List Mgmt. Treloar officially nominates Pies as his pref club (Mods: please use this thread for all AT posts)

[Apex36]

Rather Kreuzer then White. Offer’s More

He might barely offer more, but not $600k worth of value. The whole idea of paying that kind of money for a ruckman with a dodgy foot is ludicrous. Daisy ludicrous.

 

[TradeDraft]

He might barely offer more, but not $600k worth of value. The whole idea of paying that kind of money for a ruckman with a dodgy foot is ludicrous. Daisy ludicrous.

So you say Hine and Co IF true are Morons?

 

[PicaBoo]

I think you are Underestimating Kruzer as a Forward. Barley played Forward at the Blues as they have no other Ruckman. Woods and Warnock are Hacls

I did check him out . Not underestimating him at all . If fit (and that is a very big IF ) a lot to like.
Still very different player to White in speed, agility and endurance and the comparison is simply not valid. The scenario unfolding : Kreuzer would take over from Moore as 2nd tall and Moore would take White's place. So compare a Moore with White and then White would lose out on prospects/potential and talismanic attributes. But is Kreuzer a 90% forward? Nope.
Kreuzer and Cloke in the fwd line and only 1 roving tall? Not sold on that either but with Cox coming up, it might be a template we have to work through.

 

[Apex36]

So you say Hine and Co IF true are Morons?

Yes Dave, that is exactly what I'm saying...

 

[TradeDraft]

I did check him out . Not underestimating him at all . If fit (and that is a very big IF ) a lot to like.
Still very different player to White in speed, agility and endurance and the comparison is simply not valid. The scenario unfolding : Kreuzer would take over from Moore as 2nd tall and Moore would take White's place. So compare a Moore with White and then White would lose out on prospects/potential and talismanic attributes. But is Kreuzer a 90% forward? Nope.
Kreuzer and Cloke in the fwd line and only 1 roving tall? Not sold on that either but with Cox coming up, it might be a template we have to work through.

Well Kruszer might not be as Fast or Agile as White but Kruszer is a Better Footballer then White

IF we play Grundy and Kruszer. Grundy would not ruck 90% of the Time

 

[PicaBoo]

IF we play Grundy and Kruszer. Grundy would not ruck 90% of the Time

Not sure if that is a good or bad thing. Grundy seems to be holding out OK so far. But it is getting a bit off topic, it is not what Kreuzer can do on the field but how and why we are getting him in relation to Treloar. As replacement for Witts, Kreuzer is an upgrade but has injury concerns. So that is and always will be debatable.
As part of some dodgy backroom trade scheme to send a high compo pick across, is a matter of principles.

 

[TradeDraft]

Not sure if that is a good or bad thing. Grundy seems to be holding out OK so far. But it is getting a bit off topic, it is not what Kreuzer can do on the field but how and why we are getting him in relation to Treloar. As replacement for Witts, Kreuzer is an upgrade but has injury concerns. So that is and always will be debatable.
As part of some dodgy backroom trade scheme to send a high compo pick across, is a matter of principles.

Well Kreuszer thing could go Either Way and That is IF we sign him

 

[PicaBoo]

Well Kreuszer thing could go Either Way and That is IF we sign him

We will get him alright. Too many signals to doubt it is not going to happen.

 

[TradeDraft]

We will get him alright. Too many signals to doubt it is not going to happen.

Does look like us or stay where he is. Dogs should not be Ruled out yet

 

[PicaBoo]

Does look like us or stay where he is. Dogs should not be Ruled out yet

Dogs would be better off with going after Witts imho.

 

[TradeDraft]

Dogs would be better off with going after Witts imho.

Would Witts be to Slow for the Dogs Fast Moving Offence?

 

[PicaBoo]

Would Witts be to Slow for the Dogs Fast Moving Offence?

Too slow as in physical slow or decision making slow? I assume the former. I doubt he has to be a vital cog in those scenario's. It is for his ruck work so that they can make that fast transition. Add to that the right age group and such, he should be good for them.

 

[TradeDraft]

Too slow as in physical slow or decision making slow? I assume the former. I doubt he has to be a vital cog in those scenario's. It is for his ruck work so that they can make that fast transition. Add to that the right age group and such, he should be good for them.

Mostly Physical but he is also not the World Quicket Descion Maker

 

[PicaBoo]

Mostly Physical but he is also not the World Quicket Descion Maker

If he becomes that towering ruckman as we think he will be, it will be a matter of tap-> slingshot->mark-> goal. He turns like the Queen Mary and small fwds will run around him in circles. Not that good for our play style where everyone have to put pressure on opponents. Grundy is that kind of cat.

 

[unplugged]

Treloar is at their B&F at the moment. Good bloke points.

Hopefully he doesn't make a Prince Treloar speech at any stage.

 

[TradeDraft]

Treloar is at their B&F at the moment. Good bloke points.

Hopefully he doesn't make a Prince Treloar speech at any stage.

Hope he does not win it as his Price go up again

 

[NT.Thunder]

Stefan Martin would be the perfect fit for the dogs

 

[Kappa]

Treloar is at their B&F at the moment. Good bloke points.

Hopefully he doesn't make a Prince Treloar speech at any stage.

I wonder if Treloar knows which side of history he stands on?

Will he have the last laugh?

 

[Saintly Viewed]

Hope he does not win it as his Price go up again

His price will be what it is, doubt clubs at this late stage "fall" for those red herrings

 

[Saintly Viewed]

Close game dogs v crows, as lmg as who wins belts hawks out of finals.
I digress.
Teloar needs to come clean at the B&F and say he uses trolloar as his twitter.
Where is pica boomwith the latest truthful treloar happening

 

[TradeDraft]

His price will be what it is, doubt clubs at this late stage "fall" for those red herrings

Well Daniel Kerr in 2004 I think was going to us but Eagles oulled out when he nearly won the Brownlow

 

[sirlothie]

Hope he does not win it as his Price go up again

Amon Buchanon their forward coach reckons Heath Shaw will win it. He's already won their coach's award.

 

[PicaBoo]

Close game dogs v crows, as lmg as who wins belts hawks out of finals.
I digress.
Teloar needs to come clean at the B&F and say he uses trolloar as his twitter.
Where is pica boomwith the latest truthful treloar happening

I am at the GWS best and fairiest atm. Will let you know if anything happens #kevinshadymedal #day1brotherfromanothermother

 

[TradeDraft]

I am at the GWS best and fairiest atm. Will let you know if anything happens #kevinshadymedal #day1brotherfromanothermother

How did you get Tickets?

 

[sirlothie]

Dylan Shiel leading after round 8. I'm there too.