• Please read this post on the rules on BigFooty regarding posting copyright material, including fair dealing rules. Repeat infringements could see your account limited or closed.

U16's A & B dream team

Remove this Banner Ad

the unknown said:
Quinn (Spotswood) - no way in the world.. He shocking, didn't see him once the two times we played them.
Click to expand...

Harder than Phil Johnson. I have never, repeat never seen this kid back away from any contest with anyone. If not in the team for skill level then pure toughness. He'd kill a forward pocket in 3 seconds.

the unknown said:
Stapleton (St Bernards) - no, not sure what you're basing this on, maybe best player points o rsomething. one thing i definately know is that he's not on the half back flank, this bloke's a ruckman.
Click to expand...

Well yeah, but I wrote "Some players on the HBF/HFF are resting centremen. He's quick & tall & can kick from what I saw.

the unknown said:
Dean (Werribee) - doubt he's played CHB in his life, but in there somewhere.
Click to expand...

Had to put him somewhere.

the unknown said:
McKenzie (Spotswood) - interesting, i just don't think hes up with these blokes yet.
Click to expand...

I reckon he's there, 15 games played in the A's, best in 12 of them, kicked 21 goals for the year.

the unknown said:
Fairley (Williamstown) - played forward line about two times all year. Put him in the ruck.
Click to expand...

Resting on the half forward flank

the unknown said:
Overton-Skinner (Spotswood) - just no. fairley in the ruck. maybe put him on the bench.
Click to expand...

A good ruckman despite what you might think, but on closer inspection, Overton Skinner to HFF & Fairley to ruck

the unknown said:
Farrell (St Bernards) - Could think of better St Bernard's players..
Click to expand...

Very quick & knows how to get it IMO, has to be in there somewhere

the unknown said:
Ryan (Spotswood) - just to keep the team clean, we don't want any king hits behind play, plus there are better players.
Click to expand...

He'd have to have one of the best kicking actions I've ever seen. Have to have some mongrel in there somewhere :p

the unknown said:
Overall, quite good. Heres an amended version of your team Flawed.


FB Patterson (Williamstown) - O'Shea (Williamstown) - Sullivan (St Bernards) FB
HB Stephens (Williamstown) - Calman-Orr (Williamstown) - Johnson (Williamstown) HB
C Huxtable (Werribee) - Liberatore (St Bernards) - Wallis (St Bernards) C
HF Dean (Werribee) - Mitchell (St Bernards) - Schroder (St Bernards) HF
FF Mead (Williamstown) - Harrington (Werribee) - Grosso (St Bernards) FF
R Fairley (Williamstown) - Conway (Williamstown) - McKenzie (Williamstown) R
I Rafferty (Altona) - L Madden (St Bernards) - Shibeci (Werribee) - McLellan (Werribee) - Quarrier (Hoppers Crossing) - Casley (Williamstown) I


Patterson as a roughy for Willy, or more so that I had no idea who to put in the pockets. I doubt Sullivan's ever played bp in his life either.
Click to expand...

Fair enough. Quarrier out, Overton Skinner into the bench.. & I'd still have Quinn in there. Stapleton out, Calman-Orr to CHB, Dean to a HFF.

But Spotswood's McKenzie out is a mistake, IMO. Still would be a dominant team playing against most other leagues.

FB Quinn (Spotswood) - O'Shea (Williamstown) - Sullivan (St Bernards) FB
HB Stephens (Williamstown) - Calman-Orr (Williamstown) - Johnson (Williamstown) HB
C Huxtable (Werribee) - Liberatore (St Bernards) - Wallis (St Bernards) C
HF Dean (Werribee) - Mitchell (St Bernards) - Schroder (St Bernards) HF
FF Mead (Williamstown) - Harrington (Werribee) - Grosso (St Bernards) FF
R Fairley (Williamstown) - Conway (Williamstown) - McKenzie (Williamstown) R
I Rafferty (Altona) - L Madden (St Bernards) - Shibeci (Werribee) - McLellan (Werribee) - Quarrier (Hoppers Crossing) - Casley (Williamstown) I
 
Flawed Genius said:
Harder than Phil Johnson. I have never, repeat never seen this kid back away from any contest with anyone. If not in the team for skill level then pure toughness. He'd kill a forward pocket in 3 seconds.
Click to expand...

You can say whatever you want about him, but nobody, I repeat, NOBODY in the WRFL U16's is harder than Phil Johnson.

Flawed Genius said:
But Spotswood's McKenzie out is a mistake, IMO. Still would be a dominant team playing against most other leagues.
Click to expand...

Ok, I guess we could chuck him on the bench. But I still don't agree with you on Quinn. As hard as he is, I'd have Patto ahead of him anyday. I'm keeping Quarrier in there, I reckon he's a gun. On closer inspection, I'm taking Trent Rafferty out, he's over-rated, a dog, and I pretty much just don't like Altona, so we'll chuck McKenzie in there.

