What do you guys think of this trade

[tigerT]

haha greg tivendale

switch tivers with a player with some value and that seems more realistic to me, trading down 2 places and getting polak suits me, pies getting pick 8 and trading down from pick 10 to 13 and a reasonable player is also fair and freo get what they want....

substitute tivers with hartigan perhaps?

 

[Tigerbob]

haha greg tivendale

switch tivers with a player with some value and that seems more realistic to me, trading down 2 places and getting polak suits me, pies getting pick 8 and trading down from pick 10 to 13 and a reasonable player is also fair and freo get what they want....

substitute tivers with hartigan perhaps?

Tivendale did finish 6th in our B&F while Hartigan struggled to get into the 22! Very underrated player is Greg and he is a Collingwood supporter....with Collingwoods midfield looking a shambles, a quickish, left footer will add to their midfield, I think its fair for all parties involved.

Why would I then prefer to lose Tivendale rather than Hartigan? Well we have an abundance of outside midfielders comming through the ranks and since we are rebuilding it would be good to give these kids more responsibility next season.

Also, from what im hearing is Brent Hartigan could be on his way to the Bombers for Andrew Welsh. Terry loves Welsh as the tough nut in the middle with Polo, also if this happens, expect Tuck to be dealt for a second round draft pick. Just what im hearing from people around the traps!

In the end we could end up with:

Graham Polak
Joel Perry
Andrew Welsh
Pick 10
Pick 21
Second Round Pick (Mid 20's)

We Lose:

Andrew Krakouer
Greg Tivendale
Brent Hartigan
Shane Tuck
Pick 8
Pick 26

 

[Lenny*]

Why the **** are we getting rid of tuck all of the sudden?

He is one of the most important players at tigerland

 

[PLSC]

because he is actually a GOOD player, which means value

i dont care who we pick up just please god dont **** with our draft picks, give away any player you want

 

[footy4eva]

Really? Who are they?

tuck and cogs, poorly skilled players , yes can get the ball, but disposal way below par

 

[tigerT]

THE golden rule of football now and always, get first hands on the pill cant have a team full of jets that run sub 11 sec 100's, needs to be some balance