Strategy Trade and List Management Thread Part 7 (opposition supporters - READ posting rules before posting)

[iambrilliant]

22 is definitely on the table for Daniel but not as a straight swap. Likely 22 and 40 for 32 and Daniel.

Where do we sign

 

[Bulldog in Kiev]

Adelaide media reporting Peatling has also met with them. Peatling to the crows not the pies

 

[CaptainMurphy]

Oh no we don’t win the trade period then I wish we could be like the bombers and win it every year instead we will just have to hope on natural progression from Darcy Ugle-Hagan Richards Naughton Busslinger Weightman Sanders O’Donnell West Freijah

I don't want us to "win" trade period, but I'd like to see us respond to whatever deficiencies we learned we had from the season with a couple handy trades. We can't just rely on natural development for that.

 

[Pencil case]

22 is definitely on the table for Daniel but not as a straight swap. Likely 22 and 40 for 32 and Daniel.

I’d pack Daniel’s lunch, fasten his back pack, kiss him on the forehead and drive him down to Arden Street.

 

[Hobdog]

Don’t need context for some things. Matt Eagles

And there it is. Was wondering when Eagles would get a run


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[CaptainMurphy]

Any idea what a trade for O'Halloran would look like?

 

[Hoges64]

Any idea what a trade for O'Halloran would look like?

Still one year left on contract, something around the mid-30's?

 

[Foxman98]

I don't want us to "win" trade period, but I'd like to see us respond to whatever deficiencies we learned we had from the season with a couple handy trades. We can't just rely on natural development for that.

Which we can address in the draft

 

[King Harold]

22 is definitely on the table for Daniel but not as a straight swap. Likely 22 and 40 for 32 and Daniel.

Getting more realistic.
Not even North will give up 20 for a 28 yr old Daniel.

 

[Dogs Rule]

On the pain index, Trade Radio is just Roaming Brian with ads

It's basically breakfast rage baiting, 'mega trade' brain farts from the dumb as a doorpost Cooney, repeats of the rage baiting from the morning, more rage baiting for drive and then hypotethicals to leave you with for the day.

That's the 9 minutes in the hour that aren't ads...

 

[grassman75]

Just listened. Rocket as always is very good to listen to. Reminds me of listening to Terry Wallace, super intelligent.
His reading of the Bailey Smith trade is what a few have been saying here, that the pressure is actually on Geelong now because they’ve made all the big promises. In the Jeremy Cameron trade they didn’t want to give up all those top picks to GWS, but in the end they had to because they wanted him and promised him.

I think his assessment of Naughton and JUH was very interesting and Darcy and also how good of a job Bevo has done with what he had at his disposal. He knows that VDM and McNeill aren’t the best players, but they are what we’ve got. That’s where we will improve, upgrading positions like that.

Weightman to get fitter and play mid is what he reckons should happen

 

[CaptainMurphy]

Which we can address in the draft

And likely have to wait on at least a year or two of development to see the benefits of. Trading is important. Nobody's saying "Butters or we're ****ed", but I think it's reasonable to be disappointed if we don't attract anyone that really improves us. Not even blaming the club, just would like to see it happen.

 

[dergert]

I’d pack Daniel’s lunch, fasten his back pack, kiss him on the forehead and drive him down to Arden Street.

Id think both picks and CD would be too much?

 

[Foxman98]

And likely have to wait on at least a year or two of development to see the benefits of. Trading is important. Nobody's saying "Butters or we're ****ed", but I think it's reasonable to be disappointed if we don't attract anyone that really improves us. Not even blaming the club, just would like to see it happen.

Freijah impacted instantly this year for us

Wilmot Morris Fletcher all drafted in the last 2-3 years impacted on Saturday

Mannagh was huge for Geelong trading in B-C graders aren’t going to make this massive impact you seem to think here

 

[grassman75]

NORTH WAITING ON DANIELS DECISION

NORTH WAITING ON DANIELS DECISION

todayspaper.theaustralian.com.au

The Kangaroos spoke with Western Bulldogs’ playmaker Caleb Daniel last week and are expected to land Swans’ veteran Luke Parker, 31, and West Coast forward Jack Darling, 32, next month.

Daniel, 28, is yet to decide whether he will pursue a move from the kennel, following jet ballwinners Bailey Smith (Geelong) and Jack Macrae (St Kilda) out the door. He is expected to make a call on his future this week, after talks with the Kangaroos on their vision for the next few seasons and the Dogs about his spot in the side.The Dogs could demand a second-round pick for Daniel who played 16 games this year, including his best performances in the last three games of the season.

In particular, Daniel’s excellent kicking skills would help North’s ball movement in the back half and middle of the ground.

But the Dogs would hold the upper hand in any trade talks on Daniel’s future, as he is contracted on a deal worth about $700,000 until the end of 2026. The Dogs can also afford to keep Daniel, who is a popular team member, as the departures of Smith and Macrae clear up significant salary cap space for the club.

The irony of Norf getting rid of all their older players and rotting at the bottom of the ladder for the best part of a decade and now they recruit washed up old blokes, essentially putting them back to where they were 10 years ago

 

[grassman75]

Not to get ahead of ourselves, but unless a player is included, would we have the necessary trade capital to satisfy port with current/future picks?

Would Geelong?

 

[VitalDread]

Any idea what a trade for O'Halloran would look like?

GWS would ask for our second rounder

So we could do

Him + F3
Second Rounder + 4th

 

[Doggy]

GWS would ask for our second rounder

So we could do

Him + F3
Second Rounder + 4th

No thanks... they can convince Peatling to come to us and we could package both

 

[cherrypie]

Any idea what a trade for O'Halloran would look like?

 

[Pencil case]

GWS would ask for our second rounder

So we could do

Him + F3
Second Rounder + 4th

Not worth it imo. Would only be trading a 3rd rounder for him at most.

 

[Foxman98]

Not worth it imo. Would only be trading a 3rd rounder for him at most.

Wouldn’t be paying more than that for Peatling either both 24 and would struggle to have 100 games combined (minus ones as sub).

Peatling had a solid finish to the year so can see the appeal but at the same time wouldn’t want to spend too much on a fairly unproven talent in terms of consistency

 

[DiamondDogs8]

Oh no we don’t win the trade period then I wish we could be like the bombers and win it every year instead we will just have to hope on natural progression from Darcy Ugle-Hagan Richards Naughton Busslinger Weightman Sanders O’Donnell West Freijah

Weird post. Who sh*t in your cornflakes?

It’s perfectly natural to look at players that will lift our bottom 6. A couple of problem areas on the list that we’d be better off addressing. Players like Peatling and XOH address that.

 

[El Rancho]

Would a guy like Hinkley swap all his top 4s for 2GFs and a flag?

Of course not. Why would he want that?
If he swapped his top 4's for 2 GF's and 1 flag, he would clearly be the number 1 coach under the pump next year.
Wouldn't wish that on anyone

 

[Foxman98]

Weird post. Who sh*t in your cornflakes?

It’s perfectly natural to look at players that will lift our bottom 6. A couple of problem areas on the list that we’d be better off addressing. Players like Peatling and XOH address that.

Peatling is 24 and played 45 games with a large number as sub XOH is 24 and played 67 they may or may not upgrade out B22 but the reality is the difference they’d make isn’t going to be that significant to pretend we should call the period a “disaster” they’re C graders at best

 

[Chalky White]

Would a guy like Hinkley swap all his top 4s for 2GFs and a flag?

Since 2016 I would take Ports record over ours anytime