Who Is Your Favourite Magpie?

[Jesus Baulks]

Ball..

 

[TradeDraft]

Dawsey!!!!!

 

[Scottabe_pendles]

Didak, I will never like a player more then Dids.

Agreed - unless there was didak with like daisy's running and balls hardness etc.

 

[Antz]

Swanny of course. Looks like I'm the only one who has voted for him so far.

 

[WakeUpPies]

Grew up idolizing Taz, good to have him back.

 

[Heritier 09]

toovey no votes?
i'm shocked, was getting ready to see his name rivalling daisy's, who clearly at present gets the Big Footy nod.
i voted for Harry, loved him when i joined this site, (obviously) and still think there's nothing more exciting then watching him bust tackles and just go from the backline.

top 5
Harry
Daisy
Toovs
Dids
BJ

 

[Dan3490]

Steele.

 

[mattys123]

Tooooooooovey.

I am leaning this way too.

I love the talent and skill that Pendles, Swan, Thomas, Dids, Shaw etc have, but I don't think any player we have has improved his value to us over the past few seasons more then Tooves.

As shown by his absence during the Geelong game, and the following week, we really do need Toovey if we are going to go back to back.

Plus, you just have to love the Possum.

 

[damuzzdu]

I just can't vote for just one player, just no way.

as Mick said on the podium on GF2 day.

"I love them all"

well Mick thanks so i will pinch that....

"I love them all"

from the Lukey Ball down to Tom Young

 

[Texy]

leroy & taz

 

[The New Breid]

Reid
Pendles
Beams

 

[coldpieswarmbeer]

went ahead and ranked them - decided brad dick is still my fav despite how i feel about thomas. if you ask me again tomorrow though they will surely change!


33 Brad Dick
13 Dale Thomas
10 Scott Pendlebury (vc)
39 Heath Shaw
12 Luke Ball
36 Dane Swan
34 Alan Toovey
21 Sharrod Wellingham
32 Travis Cloke
31 Chris Dawes
20 Ben Reid
22 Steele Sidebottom
6 Tyson Goldsack
18 Darren Jolly
4 Alan Didak
17 Dayne Beams
30 Brent Macaffer
16 Nathan Brown
7 Andrew Krakouer
1 Leon Davis
8 Harry O'Brien
14 Luke Round
11 Jarryd Blair
2 Chris Tarrant
26 Ben Johnson
19 Cameron Wood
5 Nick Maxwell (c)
3 John McCarthy
27 Simon Buckley

 

[jerry springer]

1.Dawes
2.Leon
3.harry

 

[coldpieswarmbeer]

looking back at those ratings... its seriously tough to decide. cos i do like them all. and just because i have the captain that low doesnt mean i dont rate him or like him - just felt stronger about the others..

 

[bushpie]

I to am loving them all.............................

So I am reluctant to vote ....its too darn hard

Last year I was very impressed by the efforts of "The Anvil" and now this year Simon Buckley is giving us something back.

so nope cant pick one

 

[damuzzdu]

went ahead and ranked them - decided brad dick is still my fav despite how i feel about thomas. if you ask me again tomorrow though they will surely change!


33 Brad Dick
13 Dale Thomas
10 Scott Pendlebury (vc)
39 Heath Shaw
12 Luke Ball
36 Dane Swan
34 Alan Toovey
21 Sharrod Wellingham
32 Travis Cloke
31 Chris Dawes
20 Ben Reid
22 Steele Sidebottom
6 Tyson Goldsack
18 Darren Jolly
4 Alan Didak
17 Dayne Beams
30 Brent Macaffer
16 Nathan Brown
7 Andrew Krakouer
1 Leon Davis
8 Harry O'Brien
14 Luke Round
11 Jarryd Blair
2 Chris Tarrant
26 Ben Johnson
19 Cameron Wood
5 Nick Maxwell (c)
3 John McCarthy
27 Simon Buckley

CPWB,

I think it unfair that u put yr list like that....

You should have imo put them into say grps...as it then if u start wanting say on Simon Buckley dropped you are basing on "i dont like him" rather than sticking to facts.

You should have imo put them into grps ....

"really really like"

"really like"

Then rest into grp called - still like but not as much as the above grps.

This is just me...

 

[coldpieswarmbeer]

i get what you're saying but again i stress, theres not a player on our list i dont like and wish they were gone. simon buckley - just naturally by being one of the newest additions, is rather low on my favourites list. nothing against him personally or as a player. in fact hes doing a great job filling in while johnson is out.

also he reminds me of lonie with his run and bombs from 50. thats a good thing

 

[Cousin of Daicos]

Didak is on my jumper, but Pendlebury is actually my favourite, and pretty much has been since Bucks retired.

 

[sloth6]

Thomas
BALL
Pendles
Dids
Dick - purely caus of his enthusiasm, hand claps and head rubs after every goal.

Not much love for Luke Ball - just gotta love the way he goes about his footy.

 

[BuckleysBrigade]

70 votes, and the captain has 0! Jonathan Brown would have 70...

 

[PieNSauce]

Thomas
Not much love for Luke Ball - just gotta love the way he goes about his footy.

Yeah well said sloth! Going to love watching gentleman Luke run out on the park tomorrow and make the aints weep all over again!

 

[Jesus Baulks]

Thomas
BALL
Pendles
Dids
Dick - purely caus of his enthusiasm, hand claps and head rubs after every goal.

Not much love for Luke Ball - just gotta love the way he goes about his footy.

Ball couldn't even get a spot on the list! Outrage!

 

[Markfs]

I hope we can add Sean Rusling to the list and have a proper vote...

 

[damuzzdu]

I hope we can add Sean Rusling to the list and have a proper vote...

I want Scott Cummings on da list....

 

[PieBeast]

Interesting to note that Swanny despite being our best player in the last few years isn't getting much love.....