Opinion Top 50 2012

[hawkman]

Andrew Gaff not even in the unluckies? absurd. Other than that, a good 50.

Just regarding Priddis, it is worth noting that he has missed 3 games this year, plus was concussed early in the essendon game. So despite his consistent excellence, he has missed a few.

You can't get everyone in. Including the unluckies the most any team has is 7 from Essendon and West Coast

 

[eaglespremiers]

Here's Round 15:

Some players have exaggerated drops (i.e. Sidebottom, Dangerfield) that may not reflect their last game but I was merely trying to reposition them because I felt their spot as of last week was inaccurate.

 

[JVell7]

Pendlebury at No. 9? He hasn't played in the past four weeks.

 

[eaglespremiers]

Pendlebury at No. 9? He hasn't played in the past four weeks.

He was arguably the best player in the comp before he was injured.
He was in his position on the basis that no-one grabbed his spot off him.
During the time he's been out there's been very few players around him who have played enough to dislodge him.
As it is if he has a poor game this week I will bounce him significantly.

 

[Snarls Barkley]

Matthew Pavlich. Still the most underrated player in the comp.

Like your work nonetheless eaglespremiers

 

[eaglespremiers]

Matthew Pavlich. Still the most underrated player in the comp.

Like your work nonetheless eaglespremiers

In fairness he is actually sitting 51st in my list.
So he will be the first cab off the rank if he has another good game.

 

[eaglespremiers]

From NM v Carl:
9 - Judd
8 - Wells
7 - Swallow
6 - Robinson
5 - Henderson
4 - Yarran

 

[Dwight Schrute]

From NM v Carl:
9 - Judd
8 - Wells
7 - Swallow
6 - Robinson
5 - Henderson
4 - Yarran

Why would Yarran be in top 50 contention?

 

[eaglespremiers]

Why would Yarran be in top 50 contention?

I did him last week, clearly he's not.

 

[Dwight Schrute]

I did him last week, clearly he's not.

I thought you were only rating players in top 50 contention?

 

[eaglespremiers]

I thought you were only rating players in top 50 contention?

Just slipped in because I ranked him last week (because someone was not happy that he wasn't in the votes).
I can delete his score if you want?

 

[Dwight Schrute]

Just slipped in because I ranked him last week (because someone was not happy that he wasn't in the votes).
I can delete his score if you want?

Nah, I don't mind, I was just wondering.

 

[hawkman]

Just slipped in because I ranked him last week (because someone was not happy that he wasn't in the votes).
I can delete his score if you want?

Maybe just add your best on ground each time. It will probably save you having to answer why they weren't rated

 

[eaglespremiers]

From Gold Coast v Rich:
9 - Cotchin
8 - Ablett, Deledio, Bennell
7 - Rance
6 - Tuck

 

[eaglespremiers]

From Melb v Frem:
8 - Pavlich
6 - Jones, Johnson

 

[eaglespremiers]

From Port v Ess:
9 - Howlett
8 - Dempsey, Heppell
7 - Watson
5 - Stanton, Hooker

Heppell added because I thought he was in their best. Jetta, Myers and Bellchambers should also get mentions.

 

[eaglespremiers]

From Bris v StK:
9 - McEvoy
8 - Hayes
6 - Reiwoldt, Rockliff
5 - Redden, Hanley
4 - Dal Santo

 

[eaglespremiers]

From Geel v Coll:
9 - Beams, Kelly, Shaw
8 - Pendlebury, Johnson, Swan
5 - Taylor
3 - Cloke

 

[Dwight Schrute]

From Port v Ess:
9 - Howlett
8 - Dempsey, Heppell
7 - Watson
5 - Stanton, Hooker

Heppell added because I thought he was in their best. Jetta, Myers and Bellchambers should also get mentions.

Mainly agree with those ratings besides of Dempsey, he was average. Maybe Watson could be an 8 but thats fine.

Good job.

 

[Donakebab]

From Port v Ess:
9 - Howlett
8 - Dempsey, Heppell
7 - Watson
5 - Stanton, Hooker

Heppell added because I thought he was in their best. Jetta, Myers and Bellchambers should also get mentions.

Dempsey too high.
Watson was better than Heppell.
Stanton rated harshly, poor first half but really worked into the game and did a massive job shutting down Broadbent in the second half.

 

[jod23]

How is Waters not in your top 50. Injury hurts him but he should go AA this year. Priddis finally making it in at number 50 is ridic. Top 20 all season long.

 

[raskolnikov]

Heppell added because I thought he was in their best.

He wasn't. He did some good things but he did some ordinary things too.

 

[Ambrosia]

From Port v Ess:
9 - Howlett
8 - Dempsey, Heppell
7 - Watson
5 - Stanton, Hooker

Heppell added because I thought he was in their best. Jetta, Myers and Bellchambers should also get mentions.

I hope you don't slide Watson too much. He didn't play poorly and spent 50% of the first half on the bench.

 

[robertg22]

From Geel v Coll:
9 - Beams, Kelly, Shaw
8 - Pendlebury, Johnson, Swan
5 - Taylor
3 - Cloke

About right. Selwood a 7 too IMO. Not sure if you are tracking him but would go a 6 for Thomas. Beams almost 10. Was brilliant.

 

[MR]

From Gold Coast v Rich:
9 - Cotchin
8 - Ablett, Deledio, Bennell
7 - Rance
6 - Tuck

I'd give Cotchin a 10 and Brett and Gazza a 9. Quick question, are you not placing Grigg in your ranking? I thought he was in your unluckies, if so, then a 6-7.