Votes v Pies

[scottywiper]

3: Harvey, tried all day and is one player who uses the ball well
2: Rocca, well he was our forward line
1: Harris, chucked it in late, but who can blame him?

Rawlings, Simmo tried, Hale ok around the ground, Perry did well enough on Cloke and Trotter showed a bit. Gibbo once again did some nice things under siege.
The rest were highly disappointing.

 

[JerryWexler]

3.Harvey
2.Rawlings
1.Rocca

-3.Thompson
-2.Laidley
-1.Corey Jones

 

[pooley]

3. Rocca (6 goals even though his leads were being ignored all too often and the ball wasn't coming down there often anyway)
2. Harvey (he gets the ball, he kicks the ball, we get the next possession)
1. Rawlings (did his job on Lonie and got a lot of the pill but doen't hurt the opposition)

 

[CoastBhoy]

3- S.Rocca - 6 goals in a ******** of a day
2- D.Hale - 18 poss , 10 marks , tried hard.
1- B.Harvey - 30 poss , gave his all with little support.

 

[KingyOrTheKing]

3. Daniel Wells - actually grew some balls out there. Was good to see. Spoiling, tackling, smothering, other 1%ers. Hell. Who is this guy?? Never seen him before...

2. Harvey - Ran hard all day. Is one of the few midfielders who can be relied upon to deliver the ball cleanly to out forwards.

1 Rocca - Kicked some goals and was the only presence up forward.

 

[deano1]

3. Sav (age will not weary him, sign him up for another year now)

2. Harvey (Plenty of possesions, unfortunatly not where I would like him to be getting them, but worked hard)

1. Archer (tried his guts out, only played 3 1/4s but a few blokes who played 4 need to have a look at him.

 

[Dont think Do]

(3) Malthouse , dont know what he taught Ladiely but it wasnt much


no really

3) Sav 6 goals in a flogging like this is a great effort
2) Archer didnt play much but was one of only a couple that showed some ticker
1) Perry nice soild effort and was able to run off at times.

 

[Boro]

3. Rocca

2. Wells

1. Harvey

Shocking day and I fear it could be a long season ahead of us.

 

[ShovelstoShovels]

3 - Harris (the only man who gets in and under)
2 - Sav ( if you hit him on the chest, he'll do the rest)
1- Perry (learning his craft, tried his guts out)

 

[Z_K]

Jesus.

3 - Sav - Depressing.
2 - Hale - Meh. Played ok.
1 - Trotter - Kicked the footy better than anyone we had on the park. Comfortably. HAS TO PLAY FFS!!!


Laidley was deplorable. From the selections to the match ups. Absolute 3rd rate crap. WTF was Makepeace playing? If you are gonna take the punt with Spud on Taz, make sure Watt is there in case it doesn't work.

Green and Thurley. Stop gaps that don't bring much to the table. Depth players. At best.

He made the Hay call, and now he has to deal with it.

Rubbish performance. Could be a big, big year coming up for Mr Laidley.

 

[Angus1]

3 Rocca easily our best

2 Harvey was at least getting the ball going in our direction.


No one dserves a 1 vote because we only had 2 decent players today.



1 Perry. I can't give a vote to another onballer because Collingwoods onballers totally dominated today. We had 1 decent forward and the backs were up against it big time. Perry was one of our better backmen i suppose.

 

[viccles]

3)Rocca
2)Wells
1)Harris

 

[davefromjerra]

3. Rocca - Easily our best I thought
2. Hale - Tried all day
1. Grant - Although he was beaten on the day kicked a couple of goals and uses it well when he gets it.

Harvey, Rawlings and Simpson the best of the rest.

 

[Souup]

3 - Sav Rocca
2 - Daniel Wells
1 - David Hale

 

[razor]

3. rocca
2. wells
1. perry


worst

makepeace
firrito
green

and the rest

 

[Smudge]

3 Rocca
2 Wells
1 Boomer

Perry deserves another game and Gibson again played well under duress. I thought Glenn Archer played a typical Glenn Archer game until injured.

Just a little mystified with the umpiring. (Another post for another day)

 

[Dingster]

3. Sav (solo performance up forward)
2. Boomer (ran with the footy and looked to be positive at least)
1. Pez (made some mistakes, but at least he showed something)

Wells played on Holland. Some good signs, but couldn't give him a vote.

Rawlings was pretty good. Simmo tried, but no influence.

 

[Benno_900]

3- Sav
2- Hale
1- Boomer

 

[Lidge]

3. Rocca
2. Simpson
1. Harris

Couldn't give Harvey a vote (went missing when the heat was on during the 2nd & 3rd quarters).

 

[mighty mick]

3 rocca tried hard all day
2 ?.. harvey
1. i cant even justify a 1 vote not on that performance but heres nothing wells.

 

[Borak]

3. Rocca - welcome back
2. Harvey - atleast he put in a good effort
1. Wells - just for that spoil going back with the flight in the first quater, too much potential

Well done to Harris, Hale and Archer as well - the rest blew

 

[Mr Reliable]

What a letdown. PATHETIC. Never seen so many Roos members leave so early.

3. Sav- fantastic. kept presenting and what magnificent kicking.
2. B Rawlings- tried hard all day, accountable despite the overwhelming odds against him, ran the ball through the midfield and kicked well.
1. Harris- battled the odds all day against a losing ruck.

Couldn't fit Boomer in. A lot of junk possessions and didn't pick up his man.

Thommo is playing very poorly for a senior player. How many overhead marks can Shannon Grant drop in one game? Who was on Buckley? Sack our kicking coach. Get Firrito into the midfield.

Perry and Trotter weren't great but they showed some fight.

Hay??? Played Hawthorn 2005 style footy, only not as well as they did.

 

[gokangas]

3. Sav
2. Rawlings
1. Boomer

Best of the rest: Perry, Hale (two late misses inexcusable), Simmo (again marred by pathetic b-grade disposal), Wells and Gibson (100% tryer).

 

[Divado]

3. Sav
2. Harris
1. Harvey

Gibbo, Trotter, Perry were ok. Hale was ok, but we were beaten in teh ruck. Wells was quiet.

worst on ground 3. Hay
2. Thurley
1. Shaga was sh ite for his standards

I cant wait for Jesse Smith to get back.

 

[sloth6]

3 Votes: Sav Rocca (was a champion at Collingwood and still is.
2 Votes: Orange Witches Hat no. 1
1 Vote: Orange Witches Hat no. 5