MVP Voting R9 vs Essendon Bombers

[Scully2Folau]

5-4-3-2-1 Giants fans.

 

[Mountain Giant]

Tough for me as there was a lack of consistency across quarters for individual players.

5 - Scully
4 - Shiel
3 - Tyson
2 - Cameron
1 - Treloar

Cornes and Giles struggled. As did Coniglio and Hampton.

Edit - oops forgot about Shiel.

 

[kulak]

Went to the game last night, thought we deserved to be closer.

5 - Treloar
4 - Cameron
3 - Shiel
2 - Ward
1 - Power

Cornes made some mistakes. Hampton doesn't seem to lead to the right spots when his team needs him, results in midfielders with no-one to kick it to.

 

[zorro1836]

5 / treloar was fantastic
4 / giles as soon as he was not ruck giants went backwards
3 / sheil good motor & skills
2 / townsend always hard at it,surprised how good he is in the hard stuff
1 / bugg solid & good run

 

[Gigantor]

5 Treloar - got involved, plenty of possessions, kicked a goal
4 Shiel - Shiel belies his years, he's so hard at it
3 Cameron - our best target (almost our only target)
2 Giles - continues using his strength to help the team, pinched a goal
1 Scully - nice mover when he gets a yard of space, helped shut down Stanton

 

[GreaterWeStener]

5 - Treloar
4 - Cameron
3 - Tyson
2 - Reid
1 - Scully

 

[Bogan Juniors]

5. Treloar
4. Shiel
3. Cameron
2. Coniglio
1. Scully

 

[Canberra_Giant]

5. Shiel
4. Scully
3. Treloar
2. Cameron
1. Tyson

 

[Booeycollector]

5- Shiel
4- Scully
3- Coniglio
2- Reid
1- Giles

 

[IanW]

5- Cameron
4- Treloar
3- Shiel
2- Scully
1- MacDonald

Unhappy with Cornes' lack of disposal skills. We missed Foalu's strength at CHF

 

[dlanod]

5. Treloar
4. Shiel
3. Cornes
2. Cameron
1. Giles

 

[deluge99]

5 - Treloar
4- Scully
3 - Shiel
2- Ward
1 - Giles

 

[Ichabod Noodle]

5. Treloar - the young ones just keep on standing up
4. Sheil - best game so far.
3. Townsend - just love the way he goes about it
2. Tyson - unobtrusive but effective
1. Sauce Phillips - kid has a whole lot of potential and did some really nice things.

honorable mentions to Cogs, Scully, Reid and Mohr, Giles and Cameron.

Curtley Hampton needs to wake up to himself and the Chadwick did some terrible things early but slowly got better

 

[Scully2Folau]

5 - Treloar
4 - Shiel
3 - Scully
2 - Cameron
1 - Power