Which All Star player has been in the worst form this year?

[NT.Thunder]

Kerr imo should not be playing and having Cross as the Emerg is ridiculous!!!

Cross is way better then that hack KERR.

 

[wce_all_da_way]

Kerr imo should not be playing and having Cross as the Emerg is ridiculous!!!

Cross is way better then that hack KERR.

Classic.

I thought Glass wouldn't make it, and I didn't want him to. He needs a week off really.

 

[Atomboy]

On that note, find it unusual Lenny Hayes didn't get a guernsey ??.

He's been fantastic this year

 

[celtic_pride]

Josh Fraser - small hearted dud.

 

[Mike_blues]

fraser is a dud
i dont know how he got a game.. shows the depth in vic ruckman doesnt it?

 

[Tigersman]

Never hurts the numbers to throw a Collingwood player in when looking to fill a spot or two.

Davis- I don't rate him but yeah, ok
Pendlebury- shouldn't be there, a long way from this level.
Fraser- same.
Shaw-is good enough.

Sewell should consider himself very stiff. He has been great.

 

[Judda5]

Fraser has struggled like always.. and darren glass has been a bit scratchy this year but overall definately good enough to get a game. Not too sure about leon davis, small chance he could turn it on tho. GO VICS

 

[jazz]

Jonathon Brown is obviously untouchable.

He hasn't been in form this year and is only in the team on reputation.

 

[Power King]

fraser is a dud
i dont know how he got a game.. shows the depth in vic ruckman doesnt it?

^josh fraser was a #1 draft pick if i remember correctly

 

[pazza]

Suspect that Fraser probably wouldn't have played if Hille didn't have the pinched nerve in his neck which ruled him out and saw Simmonds called up.

 

[Gyroscope_182]

I too don't think Fraser is in that top 50 form, which is what this game suggests, but on the back of everyone, especially us Collingwood supporters suprised to see him in there, I personally think Fraser's rucking has been the best of his career.

We have all become accustomed to Josh being terrific around the ground and a failure as a ruckman. This year he has obviously taken the step of working on his rucking ability, and hasn't been the mobile man he used to be. When he does work harder around the game, hopefully both aspects will be included.

 

[Melbourne Lion]

Jonathon Brown is obviously untouchable.

He hasn't been in form this year and is only in the team on reputation.

Perhaps you should switch from bait to lures, because you certainly wont be catching any of us with that trash.

 

[JSFish]

Perhaps you should switch from bait to lures, because you certainly wont be catching any of us with that trash.

Well he's sorta on the money. No doubt Brown should be in the team, but if anyone else, Nathan Thompson for example, had played like Brown has the last few weeks, there is no chance he would be picked.

 

[celtic_pride]

Jeff White should be in the team ahead of Fraser ..

 

[PAFC_1]

On this years form... Kerr, by a mile

Yes I know he's one of the best players, but in that Eagles side, without his sidekicks he has been awful this year.

 

[El_Scorcho]

Perhaps you should switch from bait to lures, because you certainly wont be catching any of us with that trash.

One decent game plus one decent quarter?

He smashed West Coast in round one, then had a good last quarter against us when we basically weren't on the park. Well below his best, and if another forward without his name and reputation had had a start to season like that, they wouldn't be playing this weekend.

 

[Tippaz]

MOTLOP!!
he has played one good game kicking a cheeky bag against the hapless bombers.

hehehehehe
how very true.

he'll cop a teabagging from a worthy opponent like Campbell Brown or Darren Milburn.
totally doesn't deserve to be there.

 

[Rookie]

It's been consistent but unspectacular his 2008. Has had 1 brilliant game and about 2 good games. The other games he was just cruising. Probably very lucky to be in ahead of Sewell. As is Selwood IMO as Sewell has been fantastic.

An example of someone putting common sense above blind loyalty to their team and players. Respect.

 

[Altum Volantes]

On this years form... Kerr, by a mile

Yes I know he's one of the best players, but in that Eagles side, without his sidekicks he has been awful this year.

His first few weeks were great, has struggled since Priddis got injured..

 

[markr]

The howler for mine is Charman playing so that Choco can give Lade and Brogan a week off. Pick Lade on reputation or Brogan on form, but both are ahead of Charman.

 

[jazz]

Perhaps you should switch from bait to lures, because you certainly wont be catching any of us with that trash.

Not trolling - deadly serious.

His form this year doesn't warrant selection surely?

 

[candiehappy]

Jonathon Brown is obviously untouchable.

He hasn't been in form this year and is only in the team on reputation.

It's basically on last years form. Probably why Mooney was included also. But, in Browns case, was a good selection.

 

[Topendrumour]

many players picked on reputation not form.

Judd, Fraser, Waite, Griffen, Pendulberry, to think of a few

 

[eddiesmith]

Victoria have no better ruckman than Josh and only an idiot would suggest Hille

One player who was very bloody lucky was Bradshaw, should never have played ahead of Roughead

 

[Tigersman]

Victoria have no better ruckman than Josh and only an idiot would suggest Hille

One player who was very bloody lucky was Bradshaw, should never have played ahead of Roughead

Your kidding on both counts right?