Strategy Trade and List management Thread Part 5 (opposition supporters - READ posting rules before posting)

[RSully14]

Lloyd definitely doesn't belong on this list. He's usually pretty fair and can actually give reasonable game analysis

He is always about Essendon this time of year, its probably a personal gripe but I am not a fan of him

 

[dlanod]

Barrett is the biggest flog in the media, his personal hatred against us is childish and comical.

If you read sliding doors today, he touches on the Dunkley stalemate in both Bris and our columns, but calls them "a really good club" and says we are "playing silly hardball"....

My big take away from this whole trade week is that apparently we aren't actually last on Barrett's perennial shitlist. I'd say I feel sorry for you guys, but to be honest that'd suggest his opinion actually matters to anyone outside the echoing inside his head.

 

[Barking Mad]

Future picks are in higher demand this year because of the relative depths of the draft versus the projections for next years

Not as in demand as Father son picks and Dunkley it appears.

 

[Doggies_13]

Pie in the sky stuff but 5 team trade, who says no?

Lions give F1 (lions) pick 21 and pick 25
Lions get Dunkley, pick 30 and pick 39

Roos give JFH
Roos get Hunter and pick 2

Eagles give Rioli pick 2 and pick 26
Eagles get pick 8, pick 21, F1 (port)

Power give Duursma pick 8 and F1 (Port)
Power get JFH and Rioli

Dogs give Dunkley, Hunter, pick 30 and pick 39
Dogs get Duursma, F1 (Lions) pick 25 and pick 26

 

[stevieg1969]

I dont know who the worst media personality is, Barrett, Rendell, LLoyd, Cornes, Caro. The list is almost endless

Add Cooney and Goddard to the list. Boomer Harvey on RSN is awful also

 

[BulldogMuscle]

Hey mods, next List Management thread can we just straight up ban oppo supporters participating? Plenty of other threads for them to do so, no idea why they want to come and whinge in here.

 

[Islanddoggy]

I’d be doing a lot of due diligence on Nick Haynes right now.

Like this ... Nick Haynes is set to miss multiple weeks with a fractured larynx after this clash with Marcus Bontempelli. Not sure it would happen mate

 

[Barking Mad]

Yep.. and we had no ability to trade for Jones. It's Bullshit

Ok so let’s say we got pick 48 for Cordy compo and then sent 48 to Blue for Jones.
Not sure what all the fuss is.

 

[compact72]

Ok so let’s say we got pick 48 for Cordy compo and then sent 48 to Blue for Jones.
Not sure what all the fuss is.

Few sensitive people here lately

Think we all need to take a break and relax. It's just a game at the end of the day

 

[Doggy]

Ok so let’s say we got pick 48 for Cordy compo and then sent 48 to Blue for Jones.
Not sure what all the fuss is.

In this particular instance, and it's a unique one... Jones retired from the AFL.

I don't think we should have had to trade for Jones in any event. Cordy should have netted something

 

[flipper83]

They will offer 21 and their future first.

It's still not good enough

We could also ask to swap or future second for the GWS future second which wouldn't impact Brisbane's points this year.
It's not great but it's getting closer to reasonable.

 

[Mofra]

Yep.. and we had no ability to trade for Jones. It's Bullshit

Nope.
Cordy's contract is not high enough to trigger band 5

 

[Doggy]

We could also ask to swap or future second for the GWS future second which wouldn't impact Brisbane's points this year.
It's not great but it's getting closer to reasonable.

I'd like one of their young players .. even if that means we don't get 21 and we get something else a bit later instead .. along with their future first

They're trying to get their cake and eat it too

 

[Doggy]

Nope.
Cordy's contract is not high enough to trigger band 5

How do you know? It's not exactly public

 

[Libbaaaa]

Hahaha I needed a good laugh.

 

[Mofra]

How do you know? It's not exactly public

Deduction from similar deals over the years.
Fringe players never attract compo

The Jones signing is not a FA signing, he's a DFA. The AFL changed the 18 month rule to assist Carlton

 

[Doggy]

Deduction from similar deals over the years.
Fringe players never attract compo

In other words, you're guessing. An educated guess, but without hearing it from the clubs or AFL noone can say for sure

 

[Barking Mad]

Few sensitive people here lately

Think we all need to take a break and relax. It's just a game at the end of the day

It maybe just a game but the game is required for SuprCoach to exist

 

[scooter600x]

Pie in the sky stuff but 5 team trade, who says no?

Lions give F1 (lions) pick 21 and pick 25
Lions get Dunkley, pick 30 and pick 39

Roos give JFH
Roos get Hunter and pick 2

Eagles give Rioli pick 2 and pick 26
Eagles get pick 8, pick 21, F1 (port)

Power give Duursma pick 8 and F1 (Port)
Power get JFH and Rioli

Dogs give Dunkley, Hunter, pick 30 and pick 39
Dogs get Duursma, F1 (Lions) pick 25 and pick 26

That's actually really good.

I genuinely don't know who loses in that (every team according to their own fans).

 

[Dogs_r_barking]

Looking at Brisbane’s contract status for players, Tom Fullerton out of contract this year and also Connor McFadyn, I don’t know a lot about either. Fullarton replaced Daniher in the final against Melbourne, 200cm, could be a ruck back up option if the Lobb deal falls through.

 

[Barking Mad]

Damo is the biggest clown in the media

Don’t stress, I hear he’s about to be appointed to oversee the Bombers list management team after going through a thorough process.

 

[Mofra]

In other words, you're guessing. An educated guess, but without hearing it from the clubs or AFL noone can say for sure

Your original post when you were melting and calling it BS you were adamant based on?
FA compo is normally announced shortly after a signing (e.g. McStay $650 x 5 attracted Band 3)

 

[Doggy]

Looking at Brisbane’s contract status for players, Tom Fullerton out of contract this year and also Connor McFadyn, I don’t know a lot about either. Fullarton replaced Daniher in the final against Melbourne, 200cm, could be a ruck back up option if the Lobb deal falls through.

God I hope not. Fullerton is a spud.

Says something about Brisbane's depth

 

[Dogs_r_barking]

God I hope not. Fullerton is a spud.

Says something about Brisbane's depth

A spud, or young and still developing?

 

[Doggy]

Your original post when you were melting and calling it BS you were adamant based on?
FA compo is normally announced shortly after a signing (e.g. McStay $650 x 5 attracted Band 3)

Did I say I was adamant? I have been saying the dogs weren't afforded the opportunity because Jones cancelled out any possibility. I don't believe his acquisition should have given the circumstances.

Agree to disagree but everyone is allowed to have an opinion