Times 2 players kicked 8 in a game?

[SA HAWK]

With Roughy & Fev both kicking 8 today i was wondering if anyone knows of any other games when this has happened?

I know there was a Geelong v Essendon game in 93 when Ablett kicked 14 & Salmon kicked 10.

 

[Johnny_Segment]

Did Buddy and Bradshaw both get 8 last year in the game at the Gabba?

 

[hawks_time]

Well last year against Brisbane Buddy kicked 8 whilst Bradshaw kicked 7. Close enough?

 

[Stewie Griffin]

1992 Geelong v Brisbane : Gary Ablett 9, John Hutton 8.

1993 Hawthorn v Collingwood : Jason Dunstall 9, Paul Hudson 8 - Both for the same team

 

[numchuks]

Hmmm, I know in 93 McAdam and Longmire kicked 10 and 9 each for North against Sydney

 

[Stewie Griffin]

Hmmm, I know in 93 McAdam and Longmire kicked 10 and 9 each for North against Sydney

That has to be a record with players from the same team.

 

[nobbyiscool]

i know the game is a totally different game to the one that i fell in love with 20 years ago. and i still love the game now. but i think it's disappointing that we marvel at 2 forwards kicking 8 goals in a game.

for lockett and dunstall, 8 goals was a pretty standard day!

i don't remember the year, i don't remember the round (although it was late in the year). in separate games that were both taking place on a saturday nite, one kicked 16 and the other kicked 17... ahhh, they halcyon days of the full forward...

 

[shanrew5]

2000 or 2001?

Carey kicked 10
LLoyd kicked 9

Unbelievable display of goal scoring. Especially Carey's left foot banana from the pocket and Lloyd's mid air kick from 35.

 

[TheNextBigThing]

Pretty sure Lloyd 'only' kicked 7

 

[JuddyBuddy]

Well last year against Brisbane Buddy kicked 8 whilst Bradshaw kicked 7. Close enough?

No. He asked for games with more than 8.

 

[red+black]

Pretty sure Lloyd 'only' kicked 7

That's what I was thinking too.

http://stats.rleague.com/afl/stats/games/1999/051219990724.html

 

[red+black]

Here's another close one:

http://stats.rleague.com/afl/stats/games/1978/071519780701.html

Footscray v St Kilda, Round 13, 1978 @ Western Oval

Kelvin Templeton kicked 15 for the Dogs, while his teammate Ian Dunstan kicked 7!

Interesting to note that while Dunstan kicked 139 goals in his career, he once kicked 4 goals in a game, but this was the only other time he ever managed to kick more than 3 goals in a game. Talk about being overshadowed in your biggest ever game!

 

[kosifantutti]

i don't remember the year, i don't remember the round (although it was late in the year). in separate games that were both taking place on a saturday nite, one kicked 16 and the other kicked 17... ahhh, they halcyon days of the full forward...

Lockett kicked 16 once only. At the Western Oval against Fitzroy in round 19 1995. Not many night games there unless it was a legends game. On the same day, Dunstall kicked five in a losing team against the Saints.

Three years earlier Dunstall kicked 17 against Richmond during the day at Waverley. On the same DAY, Lockett kicked 10 for the Saints against the Crows.

Ah yes, I remember it well.

 

[red+black]

Found one.

http://stats.rleague.com/afl/stats/games/1970/030419700912.html

Collingwood v Carlton, 2nd semi final, 1970 @ MCG

Peter McKenna (CM) 9 - Alex Jesaulenko (CB) 8

Collingwood won 118-108.

 

[red+black]

http://stats.rleague.com/afl/stats/games/1971/040919710731.html

Geelong v Collingwood, Round 18, 1971 @ Kardinia Park

Doug Wade (GC) 9 - Peter McKenna (CM) 8

Geelong won 137-128.

 

[kosifantutti]

I was at this game.

1975 Saints Pies at Moorabbin
Phil Carman 11
George Young 8

 

[red+black]

1993 Hawthorn v Collingwood : Jason Dunstall 9, Paul Hudson 8 - Both for the same team

It was against Sydney:

http://stats.rleague.com/afl/stats/games/1993/101619930725.html

Hawthorn win by 88, and Paul Hudson gets no Brownlow votes

 

[red+black]

I was at this game. Shame about the stupid finals system that year

http://stats.rleague.com/afl/stats/games/1991/091519910908.html

Geelong v St Kilda, Elimination Final, 1991 @ Waverley Park

Bill Brownless (GC) 8 - Tony Lockett (StK) 9

Geelong won 104-97.

