note, there is a difference between respect and envy)

 

[GETSOMENUTS]

Sunshine, i knew what was going on.

How many times do you think Ben Ruttens phone has rung in the last 48 hours? Everyone is up for grabs no-matter what people read.

The sad thing for your lot, is that our presentation was better than yours,
and 2 other prominent Melbourne based clubs, and Judd named us,
and a deal was made.
so we must have done something right.

What is your point?

I dont know how many times can the blues footy dept. call in that time?
As I said Judd was going to Carlton all the time and his "charade" of interviewing the other clubs was just a media stunt. Thats old news anyway. My point from the original post was that Libbas word carries signifigant weight and its poor form from blues fans on BF to try to discredit the bloke purely for the fact that he had the balls to say what everyone already knew.
And yes it is the AFLs fault for allowing tanking- even if Vlad reckons it isnt happening.

 

[Effes]

You are naive if you think Judd wasnt in carltons sights at that stage. Swann talked him into coming home to melbourne the season before when Swann was still with Collingwood. Judd even stated at his Carlton press confrence that a major reason for his decision in choosing carlton was greg swann. Make of that what u will.

It's a damn shame that Swann moved to Carlton then isn't it

 

[Stig O'Hara]

I dont know how many times can the blues footy dept. call in that time?
As I said Judd was going to Carlton all the time and his "charade" of interviewing the other clubs was just a media stunt. Thats old news anyway. My point from the original post was that Libbas word carries signifigant weight and its poor form from blues fans on BF to try to discredit the bloke purely for the fact that he had the balls to say what everyone already knew.
And yes it is the AFLs fault for allowing tanking- even if Vlad reckons it isnt happening.

Tony Liberatore will be hung out to dry on this,
no matter how good his intentions,
the wagons are circling.

 

[VERA HICKEY]

I dont know how many times can the blues footy dept. call in that time?
As I said Judd was going to Carlton all the time and his "charade" of interviewing the other clubs was just a media stunt. Thats old news anyway. My point from the original post was that Libbas word carries signifigant weight and its poor form from blues fans on BF to try to discredit the bloke purely for the fact that he had the balls to say what everyone already knew.
And yes it is the AFLs fault for allowing tanking- even if Vlad reckons it isnt happening.

Let's be honest here what did he actually say?
He had a feeling and was a bit suss
WTF.
I've always had a feeling and been a bit suss on Lindy Chamberlain as well so she must be guilty.