1714isotonic81015
Debutant
dunno bout that
carter getting cut from sandy is a joke!
the kid can play!
well should be 2 or 3 boys in there.
carter getting cut from sandy is a joke!
the kid can play!
well should be 2 or 3 boys in there.
-
Please read this post on the rules on BigFooty regarding posting copyright material, including fair dealing rules. Repeat infringements could see your account limited or closed.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Top 5 Players in the APS
- Thread starter danharris#4
- Start date
- Tagged users None
aintplayin03
Senior List
Agreed, sorry to raise it again but Sam Lees would also have to be one of those guys who should really be in there.
1714isotonic81015
Debutant
5 hc boys in top ten?
questionable.
questionable.
boys it seems that melbourne grammer are trying to take over this website. just becuase you beat xavier dont mean your all superstars. there are only a few great players at melbourne grammer such as Carter, Shaw and hayes.
If MGS back themself up and do well this year with a few wins call yourself a team not the best players. i think my prediction on the top 20 is pretty right, mayb not in the best order but thats who i see as the best 20.
Hayes and carter would have been coming in the next 5 best, (20-25). Dont think i dont rate them, just not in the top 20.
Ps. i dont go to hailebury either, hate the school but they seem to buy there way into good footballers.
If MGS back themself up and do well this year with a few wins call yourself a team not the best players. i think my prediction on the top 20 is pretty right, mayb not in the best order but thats who i see as the best 20.
Hayes and carter would have been coming in the next 5 best, (20-25). Dont think i dont rate them, just not in the top 20.
Ps. i dont go to hailebury either, hate the school but they seem to buy there way into good footballers.
r u just rankin these players on there TAC and wat teams they have made, cause i dotn think kennedy would b that high if any 1 sore him play on sat u'd no that he wouldnt of been close to top 5 players on the ground. and the top 5 players on the ground none of them bar hannerbury r in the list
1714isotonic81015
Debutant
carter has gone to another level.
should be in the 20!
showed lee's up on the weekend!
should be in the 20!
showed lee's up on the weekend!
aintplayin03
Senior List
its lees
f00ty-1S-L!fe
Team Captain
how's it questionable mate? yeah eveyrone knows that they're on scholarships but they deserve to have that many in the top 10 coz they are all quality players. No one on this site can deny that. Unless your opinion is an extremely bias one, those players deserve to be there.
Mgs superstars
Draftee
J. Strauss
T. Lynch
C. Shaw
B. Kennedy
R.hale
T. Lynch
C. Shaw
B. Kennedy
R.hale
Alright, i go to hailebury. And to be honest this is a joke. there arent 5 hailebury kids in the top 10.
1. Vickery aint the best player in the APS.
2. Scully is better than Strauss, and Vickery.
3. D. Hannebury is better than Martin. Hannebury easy top 10.
4. Cachia should round out the top 10, ahead of Noonan, Kennedy, Nitso.
5. J Bull is not top 20.
6. You have missed Rioli from Scotch, easy top 20.
7. i dont know where you got who was training with Vic Metro from, but i could of swore i saw Cachia and a few other APS boys training with them that you havent mentioned.
8. The top 5 is...
1. Tom Lynch
2. Tom Scully
3. Jack Ziebell
4. Vickery
5. Jack Watts
Dan Hannebury, very unlucky to miss out. averaging about 25 touches for oakliegh this year. should be a good inclusion for vic metro. may seem biased, but lynchy, scully, and vickery are all top 5 players.
Big Fraser
Debutant
stupid not to put Hannebery in the top 10 if not 5. easily one of the best midfielders and only in yr 11. got bog for all his oakliegh games and Xav vs Grammar.
Ablettttttt!
Senior List
He wasn't BOG against grammar
Big Fraser
Debutant
he was foir Xavier.
Ablettttttt!
Senior List
true
1714isotonic81015
Debutant
hateitorlovett13
Senior List
Kennedy shouldn't be in there either, by the sounds of it he's not even the best at Xavier (Hannebery is apparently in the Vic Metro squad) let alone in the top 5 in the APS.
scully, ziebell, vickery....?
danharris#4
Debutant
- Thread starter
- #143
I reckon the players in Footy07's top 10 is pretty accurate..Haileybury would have to deserve to have 5 players in the top 10 because they are all guns and have the creditentials to back up their selection... watch at the end of this year( and next year in scullys case) they'll get drafted and pretty early as well while the MGS boys won't
Jimmy_is_a_King
Debutant
1- strauss
2- lynch
3-scully
4- hanneberry
5- vickery
zeiball just hasnt done enough for mine. he hasnt dominated the aps yet, he might have done alright outside of it.
watts... not yet
2- lynch
3-scully
4- hanneberry
5- vickery
zeiball just hasnt done enough for mine. he hasnt dominated the aps yet, he might have done alright outside of it.
watts... not yet
Punch From Behind
Rookie
probably not top 5... but jack bull from scotch is a little gun
1714isotonic81015
Debutant
- Mar 29, 2005
- 8,407
- 944
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Other Teams
- Bushrangers, Liverpool, Celtics
Maybe Shaw, but probably not. Good team, average players.
Billy Costigan
Rookie
- Mar 8, 2007
- 49
- 0
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Not 1 MGS player will even go near getting drafted this yr they r a reasonable side but no one seriously outstanding.
Barrystoneham
Debutant
Its unlikely that Shaw, Carter, Lapin, Macciolli, Vickers-Willis or Goddard will get drafted.
