Which Club in the league has the best squad suited to an all-in melee?

[Teebone]

If the shit hit the fan and there was a giant rumble, which team do you think would be most likely to come out on top?

 

[Happy Johnny]

If the shit hit the fan and there was a giant rumble, which team do you think would be most likely to come out on top?

Whoever Barry Hall is playing for

 

[Gozz]

I personally think Geelong, Saints or Hawks as they have the more experienced and developed players.

 

[Theprofessional]

Whoever Barry Hall is playing for

True, if it was mid of 2009 or after Staker was hit if a fight broke loose I'm quite sure Barry Hall would've killed somebody.

 

[Rustin Cohle]

Carlton. Chris Judd would nullify the eyesight of the opposition making for an easy victory.

 

[CarnThePiesfor09]

If everyone was going all out?

Honestly I think the Cats would slaughter anyone.

Players like Harley, Scarlett (who's a ****), Milburn & co. are all very physically developed (deeelicious) so I reckon they'd take most teams.

Oh and they have Mooney, who has intensity levels off the charts (which is pretty much all you need in a brawl anyways)

 

[tcwaters]

Geelong probably. Harley, Chappy, Mooney, etc. Wouldn't want to fight them in a hurry.. Having said that, it'd be good to watch J. Brown, Charman, Bradshaw and Merrett go toe to toe with 'em.

Then of course the Q Stick would come in and **** everybody up by himself..

 

[Godzke]

If everyone was going all out?

Honestly I think the Cats would slaughter anyone.

Players like Harley, Scarlett (who's a ****), Milburn & co. are all very physically developed (deeelicious) so I reckon they'd take most teams.

Oh and they have Mooney, who has intensity levels off the charts (which is pretty much all you need in a brawl anyways)

Geelong probably. Harley, Chappy, Mooney, etc. Wouldn't want to fight them in a hurry.. Having said that, it'd be good to watch J. Brown, Charman, Bradshaw and Merrett go toe to toe with 'em.

Then of course the Q Stick would come in and **** everybody up by himself..

Although I agree Geelong would win a scrap, you've both failed to mention by far the most dangerous animal in their team.

There wouldn't be a single player in the league that could beat Rooke in a fight (now barry hall is gone).

 

[Jatz]

Carlton. Chris Judd would nullify the eyesight of the opposition making for an easy victory.

pay that
except he would be going for pressure points remember

 

[master bate]

Moloney, Sylvia and McLean could get through half a side themselves, but the rest of the Melbourne team wouldn't be good for much.

 

[Can Opener]

what about cambpell browns bi**h slaps?? noone would wanna take him on surely

 

[SriLankanCat]

haha Geelong of course.

Yeah i agree ROoke, Milburn, Scarlett, Harley, Chapman, Mooney etc. would handle themselves well id imagine

 

[Happy Johnny]

I'd like to see 2007 Dockers vs 2009 Cats in a melee
that'd be a ripper with Solomon, Headland and the Carr brothers in Freo

 

[omit]

Moloney, Sylvia and McLean could get through half a side themselves, but the rest of the Melbourne team wouldn't be good for much.

Warnock has a bit of biff about him as well.
it's a shame wrecker is gone, he'd be a great in an all out brawl

 

[tcwaters]

Although I agree Geelong would win a scrap, you've both failed to mention by far the most dangerous animal in their team.

There wouldn't be a single player in the league that could beat Rooke in a fight (now barry hall is gone).

Good get I didn't even think of him.

**** that

 

[dan warna]

If the shit hit the fan and there was a giant rumble, which team do you think would be most likely to come out on top?

max rooke, scarlett and cameron mooney, Rooke looks about 20 seconds away from sending someone to hospital.

a few years ago i would have said at the saints Powell, baker, lawrence and Hamill would have carried a barney to the limit on their own.

Hall is a one man machine but the reason he doesn't enter the boxing ring is generally the other bloke hits back and is waiting for the hit from him, as opposed to snide punches when exposed.

the Brisbane boys under leigh Matthews were a killing machine.

 

[Boogoos]

going on this year i feel st kilda have some big bodies that would throw down

 

[winty]

Moloney, Sylvia and McLean could get through half a side themselves, but the rest of the Melbourne team wouldn't be good for much.

Max Rooke could take out that trio with one arm tied behind his back.

 

[dylan123]

I would like to see Brisbane in it because i think Brown could take out about 10 by himself.

 

[phantom13]

An interesting thought would be the kangaroos, Brent Harvey's scrubber missus would love to throw a few. She would have a fair crack at taking out Richmond at least.

 

[AFLOnline]

LOL at people saying Saints. Just because we are good, doesn't necessarily mean we are a bunch of fighters.

I can't see anyone in our club that would actually stand a chance in a all in brawl. Baker would be the obvious one to go alright and maybe Goddard and Kosi. The rest wouldn't be to much chop.

 

[Spluff]

Hall is a one man machine but the reason he doesn't enter the boxing ring is generally the other bloke hits back and is waiting for the hit from him, as opposed to snide punches when exposed.

You know Hall was the U18 Australian boxing champion, right?

 

[Coooooooneyyyyyyyy]

Dogs have Ryan Hargrave anyone remember St kilda v bulldogs a few years ago ryan left heath black on the ground, ryan quit karate because he broke his masters leg hahahae

 

[Rosstickle]

Although I agree Geelong would win a scrap, you've both failed to mention by far the most dangerous animal in their team.

There wouldn't be a single player in the league that could beat Rooke in a fight (now barry hall is gone).

Hawkins and Ottens are monsters too.

 

[scotty4]

no one could reach sandilands, hed just pick people up and throw them.