Which young four would you prefer?

[Donakebab]

The Essendon quartet aren't from the same draft either. Massive fail from you. Completely irrelevant post from you.

Never said they were, there was a plural for drafts as thought Daniher and Kolo came from the same draft. The rest line up from the same draft years, so while not massive it's a fail and will cop it on the chin. Still far more relevant as the four Hawthorn players aren't even in the poll, so they are in fact irrelevant.

 

[Mitchell54]

Good, because I wouldn't give up Daniher for all 4.

 

[Mitchell54]

Never said they were, there was a plural for drafts as thought Daniher and Kolo came from the same draft. The rest line up from the same draft years, so while not massive it's a fail and will cop it on the chin. Still far more relevant as the four Hawthorn players aren't even in the poll, so they are in fact irrelevant.

Then your replying to a irrelevant post. It's irrelevant replying to a irrelevant post.

 

[Bobby_]

Laverde and Daniher are going to be genuine stars. Daniher is already getting there despite having placed less than 50 games thus far.

Nakia Cockatoo probably has the most potential out of the eight players listed. His athletic qualities (leaping, strength, speed) coupled with his sublime skills . . . it will only ever be a mentality issue/desire to succeed for him.

 

[ParapMarkets]

F***! I hate polls where I have to vote for Essendon, but like the Heppell poll I have go with the bombers here.

 

[Dazb86]

I rate the Bombers group.

 

[Lethality]

Nakia Cockatoo probably has the most potential out of the eight players listed. His athletic qualities (leaping, strength, speed) coupled with his sublime skills . . . it will only ever be a mentality issue/desire to succeed for him.

How is he better than Jordan Murdoch?

 

[Bobby_]

How is he better than Jordan Murdoch?

potential and being better are two very different things hodgepodge.
Cockatoo's ceiling is off the charts. Murdoch's ceiling is what we see right now but with more consistency.

 

[Lethality]

potential and being better are two very different things hodgepodge.
Cockatoo's ceiling is off the charts. Murdoch's ceiling is what we see right now but with more consistency.

Ok, how is his potential better than Murdoch's?

 

[Bobby_]

Ok, how is his potential better than Murdoch's?

his vertical leap is incredible http://www.geelongcats.com.au/video/2015-07-20/cockatoo-flies-r16
something in which Murdoch does not possess. His aggression is a feature of his game from what we saw when he played VFL this year and this is most definitely a side of Murdoch's game which is lacking. I also like the way Cockatoo tries to take on players. He has enormous confidence in his own ability and this is an 18 year old kid we are talking about, not someone who is 23 years of age and been in the system for four seasons now.