Strategy Trade and List management Thread Part 5 (opposition supporters - READ posting rules before posting)

[compact72]

I’d be doing a lot of due diligence on Nick Haynes

19

Nick Haynes

Age

32

Ht

192cm

Wt

88kg

Pos.

Def

Career

Season

Last 5

D

16.4

4star

K

11.4

4star

HB

4.9

4star

M

6.2

5star

T

1.6

4star

MG

326.8

4star

D

17.4

4star

K

13.9

5star

HB

3.5

2star

M

8.0

5star

T

1.5

2star

MG

326.8

5star

D

7.8

2star

K

4.4

2star

HB

3.4

3star

M

2.4

3star

T

2.2

4star

right now.

Maybe 5-6 years ago, a bit too late now imo

Sent from my SM-N975F using Tapatalk

 

[Norm De Guerre]

Does anybody live near Middle Park?

It's absolutely bucketing down. Somebody needs to go and drag Norm De Guerre out of that drain before he drowns.

View attachment 1528825

Its all good. I moved inside Josh's house to avoided the rain.

 

[TiAn_]

I’d be doing a lot of due diligence on Nick Haynes right now.

I didn’t see much of him this year but his contested marks dropping all the way down to just 4 in 17 games is a huge concern given athleticism and intercepting is his strong suit. As we saw with Easton, the cliff comes very quickly for this types of players.

 

[Doggies_13]

Injury prone isn’t he?

Has played 17 games or more in every season since 2015.

He looked utterly cooked this year.

In the right context you'd back him to turn it around as the man is a warrior and a consumate professional.

One of the only players at GWS you could still like despite all the hatred for their club.

Was down this year but is that a consequence of the giants being very poor. Is he possibly a good player in a good team.

He was also moved around a bit this year being forward and on a wing etc

 

[Libbaaaa]

If Haynes cuts his salary in half I am more than happy for him to toss the coin with the Bont every game.

 

[Libbaaaa]

Also I may need to step away from the Dunkley thread, its now hit the point where Lions fans are saying Wilmot and Lohmann are untouchable. It would be like us getting McCluggage to commit to us and not wanting to throw in Garcia.

 

[Scottish Bob]

If we could get a year or two out of Haynes while our ‘window’ is still open it’s got to be perused, could have the bont throttling him at his signing would get us some press!

 

[Mofra]

I'm a massive no to Haynes - unless it comes with a fantastic pick as a salary dump.
He's playing on reputation rather than output, and he takes forever to get boot to ball when he does mark it (which is happening much more rarely these days).

 

[doggies ftw]

Should be on the first flight to Brissy this morning, offer Raynor something ridiculous he can’t turn down like 1mil/7 and get him to publicly commit, knowing full well there is 0% chance Brissy say yes. That would be pure embarrassment for them there is just no way they let him go under contract after all this.

What that’ll do though is make them satisfy us pretttttty quickly with picks for Dunks and allow them save face saying we stuck to our guns held Raynor etc

Alpha move

 

[Dogs_r_barking]

The way I look at the Dunkley trade, if Brisbane has been courting a player who is under contract until 31 December 2022, then they need to ensure they have the assets to make a suitable trade at the market rate.

The market rate has been set by Richmond as two firsts for a young player with credentials and proven track record. In Dunkley’s case a B&F, Premiership, 40 Brownlow votes, in other words, a known player.

This deal is to recompense the Bulldogs for the draft pick, and development they have put into said player which Brisbane will benefit from.

Bulldogs have the gamble of going to the draft and having to find another Dunkley and putting the years off development in that Dunkley has received, which is not a sure thing, hence two first round picks reduces the odds of picking a dud.

What part of this does Brisbane and their feral fans not understand?

 

[Northernsoul74]

Should be on the first flight to Brissy this morning, offer Raynor something ridiculous he can’t turn down like 1mil/7 and get him to publicly commit, knowing full well there is 0% chance Brissy say yes. That would be pure embarrassment for them there is just no way they let him go under contract after all this.

What that’ll do though is make them satisfy us pretttttty quickly with picks for Dunks and allow them save face saying we stuck to our guns held Raynor etc

Alpha move

Rayner loves it there though.

