Top five players at your club

Remove this Banner Ad

FOOTYBOSS said:
No Shane Watson at Euroa Duff Man. I think you mean our legendary skipper Scott Watson. I probably wouldnt have him in our top 5. A very good footballer none the less. My opinion of our top 5 in no particular order.

Shane Clayton
Daniel Sage
Rory Hilton
Nathan Gilliland
Scott Grainger

This is done on talent.

In means of importance to team structure I would go and players hard to replace to keep winning it would be as follows:

Luke Hyatt
Damon Clarke
Shane Clayton
Daniel Sage
Ben Shelton.
Click to expand...

Not many sides in the GV could boast a more talented top 5 than that lot..

How has Shelts been going footyboss? And how have you been going?
 
Keilor top 5 of all time in my opinion ( 85 onwards )

1 Jamie Cuffe
2 Lee Fraser
3 Andrew Willmott
4 Bluey Callahan
5 Steven Long

Unlucky

Nick Garnham
Rick Marcy
Mark Fotheringham
Jason Thorley
Rambo
 
Band O Brother said:
Keilor top 5 of all time in my opinion ( 85 onwards )

1 Jamie Cuffe
2 Lee Fraser
3 Andrew Willmott
4 Bluey Callahan
5 Steven Long

Unlucky

Nick Garnham
Rick Marcy
Mark Fotheringham
Jason Thorley
Rambo
Click to expand...

J.Thorley and N.Garnham ahead of A.Willmott in my opinion! :thumbsu:
 

Log in to remove this ad.

A Willmott delivered in the big games , could kick them consistently from 50 and was a true leader , he palyed at Sunbury from 92 and finished in 95 where he won a comp medal and is very respected up there , although in the lesser games he was known to cruise
 
stampy said:
1. luke wompoff wilson. (got caught spanking in back of taxi)
2. justin spewer condely (can't make it past 10pm without a spew)
3. stewart roosta07 brousard (wompoff's new bro-inlaw)
4. samuel john joseph mathew simon cleary (spotted shagging on riverbank in full view.
5.ben virgin mahon (tells all the women he's a virgin for sympathy sex)
Click to expand...

like your form stampy, but here are mine:

1: Brett powder Atken (for his delightful scent)
2: Shaun thighs Lawry (his drivers are bigger than mine)
3: Samuel please don't tell anyone or i'll get bashed Cleary (for his early bed time on saturday night)
4: Josh get out of my house Woolhouse (for his angry persona toward a team mate on saturday night)
5: Luke you've got a comfy bed Wilson (thanks mate)
 
VT#23 said:
Jack Smyth is with shepp swans he came bak 2 vt for a couple of years but went back to the swans but last i heard he was injured(again)

as for jimbob he's a very good footballer but not in the same class as these greats
Click to expand...

What he lacks in footy he more than makes up being a good bloke. Only bloke ive ever known whose team members like him going to a pub on a friday night as they feel it makes him play better.
 
Grubby said:
1) Mick Werner
2) Jamie Cuffe
3) Mark Hay
4) Brad Fox
5) Simon Elsum
Click to expand...

Elsum played at Gisborne for 1 or 2 years. You have to have 5 years as a minimum to be a club legend.

This is Cuffe's second team he has been nominated in. - Keilor the other!
 
FOOTYBOSS said:
No Shane Watson at Euroa Duff Man. I think you mean our legendary skipper Scott Watson. I probably wouldnt have him in our top 5. A very good footballer none the less.
Click to expand...

Thanks for picking me up on that one Boss. Of course I did mean our skipper Scott Watson, who is not to be confused with Shane 'Skunk' Watson of ex Collingwood fame.

And I know you're only being humble champ, but you easily make our top 5 list. :thumbsu:
 
T.Perry said:
Not many sides in the GV could boast a more talented top 5 than that lot..

How has Shelts been going footyboss? And how have you been going?
Click to expand...
Shelts has been going reasonably well. He had a shocker the other week against Shep Utd. where Forys beat him early but he responded last weekend to have another good game. Very realiable defender.

As for me Im slowly getting there. Playing full games now and the fitness is much better. Another few more weeks of solid training and full games, I will be cherry ripe to play properly again barring injuries. 2nd half of the year Im looking at.

How have you been travelling? I see you have kicked a couple of goals in recent weeks.
 
Duff Man said:
Thanks for picking me up on that one Boss. Of course I did mean our skipper Scott Watson, who is not to be confused with Shane 'Skunk' Watson of ex Collingwood fame.

And I know you're only being humble champ, but you easily make our top 5 list. :thumbsu:
Click to expand...
I make our top 5 most :D:D:D:Ded blokes every saturday night. Thats the only top 5 I make at the club.:D
 
VT#23 said:
Ill have a go at Violet Town's from the 80's onwards, open to criticism

1. Andrew Knowles
2. Gary Abley
3. Chris Hayes
4.Peter J. Smith
5. Gary Gerada
Click to expand...

Good choices on the five in terms of service to the senior team over the years but what about league medal winners like the man giant noel coutts two league medals and his other year at the club he won on votes but had been suspended for a match earleir in the year.... And the young gun Matt Sharp now playing with Benalla league leading goalkicker and league medalist at the age of 17..... Surely these two deserve consideration.....?? And my third and final choice would be a dark horse but what about the ever reliable bulldozer big Dougy Palmer.... JimBob
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

DOCKERS said:
like your form stampy, but here are mine:

1: Brett powder Atken (for his delightful scent)
2: Shaun thighs Lawry (his drivers are bigger than mine)
3: Samuel please don't tell anyone or i'll get bashed Cleary (for his early bed time on saturday night)
4: Josh get out of my house Woolhouse (for his angry persona toward a team mate on saturday night)
5: Luke you've got a comfy bed Wilson (thanks mate)
Click to expand...