FB Patterson (Williamstown) - O'Shea (Williamstown) - Sullivan (St Bernards) FB
HB Stephens (Williamstown) - Calman-Orr (Williamstown) - Johnson (Williamstown) HB
C Huxtable (Werribee) - Liberatore (St Bernards) - Wallis (St Bernards) C
HF Dean (Werribee) - Mitchell (St Bernards) - Schroder (St Bernards) HF
FF Mead (Williamstown) - Harrington (Werribee) - Grosso (St Bernards) FF
R Fairley (Williamstown) - Conway (Williamstown) - McKenzie (Williamstown) R
I Mackenzie (Spotswood) - L Madden (St Bernards) - Shibeci (Werribee) - McLellan (Werribee) - Quarrier (Hoppers Crossing) - Casley (Williamstown) I
 
the unknown said:
You can say whatever you want about him, but nobody, I repeat, NOBODY in the WRFL U16's is harder than Phil Johnson.
Click to expand...

Bias must come into play here. Love to see the two play on each other.

the unknown said:
Ok, I guess we could chuck him on the bench. But I still don't agree with you on Quinn. As hard as he is, I'd have Patto ahead of him anyday. I'm keeping Quarrier in there, I reckon he's a gun. On closer inspection, I'm taking Trent Rafferty out, he's over-rated, a dog, and I pretty much just don't like Altona, so we'll chuck McKenzie in there.

FB Patterson (Williamstown) - O'Shea (Williamstown) - Sullivan (St Bernards) FB
HB Stephens (Williamstown) - Calman-Orr (Williamstown) - Johnson (Williamstown) HB
C Huxtable (Werribee) - Liberatore (St Bernards) - Wallis (St Bernards) C
HF Dean (Werribee) - Mitchell (St Bernards) - Schroder (St Bernards) HF
FF Mead (Williamstown) - Harrington (Werribee) - Grosso (St Bernards) FF
R Fairley (Williamstown) - Conway (Williamstown) - McKenzie (Williamstown) R
I Mackenzie (Spotswood) - L Madden (St Bernards) - Shibeci (Werribee) - McLellan (Werribee) - Quinn (Spotswood) - Casley (Williamstown) I
Click to expand...

I reckon Quinn > Quarrier.
Get Quarrier off the bench & put Quinn in there.
He deserves a spot.

Williamstown: 10 players
St Bernards: 7 players
Werribee: 5 players
Spotswood: 2 players
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Flawed Genius said:
Bias must come into play here. Love to see the two play on each other.



I reckon Quinn > Quarrier.
Get Quarrier off the bench & put Quinn in there.
He deserves a spot.

Williamstown: 10 players
St Bernards: 7 players
Werribee: 5 players
Spotswood: 2 players
Click to expand...

What and your not biased on Quinn, a Spotswood player. I'd take Quarrier over Quinn anyday. Quarrier plays Jets, Quinn isn't even close. Plus Quarrier played one or two U18's games this year, an excellent effort in anyone's book.
 
the unknown said:
What and your not biased on Quinn, a Spotswood player. I'd take Quarrier over Quinn anyday. Quarrier plays Jets, Quinn isn't even close. Plus Quarrier played one or two U18's games this year, an excellent effort in anyone's book.
Click to expand...

No, I agree that I'm biased.
There was bias on both sides
 
Well, I say Quinn, because he made the Jets squad but got cut before the first game, & because he's a little mongrel.

TU says Quarrier, even though he did nothing against us, didn't notice him.

What do you reckon Jimmy
 
Flawed Genius said:
Well, I say Quinn, because he made the Jets squad but got cut before the first game, & because he's a little mongrel.

TU says Quarrier, even though he did nothing against us, didn't notice him.

What do you reckon Jimmy
Click to expand...
Haven't seen much of Quarrier play.
so can't really comment on his games to much.
against williamstown he didn't seem to have a huge impact but neither did Quinn.
i know Quinn can play and does go in hard as i have seen first hand.
both good players too hard to choose.
they both have differnt style's.

Who's style of game do u think will suit the team better?
 
jimmy3 said:
Haven't seen much of Quarrier play.
so can't really comment on his games to much.
against williamstown he didn't seem to have a huge impact but neither did Quinn.
i know Quinn can play and does go in hard as i have seen first hand.
both good players too hard to choose.
they both have differnt style's.

Who's style of game do u think will suit the team better?
Click to expand...

There's a lot more outside running players than in and under players, so I'd say Quinn but there's a bit of bias in saying that.

How did the Olympics go?
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Here in the dream team thread, the Williamstown boys discuss Nathan Sambevski's sexuality. A fun time is sure to be had by all.
 
Moooooon21 said:
what u got up to FG these past 2 days?
Click to expand...

Been at Dad's. Sleeping till the afternoon, staying up till the early morning.. watching the Olympics, making good use of the deep fryer.

Yourself? Have you been going to school?
 

Remove this Banner Ad

U16's A & B dream team

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top