 

[red+black]

What I am finding is there are a few games where 2 players have scored 7 or more each, but only the odd game where 2 players have each scored 8, a mere handful of those being two players from the same team.

I'm guessing the Ablett/Salmon game is the only instance of 2 playing each kicking 9 or more goals in a game.

 

[ThomasR]

This is the full list as far as I can tell. It has been done 30 times now - I actually thought it might have been more frequent than this

HAW     CAR     6       2009    Brendan Fevola 8, Jarryd Roughead 8       
RCH     MEL     21      1993    Allen Jakovich 8, Andy Lovell 8           
SYD     FIT     20      1993    Simon Minton-Connell 8, Darren Wheildon 8 
HAW     SYD     17      1993    Paul Hudson 8, Jason Dunstall 9           
BRB     SYD     8       1993    Michael Murphy 8, Roger Merrett 8         
NM      SYD     6       1993    Adrian McAdam 10, John Longmire 9         
ESS     GEE     6       1993    Gary Ablett snr 14, Paul Salmon 10        
GEE     FSC     QF      1992    Danny del-Re 8, Billy Brownless 9         
BRB     GEE     7       1992    John Hutton 8, Gary Ablett snr 9          
GEE     STK     EF      1991    Tony Lockett 9, Billy Brownless 8         
CAR     STK     20      1989    Stephen Kernahan 10, Nicky Winmar 8       
GEE     BRB     2       1987    Jim Edmond 8, Gary Ablett snr 8           
FSC     HAW     17      1980    Shane Loveless 8, Mike Moncrieff 8        
SM      GEE     20      1978    Stewart Gull 8, Larry Donohue 8           
HAW     GEE     15      1977    Peter Hudson 8, John Hendrie 8            
FSC     GEE     10      1977    Larry Donohue 8, Kelvin Templeton 9       
STK     COL     20      1975    Phil Carman 11, George Young 8     
GEE     COL     18      1971    Peter McKenna 8, Doug Wade 9              
COL     CAR     SF      1970    Alex Jesaulenko 8, Peter McKenna 9        
FIT     HAW     20      1968    Peter Hudson 8, Doug Searl 9              
CAR     FSC     15      1939    Ken Baxter 8, Paul Schmidt 8              
COL     CAR     5       1938    Ron Todd 11, Harry Vallence 8             
STK     NM      6       1936    Bill Mohr 11, Frank Crapper 9             
SM      COL     1       1934    Bob Pratt 8, Gordon Coventry 8            
COL     MEL     18      1933    Gordon Coventry 10, George Margitich 10   
MEL     GEE     13      1933    George Moloney 8, Bob Johnson 8           
CAR     FSC     8       1933    Harry Vallence 9, Alan Rait 10            
CAR     FIT     12      1932    Jack Moriarty 8, Creswell 'Mickey' Crisp 8
STK     COL     17      1931    Gordon Coventry 11, Bill Mohr 11          
RCH     NM      2       1931    Jack Titus 8, Doug Strang 14

 

[PAFC_1870]

hilarious:

SYD FIT 20 1993 Simon Minton-Connell 8, Darren Wheildon 8

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

hilarious:

SYD FIT 20 1993 Simon Minton-Connell 8, Darren Wheildon 8

Not that hilarious, both were sensational players on their day.

 

[old_clint]

Not that hilarious, both were sensational players on their day.

As indeed were Frank Crapper and Cresswell "Mickey" Crisp (who incidentally was a centreman).

 

[Stewie Griffin]

This is the full list as far as I can tell. It has been done 30 times now - I actually thought it might have been more frequent than this