Did you get a sympathy one off wilson or a chick DOCKERS.
 
big tony said:
andrew knowles
noel coutts
gary abley
matt sharp
chris hayes

hournerable mention to john veran, gary gerada, p.j smith.
Click to expand...
Was it 02 or 03 that a young sharp won the league goal kicking with 60 to 70 goals and played a majority of the year off the half back flank. Please set me straight if i'm wrong big tony but if true its says a lot about the blokes talent.
 
Kings Army
BigFooty Member


Join Date: Mar 2006
Club: North Melbourne Re: Top five players at your club

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Quote:
Originally Posted by Grubby
1) Mick Werner
2) Jamie Cuffe
3) Mark Hay
4) Brad Fox
5) Simon Elsum


Elsum played at Gisborne for 1 or 2 years. You have to have 5 years as a minimum to be a club legend.

So why is Mick Werner in your top 5 then?

It sais the best players to play at your club.[/B]
 
Grubby said:
Kings Army
BigFooty Member


Join Date: Mar 2006
Club: North Melbourne Re: Top five players at your club

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Quote:
Originally Posted by Grubby
1) Mick Werner
2) Jamie Cuffe
3) Mark Hay
4) Brad Fox
5) Simon Elsum


Elsum played at Gisborne for 1 or 2 years. You have to have 5 years as a minimum to be a club legend.

So why is Mick Werner in your top 5 then?

It sais the best players to play at your club.[/b]
Click to expand...

Werner played for 5 years - Elsum for 2. You cannot be a club great after 2 years. I thought you may have named yourself?

Elsum would not be better than Saunders of Fitzy. Fitzy had 49 possies the other Saturday.
 
Grubby said:
Kings Army
BigFooty Member


Join Date: Mar 2006
Club: North Melbourne Re: Top five players at your club

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Quote:
Originally Posted by Grubby
1) Mick Werner
2) Jamie Cuffe
3) Mark Hay
4) Brad Fox
5) Simon Elsum


Elsum played at Gisborne for 1 or 2 years. You have to have 5 years as a minimum to be a club legend.

So why is Mick Werner in your top 5 then?

It sais the best players to play at your club.[/b]
Click to expand...
Grubby , i know for a fact that Kingsarmy has never seen any one of his top 5 play more than 1 or 2 games , so i dont know how he came up with these names , in fact he admitted to me he's never even seen John Fitzgerald play ,whom he had at number 1. i guess it's like the rest of his posts on bigfooty , all second hand info . to state you have to have 5 years minimum and then put Mick in the top five shows you how much he really knows about Gisborne.
 
Deni Rovers in the Picola District Football League

1. Ash Germano (silky smooth skills)
2. Benji Hardman (spectacular full forward/ruck rover)
3. Chris O'Connor (young high-leaping ruckman. One to watch)
4. Liam Fleming (markologist at CHB. Fabulous football brain and a top bloke to match).
5. Gerard "the fox" Robinson (clever footballer, who uses the ball well. Can play at both ends)
 
Riewoldt12 said:
Deni Rovers in the Picola District Football League

1. Ash Germano (silky smooth skills)
2. Benji Hardman (spectacular full forward/ruck rover)
3. Chris O'Connor (young high-leaping ruckman. One to watch)
4. Liam Fleming (markologist at CHB. Fabulous football brain and a top bloke to match).
5. Gerard "the fox" Robinson (clever footballer, who uses the ball well. Can play at both ends)
Click to expand...

I'm sure that these blokes are reasonable footballers-how come the Rovers have only won the one game then?
 
bearsboy said:
Grubby , i know for a fact that Kingsarmy has never seen any one of his top 5 play more than 1 or 2 games , so i dont know how he came up with these names , in fact he admitted to me he's never even seen John Fitzgerald play ,whom he had at number 1. i guess it's like the rest of his posts on bigfooty , all second hand info . to state you have to have 5 years minimum and then put Mick in the top five shows you how much he really knows about Gisborne.
Click to expand...

Seen them all BB - your facts are once again crap!

By the way where is your top 5?
 
bearsboy said:
RIDDELL FC Luke Mckaskill , Rocky Towers , Tim Rowsell , Adam [flea]Stewart , Steady Eddie . wouldnt be a better wing man in country footy than Mckaskill .
Click to expand...

This is how much Bears Boy knows about the game. Once again another crap post by someone who thinks he knows about the game. Maybe it is humour or maybe this bloke is a moron.

McKakill and Flea only plays 2's footy.
 
ringo1 said:
I'm sure that these blokes are reasonable footballers-how come the Rovers have only won the one game then?
Click to expand...

Very young side. 11 kids straight out of the 3rds in the past 2 years. Lost a couple of blokes, had a bad run of injuries and not playing well as a team. Would expect a big improvement over the next few weeks, with winnable games and then a more competitive effort in the second half of the year.
We are having a crack, but can only field about 14 in the ressies each week, so the depth is unfortunately not there.
 
Riewoldt12 said:
Very young side. 11 kids straight out of the 3rds in the past 2 years. Lost a couple of blokes, had a bad run of injuries and not playing well as a team. Would expect a big improvement over the next few weeks, with winnable games and then a more competitive effort in the second half of the year.
We are having a crack, but can only field about 14 in the ressies each week, so the depth is unfortunately not there.
Click to expand...

Riewoldt, thanks for that. Obviously u know a bit about the club. Any chance of you putting together your top of all time as I'm trying to get as much info on top 5's as I can.:thumbsu:
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Top five players at your club

Similar threads

Munners
Your Favourite Country Footy Ground?
Replies
1
Views
495
RudyCt
R

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top