Top Three Players Of All Time - Club By Club

[hotpie]

Adelaide
Riccuitto
McLeod
Smart

Brisbane Bears
???

Brisbane Lions
Voss
Brown
Black

Carlton
Nicholls
Kernahan
Bradley

Collingwood
S Coventry
Buckley
Thompson

Essendon
Coleman
Hird
Madden

Fitzroy
Quinlan
Roos
Wilson

Fremantle
Pavlich
Hasleby
???

Geelong
Ablett
Brownless
Ling

Footscray
Whitten
Hawkins
Grant

Hawthorn
Matthews
Tuck
Hudson

Melbourne
Flower
Barassi
???

North Melb
Carey
Archer
Blight

Richmond
Bartlett
Hart
Clay???

StKilda
Baldock
Lockett
Stewart

South Melb/Sydney
Lockett
Pratt
Skilton

West Coast
Jakovich
Judd
Cousins

 

[Joffaboy]

And you reckon Harvey wouldn't be top three in any other club.

Oh btw he would be No2 at St.kilda following Lockett.

 

[hotpie]

feel free to post your own opinions - we are all entitled to them, subjective or otherwise.

try not to have a cry whilst doing so.

 

[Longy413]

Top 10 in the Champions of Essendon -

1. Richard Reynolds
2. John Coleman
3. James Hird
4. Bill Hutchison
5. Simon Madden
6. Tim Watson
7. Ken Fraser
8. Jack Clarke
9. Albert Thurgood
10. Tom Fitzmaurice

 

[Bring-Back-Powell]

Cam Bruce at the third missing place for Melbourne

 

[celtic_pride]

Good question Hotpie,but I don't think you could possibly not have Jezza in Carlton's top 3 of all time (I wouldn't have Bradley in there, even though he's the club's game holder)
Doull would also be pretty close in there as well.

 

[TheGhostOfJohnBelushi]

Geelong
Ablett
Brownless
Ling

Huh?

Farmer? Wade? Goggin? Hickey?

 

[Mad Dog]

Adelaide:

1 Roo
2 McLeod
3 dead heat with Rehn and D Jarman

 

[Hawkers]

Where's University? You've got Fitzroy and the Bears.

 

[TheGhostOfJohnBelushi]

West Coast:
Glen Jakovich
Peter Matera
Ben Cousins

 

[hotpie]

Huh?

Farmer? Wade? Goggin? Hickey?

fair enough

Farmer and Goggin and Ablett.

 

[pazza]

Needs some work hotters!

Adelaide: Ricciuto, McLeod, Bickley
Bris. Bears: Merrett, Hardie, Raines
Bris. Lions: Voss, Akermanis, Brown
Carlton: Nicholls, Vallence, Kernahan
Collingwood: G. Coventry, Rose, Buckley
Essendon: Coleman, Reynolds, S. Madden
Fitzroy: Bunton Snr, Wilson, Quinlan
Footscray/Bulldogs: Whitten Snr, Dempsey, Hawkins
Fremantle: Pavlich, Bell, McManus
Geelong: Ablett, Newman, I. Nankervis
Hawthorn: L. Matthews, Tuck, Peter Hudson
Melbourne: Barassi Junior, Flower, Warne-Smith
North Melbourne: Greig, Carey, Blight
Port Adelaide: Wanganeen, Primus, Tredrea
Richmond: Bartlett, Hart, Bourke
St. Kilda: Barker, Harvey, Baldock
South/Sydney: Lockett, Pratt, Skilton
West Coast: Jakovich, McKenna, Judd

 

[TheGhostOfJohnBelushi]

fair enough

Farmer and Goggin and Ablett.

hey, man, it's cool

 

[hotpie]

Where's University? You've got Fitzroy and the Bears.

probably three blokes with hyphenated names

 

[LightTower4]

Cam Bruce at the third missing place for Melbourne

To early to tell for Cam. Maybe a contender but have to wait till the end of his career.

Slot in Ivor Warne-Smith.

 

[goal sneak]

Geelong
Ablett
Brownless
Ling

Have you been smoking the doobies?

 

[hotpie]

Have you been smoking the doobies?

read the thread I had a brain explosion and have corrected my error

 

[Hotel 6]

I reckon Jack Dyer would get in at Richmond.

Kevin Murray and Haydn Bunton for Fitzroy

Gordon Coventry at Collingwood (1299 goals)

Reynolds at Essendon before Madden

Soapy Vallance at Carlton before Bradley

 

[pazza]

For University - they did have plenty of Cordner's play for them - is that a hint?

 

[OneEyedHawk]

Hawthorn
Matthews
Tuck
Hudson

Matthews
Hudson
Arthur/ Dunstall

 

[Jimi]

Cam Bruce at the third missing place for Melbourne

You've got to be joking!!!

Warne-Smith, Cordner, Norm Smith, Stynes, Lyon, etc etc would all slot into that 3rd position well ahead of Cam Bruce.

 

[Warwick]

For the Brisbane Lions - there is no way Brown has been a better player than Lappin, Leppitsch, Shaun Hart, or Lynch.

I would probably go:
Voss
Akermanis
Lappin

 

[MickZu]

Brisbane Bears
Graig Lambert
Scott McIvor
Michael McLean

Brisbane Lions
Voss (Lock it in)
Brown (ahh No)
Black (see Brown)
Akermanis
Lynch

My adjustments in bold.

 

[Scarlett30]

Geelong
Ablett
Brownless
Ling

You’re joking

Couch, Hocking, Farmer, Goggin, Newman, Wade, Davis, Flanagan, Morrison, Pianto, Bernie Smith, ‘Carji’ Greeves, Hickey, Rankin, ‘Jocka’ Todd.

Take your pick

Brownless and Ling are not even in top 50

At least you got Ablett.

 

[Bourky23]

hahah wats with ppl puttin browny in brisbanes best 3 of all time he'd struggle to be in their top 3 of the current list