HAW     CAR     6       2009    Brendan Fevola 8, Jarryd Roughead 8       
RCH     MEL     21      1993    Allen Jakovich 8, Andy Lovell 8           
SYD     FIT     20      1993    Simon Minton-Connell 8, Darren Wheildon 8 
HAW     SYD     17      1993    Paul Hudson 8, Jason Dunstall 9           
BRB     SYD     8       1993    Michael Murphy 8, Roger Merrett 8         
NM      SYD     6       1993    Adrian McAdam 10, John Longmire 9         
ESS     GEE     6       1993    Gary Ablett snr 14, Paul Salmon 10        
GEE     WBD     QF      1992    Danny del-Re 8, Billy Brownless 9         
BRB     GEE     7       1992    John Hutton 8, Gary Ablett snr 9          
GEE     STK     EF      1991    Tony Lockett 9, Billy Brownless 8         
CAR     STK     20      1989    Stephen Kernahan 10, Nicky Winmar 8       
GEE     BRB     2       1987    Jim Edmond 8, Gary Ablett snr 8           
WBD     HAW     17      1980    Shane Loveless 8, Mike Moncrieff 8        
SYD     GEE     20      1978    Stewart Gull 8, Larry Donohue 8           
HAW     GEE     15      1977    Peter Hudson 8, John Hendrie 8            
WBD     GEE     10      1977    Larry Donohue 8, Kelvin Templeton 9       
STK     COL     20      1975    Phil Carman 11, George Young 8     
GEE     COL     18      1971    Peter McKenna 8, Doug Wade 9              
COL     CAR     SF      1970    Alex Jesaulenko 8, Peter McKenna 9        
FIT     HAW     20      1968    Peter Hudson 8, Doug Searl 9              
CAR     WBD     15      1939    Ken Baxter 8, Paul Schmidt 8              
COL     CAR     5       1938    Ron Todd 11, Harry Vallence 8             
STK     NM      6       1936    Bill Mohr 11, Frank Crapper 9             
SYD     COL     1       1934    Bob Pratt 8, Gordon Coventry 8            
COL     MEL     18      1933    Gordon Coventry 10, George Margitich 10   
MEL     GEE     13      1933    George Moloney 8, Bob Johnson 8           
CAR     WBD     8       1933    Harry Vallence 9, Alan Rait 10            
CAR     FIT     12      1932    Jack Moriarty 8, Creswell 'Mickey' Crisp 8
STK     COL     17      1931    Gordon Coventry 11, Bill Mohr 11          
RCH     NM      2       1931    Jack Titus 8, Doug Strang 14

Only once in the last 16 years.

Doubt we will se it happen many more times the way the games is played these days.

 

[Bulldog Joe]

This is the full list as far as I can tell. It has been done 30 times now - I actually thought it might have been more frequent than this

HAW     CAR     6       2009    Brendan Fevola 8, Jarryd Roughead 8       
RCH     MEL     21      1993    Allen Jakovich 8, Andy Lovell 8           
SYD     FIT     20      1993    Simon Minton-Connell 8, Darren Wheildon 8 
HAW     SYD     17      1993    Paul Hudson 8, Jason Dunstall 9           
BRB     SYD     8       1993    Michael Murphy 8, Roger Merrett 8         
NM      SYD     6       1993    Adrian McAdam 10, John Longmire 9         
ESS     GEE     6       1993    Gary Ablett snr 14, Paul Salmon 10        
GEE     WBD     QF      1992    Danny del-Re 8, Billy Brownless 9         
BRB     GEE     7       1992    John Hutton 8, Gary Ablett snr 9          
GEE     STK     EF      1991    Tony Lockett 9, Billy Brownless 8         
CAR     STK     20      1989    Stephen Kernahan 10, Nicky Winmar 8       
GEE     BRB     2       1987    Jim Edmond 8, Gary Ablett snr 8           
WBD     HAW     17      1980    Shane Loveless 8, Mike Moncrieff 8        
[B]SYD [/B]    GEE     20      1978    Stewart Gull 8, Larry Donohue 8           
HAW     GEE     15      1977    Peter Hudson 8, John Hendrie 8            
WBD     GEE     10      1977    Larry Donohue 8, Kelvin Templeton 9       
STK     COL     20      1975    Phil Carman 11, George Young 8     
GEE     COL     18      1971    Peter McKenna 8, Doug Wade 9              
COL     CAR     SF      1970    Alex Jesaulenko 8, Peter McKenna 9        
FIT     HAW     20      1968    Peter Hudson 8, Doug Searl 9              
CAR     WBD     15      1939    Ken Baxter 8, Paul Schmidt 8              
COL     CAR     5       1938    Ron Todd 11, Harry Vallence 8             
STK     NM      6       1936    Bill Mohr 11, Frank Crapper 9             
[B]SYD [/B]    COL     1       1934    Bob Pratt 8, Gordon Coventry 8            
COL     MEL     18      1933    Gordon Coventry 10, George Margitich 10   
MEL     GEE     13      1933    George Moloney 8, Bob Johnson 8           
CAR     WBD     8       1933    Harry Vallence 9, Alan Rait 10            
CAR     FIT     12      1932    Jack Moriarty 8, Creswell 'Mickey' Crisp 8
STK     COL     17      1931    Gordon Coventry 11, Bill Mohr 11          
RCH     NM      2       1931    Jack Titus 8, Doug Strang 14

Interesting official stat for Sydney,since they did not have a team until the 80's. I am pretty sure Bob Pratt played all his footy for South Melbourne.