Trades

[catzfan]

Hypothetically who would you like to see your club target and what would you offer for them. Draft Picks Included

For Geelong I would like to see Prismall and Lonergan to Port for T.Boak.
J.Corey to W.C for P.P 18.

 

[Unique]

Hypothetically who would you like to see your club target and what would you offer for them. Draft Picks Included

For Geelong I would like to see Prismall and Lonergan to Port for T.Boak.
J.Corey to W.C for P.P 18.

Joel Corey for pick 18? Shit.

Robert Warnock
Jason Roe
Troy Chaplin
Kelvin Moore
Danyle Pearce
Daniel Wells

 

[Kaladin Stormblessed]

Ryan Murphy from Freo for a third rounder.

 

[fraser25]

Any club that doesn't look at Murphy is neglecting their duty as recruiters.

Well balanced, mobile, tall forwards with a beautiful shot for goal do not grow on trees.

 

[Ysaye]

Ryan Murphy from Freo for a third rounder.

Done.

Eric McKenzie from Eagles for Mundy or whatever we can get for him?

 

[acuguy]

What would you guys give for T.Selwood

 

[Dave The Man]

What would you guys give for T.Selwood

3 Rounder and Chris Egan

 

[Blueinblood]

2nd rounder for Mckinely

 

[dylan123]

well i would like to see adelaide trade mcgreogor to another team for no 1 and we will also give them money just to keep him. melbourne might take him for the money but i dont no about the rest of the clubs

 

[patto_man]

Joel Corey for pick 18? Shit.

Robert Warnock
Jason Roe
Troy Chaplin
Kelvin Moore
Danyle Pearce
Daniel Wells

kelvin moore is staying at richmond

warnock

 

[mattdwyer]

What would you guys give for T.Selwood

Pettifer ??

 

[raffrox]

Done.

Eric McKenzie from Eagles for Mundy or whatever we can get for him?

Keep Mundy and a third rounder for Murphy sounds fair but again, I'd keep him if we can.

I believe Murphy is too mentally weak to play consistent AFL footy. He'll be a nice piece in a team that is actually going well (i.e. us in 2006).

I'd like us to go for:

McGrath from Brisbane (swap for Murphy or third rounder) to replace Farmer as a FP.
Surjan from Port and their third or fourth rounder for J Carr(?)
The best kids in the draft (unless Corey is going real cheap).

 

[sydney eagle]

2nd rounder for Mckinely

I doubt that that would be enough. McKinley is just starting to show something and is currently the Eagles' leading goalkicker. Would you take a second round pick for Carlton's leading goalkicker ?

 

[Prem87]

Seaby + McKinley + Pick 21 for Carlton's First Round Pick (8-10)

 

[rotto]

Hunter + 35 pick to Hawks, 15 Pick to The Eagles. Eagles need space for their long list of young backs and Hawks need an experienced tall back.

 

[dyl_tigerman]

id get mc kinely from wc for a 2nd rounder...

joel bowden and jay schultz for warnock and a third rounder

 

[Yoda_]

you know whats funny, all carlton supporters that go, we need a CHF, you guys had one, but offloaded him for some unknown, lol. ok you got judd, but you needed a CHF before a midfielder dont you. and Kenedy is promising too. lol. you all carlton supporters are ########s
no wonder you have done so crap. lol.

 

[rotto]

dyl_tigerman, sorry but no. Freo needs young midfielders.

 

[raffrox]

you know whats funny, all carlton supporters that go, we need a CHF, you guys had one, but offloaded him for some unknown, lol. ok you got judd, but you needed a CHF before a midfielder dont you. and Kenedy is promising too. lol. you all carlton supporters are ########s
no wonder you have done so crap. lol.

Judd trade was pretty even I reckon. You've got to give up quality to get a top 5 player. I think your comments don't make too much sense.

 

[ROYAL EAGLE]

Re: Trades
Hunter + 35 pick to Hawks, 15 Pick to The Eagles. Eagles need space for their long list of young backs and Hawks need an experienced tall back.

Sounds a reasonable trade for the hawks, Hunter always plays well in finals, but can we aford to lose his experience now with our young side?

Depends on the quality of this draft can we get a good player for that pick.

We probaly could this year so i would do that trade, but would be very hard to watch Hunter picking up another premiership medallion with the
Hawks.

 

[choco123]

would do ash mcgrath for freo's third rounder (around 35).

To the Hawks poster who wanted Roe, we'll give him up with that pick (35) for Jordan Lewis...

Would like Corey Jones and Daniel Harris. How about Harris and Jones for Sherman and S Harding (sherman and Harding are both younger than harris and jones)?

 

[Beats]

would do ash mcgrath for freo's third rounder (around 35).

To the Hawks poster who wanted Roe, we'll give him up with that pick (35) for Jordan Lewis...

Would like Corey Jones and Daniel Harris. How about Harris and Jones for Sherman and S Harding (sherman and Harding are both younger than harris and jones)?

Throw in Brisbanes first rounder and that would seem more reasonable...
2 regular players for 2 fringe players at best.

They might be younger, but are no where near in terms of class and skill.

 

[TrentM]

B Fevola for B Prismall and T Hawkins

or

B Fevola for B Reid and First Round Pick

or

B Fevola for J Kennedy and Pick 18 one of those would suit me fine

 

[rotto]

Eagles have alot of good young prospects in the Key Backs. Ok losing Hunter would hurt but that would allow likes of Mitch Brown, Mckenzie, Wilkes, Stangler, and Schofield room to fill. Currently, the eagles have Glass and Hunter as the kp backs with above fighting for one or two possible spots. Up forward they have Notte, Hansen, Lynch, and Kennedy fighting for three spots. Make sense to trade a kp with some value. I wouldnt trade Glass as he holds the defense, very underated player compared Cox or Kerr.

 

[King Woodie]

From Collingwood's point of view, I would trade one of our mediuim backs (Maxwell would have the most value in my opinion) and possibly one of our medium talls (ie Rusling, as we have a similar type of player in Maccaffer).

Both of these areas we have surplus of. We need mids.