 

[Northernsoul74]

The way I look at the Dunkley trade, if Brisbane has been courting a player who is under contract until 31 December 2022, then they need to ensure they have the assets to make a suitable trade at the market rate.

The market rate has been set by Richmond as two firsts for a young player with credentials and proven track record. In Dunkley’s case a B&F, Premiership, 40 Brownlow votes, in other words, a known player.

This deal is to recompense the Bulldogs for the draft pick, and development they have put into said player which Brisbane will benefit from.

Bulldogs have the gamble of going to the draft and having to find another Dunkley and putting the years off development in that Dunkley has received, which is not a sure thing, hence two first round picks reduces the odds of picking a dud.

What part of this does Brisbane and their feral fans not understand?

I think they understand it but they’re just focused/prioritizing on the points for father sons element. The only way they can do it all is if we fold and take unders or a decent player is involved.

 

[dergert]

Damo reckons Lobb for Dunkley should be a straight 3 way swap

 

[Dogs Rule]

Should be on the first flight to Brissy this morning, offer Raynor something ridiculous he can’t turn down like 1mil/7 and get him to publicly commit, knowing full well there is 0% chance Brissy say yes. That would be pure embarrassment for them there is just no way they let him go under contract after all this.

What that’ll do though is make them satisfy us pretttttty quickly with picks for Dunks and allow them save face saying we stuck to our guns held Raynor etc

Alpha move

Agreed. Raise the stakes. Time for a Boyd/ Griffen 'stick it right up 'em/screw you' moment.

 

[Dogs_r_barking]

I would much rather we looked at Lohman, has not signed an extension and is a Ballarat boy, sounds like he is not committed ongoing to the Lions, so it would be smart if the Lions to get on the front foot.

 

[RSully14]

Damo reckons Lobb for Dunkley should be a straight 3 way swap

Barrett is the biggest flog in the media, his personal hatred against us is childish and comical.

If you read sliding doors today, he touches on the Dunkley stalemate in both Bris and our columns, but calls them "a really good club" and says we are "playing silly hardball"....

 

[Dogs Rule]

Damo reckons Lobb for Dunkley should be a straight 3 way swap

Been spending way too much time with old man Rendell.

 

[Dogs_r_barking]

I think they understand it but they’re just focused/prioritizing on the points for father sons element. The only way they can do it all is if we fold and take unders or a decent player is involved.

Then they should not have been chasing Dunkley, if that is their priority, they are screwing him around as well. No coach and now this, I hope Dunkley realises what a shite show he is walking in to.

 

[RSully14]

I would much rather we looked at Lohman, has not signed an extension and is a Ballarat boy, sounds like he is not committed ongoing to the Lions, so it would be smart if the Lions to get on the front foot.

If Lohman seems uncommitted to lions in long run and a Ballarat boy, we should enquire but ask for him along with multiple firsts, they will obviously decline, then when he is coming out of contract court him again and then eff them over next year

 

[Dogs_r_barking]

Barrett is the biggest flog in the media, his personal hatred against us is childish and comical.

If you read sliding doors today, he touches on the Dunkley stalemate in both Bris and our columns, but calls them "a really good club" and says we are "playing silly hardball"....

Where the rest of the media was incredulous of the offer Brisbane made wanting picks back.

 

[Northernsoul74]

Damo reckons Lobb for Dunkley should be a straight 3 way swap

 

[Northernsoul74]

If Lohman seems uncommitted to lions in long run and a Ballarat boy, we should enquire but ask for him along with multiple firsts, they will obviously decline, then when he is coming out of contract court him again and then eff them over next year

Apparently close to re-signing but until he does we should ask the question. I know little about him as a player though.

 

[RSully14]

Where the rest of the media was incredulous of the offer Brisbane made wanting picks back.

I dont know who the worst media personality is, Barrett, Rendell, LLoyd, Cornes, Caro. The list is almost endless

 

[Bulldogs85]

Damo reckons Lobb for Dunkley should be a straight 3 way swap

Damo is the biggest clown in the media

 

[Struggle]

I dont know who the worst media personality is, Barrett, Rendell, LLoyd, Cornes, Caro. The list is almost endless

Lloyd definitely doesn't belong on this list. He's usually pretty fair and can actually give reasonable game analysis