Analysis Umpires

[Graffy4242]

One thing that is an absolute certainty. You'll know who the AFL Umpiring panel rates as the top-4 umps when we see which group is doing the Coll v Ess match this week.

Hopefully Nafan


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[DangerousD]

Brad Scott got clarity from someone at the AFL about the holding the ball decisions from the bombers game.
The Ridley decision: “AFL said he had no prior but he could have attempted to dispose of the ball, as long as you throw a foot at it and miss it would be play on”

FMD, No, that is incorrect disposal.

I’m starting to be convinced the AFL wants as much grey as possible


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

The thing that annoys me about this is, the genuine attempt part, it sounds easy, but I constantly see players just drop the ball and nothing happens.

At least ping the blokes who drop it at the first sign of a tackle