Votes vs Brisbane

[Ripper]

5: Macpharlap - Superb defensive effort.
4: M Johnson - best game since 2006
3: Chopper Mayne
2: Pav
1: Rys Palmer

Honourable mentions to Grover , Ibbo , Sandi , Josh , Heathblack , Wiz , Grover.

 

[Bradesmaen]

5. Sandiman
4. McPharlin
3. Mi Johnson
2. Pav
1. Palmer

 

[The Night Shift]

5. Michael Johnson
4. Luke McPharlin
3. Mathew Pavlich
2. Heath Black [kicking was back to his best - very accurate today]
1. Rhys Palmer

 

[bigkev bleeds purple]

5 votes: Magic Johnson
4 votes: Luke McPharlin
3 votes: Rhys Palmer
2 votes: Aaron Sandilands
1 vote: Choppaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

Loved Heath Black's game too, just couldn't quite fit him in.

EDIT: I almost forgot to give Tarrant a mention too. Good game by him, got a fair bit of it and worked hard.

 

[Clay Davis]

5. Rhys Palmer. 30 possessions, 12 of them contested (and a good goal)
4. Michael Johnson
3. Luke McPharlin
2. Aaron Sandilands
1. Chris Tarrant (I thought he worked hard today)

 

[Shaymuhz]

5. Sandilands
4. Mcpharlin
3. Air Johnson
2. Pav
1. Tarrant

 

[rgauci]

5. Chris Mayne
4. Chris Tarrant
3. Michael Johnson
2. Aaron Sandilands
1. Matthew Pavlich

 

[chook2734]

5 - Michael Johnson
4 - Rhys Palmer
3 - Luke McPharlin
2 - Aaron Sandilands
1 - Chris Tarrant

 

[Dyslexic Emo]

5: Thornton
4: McManus
3: Mark Johnson
2: Peake
1: Mundy

 

[rgauci]

5: Thornton
4: McManus
3: Mark Johnson
2: Peake
1: Mundy

That is the anti-vote. Could of left Peake out.

 

[Reveler]

5. M.Johnson
4. L.McPharlin
3. R.Palmer
2. C.Tarrant
1. J.Farmer

 

[Freo Big Fella]

5 - Jonno
4 - Chopper
3 - Palmer
2 - McPharlin
1 - Tarrant

 

[Nodgey]

5. McPharlin
4. Michael Johnson
3. Palmer
2. Grover
1. Pavlich

 

[hoss]

5. Michael Johnson
4. Palmer
3. Mayne
2. Sandi
1. Tarrant

 

[E Shed]

5: Elvis
4: Magic Johnson
3: Rhys
2: Pav
1: Chopper

 

[masai]

5. Sandi
4. Elvis
3. Palmer
2. Mick Johnson
1. Tarrant

 

[Dr Zoiburg]

5. Sandiman
4. McPharlin
3. Mi Johnson
2. Pav
1. Palmer

Agree

 

[Kenny_01]

5- Palmer
4- Tarrant
3- Johnson
2- Sandilands
1- Pavlich

 

[FD369]

5. Rhys Palmer
4. Luke McPharlin
3. Michael Johnson
2. Aaron Sandilands
1. Chris Tarrant

 

[Freeeoo]

5. Rhys Palmer
4. Luke McPharlin
3. Michael Johnson
2. Aaron Sandilands
1. Chris Tarrant

Ditto

 

[Plugga]

5 Michael Johnson
4 Luke McPharlin
3 Rhys Palmer
2 Chris Mayne
1 Chris Tarrant

 

[Avid_Avenger]

5 - McPharlin
4 - Mi Johnson
3 - Palmer
2 - Sandi
1 - Tarrant

 

[Chops_a_must]

Don't know how people could leave Palmer out, anyway:


5. Palmer - work rate when getting beaten second to none. Don't care about anything else.
4. Mcpharlin - seemed to dominate back there.
3. Tarrant - supreme work ethic with little help.
2. MiJ - a lot of ball, but not getting to enough contests as a loose man has him down the order.
1. Sandi - tap accuracy looks to have improved a fair bit.

Pav was probably unlucky for mine.

Really hard to find another midfielder apart from Rhys out there...

 

[yakamoto]

5. MiJ
$. McPharlap
3. Rhys
2. Chopper
1. Pav

 

[PapaJ]

5 - McPharlin - quality player as he usually is when fit.
4 - Mayne - Can't wait till he's got a season or two under him.
3 - Pav - Although missed shots for goal again, he is still our most dangerous avenue to goal whether directly or in score assists etc.
2 - Sandi - faded out again and his lack of mobility is getting exposed more and more when we're not in posesion, but for what he can control he did well.
1 - Mi.Johno - great game though played a relatively 'easy' position as spare man and the Bris game style brought him into the game a lot, but still did his job very well.

Unlucky:
Palmer - such hard worker, I just can't believe this guys effort and amount of ball he gets. The ball use was average though and so I couldn't quite squeeze him in my votes.
Tarrant - worked hard, was dangerous and creative for most of the day.
Black - much improved game, been missing that dangerous left foot of his, but still not quite enough for votes