Search results for query: *

Remove this Banner Ad

  1. Cleric

    Opinion Does WA underperform in producing AFL talent?

    I think there is greater issues in both SA and WA about Jr Development resources. The SANFL and WAFL are expected to fund and execute Jr development in both SA and WA, with the minimal resources they have. On the other hand, the AFL pumps millions into the development of Victorian kids. Imagine...
  2. Cleric

    Player Watch Daniel Curtin - Debut

    I think he is still not sure yet. Has two more years anyway.
  3. Cleric

    Player Watch Luke Nankervis - Re-Signed to End of 2027

    And his last season coincides with the new Tasmanian team. Alot of players his age will use the threat of the Tasmanian team to get a bigger wage.
  4. Cleric

    AFL Culture needs to grow up re: players waiting till end-of-season to reveal that they are planning to move out

    So if you are happy that you think you know who is leaving, and that's without getting them to have to announce it prior, what are you losing out by the current situation? Let's not forget that a certain number of rumours of players moving is the manager driving up their players price. What...
  5. Cleric

    AFL Culture needs to grow up re: players waiting till end-of-season to reveal that they are planning to move out

    No, I don't think that has anything to do with growing up. Firstly, it will put the fans at odds with the player. Don't bring up NRL as an example, because NRL fans are nowhere near fanatical as AFL ones are. Secondly, it puts the player at odds with the club and his team mates. This isn't...
  6. Cleric

    NO TROLLS Collingwood CEO Craig Kelly involved in racism & homophobia allegations lodged in court documents

    Sometimes it's out of the control of the person. I am sure Collingwood have indemnity insurance, and so the legal defence is being undertaken by an insurance company. The insurance company may make a decision that its cheaper to give the accuser 50k than to defend it in court, so the insurance...
  7. Cleric

    List Mgmt. Which young mids will work out?

    We have a bit of a young midfield group, and a number of them will make it at AFL, and others won't. I'm using 150 games by the end of their career as the pass mark. It doesn't have to mean that they play the 150 games with us, but throughout their career total.
  8. Cleric

    Hobart Stadium: $750 million cost

    Is the stadium capable of upgrading capacity? While Tasmania has a lower population than other areas, I would fully expect them to sell out the current planned capacity pretty much every game, and without the ability to increase capacity along with growth of the state and supporters, it could be...
  9. Cleric

    List Mgmt. 2025 List Mismanagement and Trading

    Ok, I have asked this on a number of places but can't get an answer. If there is an U17 kid tied to a club via FS or Academy, and Tasmania gets the pick of the U17s for their initial squads, who gets preference on the kid?
  10. Cleric

    List Mgmt. 2025 List Mismanagement and Trading

    The SA and Academy kids always fall back as the year goes on.
  11. Cleric

    List Mgmt. 2025 List Mismanagement and Trading

    Priority 1. Ruck. Priority 2. Dyson Sharp. Priority 3. Tall forward/ruck position
  12. Cleric

    Mod. Notice Seeking a new Adelaide Board Moderator

    This place would be all action if that was the case. Chiefs inbox would be getting smashed.
  13. Cleric

    Welcome Welcome to Adelaide: Tyler Welsh - Pick 59, 2024

    The fact we were so adamant that we would take him, even with his average form this year, led me to believe that everything was going according to plan.
  14. Cleric

    Draper and cohort concerned

    Not only that, but the position it put Sid in was terrible. He loved the Crows and wanted to get here, and then some flog puts out a story like that which could ruin his dreams and put him at odds with the club he loves.
  15. Cleric

    List Mgmt. Operation - Get Dyson Sharp 2025.

    Phillipou was a rabid Port fan by all accounts, so he would go back to the Pear one would think.
  16. Cleric

    Welcome Welcome to Adelaide: Tyler Welsh - Pick 59, 2024

    I'm starting to think that Welsh did pull back this year to let his draft spot fall.
  17. Cleric

    Welcome Welcome to Adelaide: Sid Draper - Pick 4, 2024

    I think he just wanted it to be true so that the club got punished more for what they did to Josh.
  18. Cleric

    Toast Thanks Brad, Crouch Retires

    Brad was a really good player, and would have seen more success if it wasn't for his injuries. I was upset when he left the club, and hopefully he has a great after football life.
  19. Cleric

    List Mgmt. Ok, so where is our midfield at now? Whats your Game 1 starting group?

    We had a pretty obvious deficiency in our midfield, preferring to rebuild from the KPPs out. So, where does our midfield sit now? Is it fixed? I think we have a decent midfield that has alot of points of difference. Peatling, Crouch, Dawson, Soligo, Draper, Cummins, Dowling, Scholl, Taylor...
  20. Cleric

    Welcome Welcome to Adelaide: Sid Draper - Pick 4, 2024

    You remember all the talk that he didn't want to come here, and preferred to go to Vic or Port? Just how crazy was it for the media to put out such blatant lies. For what purpose?
  21. Cleric

    Draper and cohort concerned

    Crazy just how wrong all this talk was. He was desperate to try and get to the Crows.
  22. Cleric

    List Mgmt. Operation - Get Dyson Sharp 2025.

    Yeah, a very important player, and one you would have thought would have got the maximum amount of effort from the club.
  23. Cleric

    List Mgmt. Operation - Get Dyson Sharp 2025.

    No, I'm saying that it is way less than I thought there would be. I had an expectation that the club was always in their ear, always telling them they really want them at the club, from when they were a Jr and up. Now, what's the right amount of contact, I'm not sure. I'm not a list manager or a...
  24. Cleric

    List Mgmt. Operation - Get Dyson Sharp 2025.

    Ah, you are one of those supporters.
  25. Cleric

    List Mgmt. Operation - Get Dyson Sharp 2025.

    It worked. My point isn't that the club is wrong, but it was way less contact than I thought there would be. I guess there is a point of wearing out your welcome which the club has to navigate, but I thought they would spend a heap of time and effort on them.
  26. Cleric

    Prediction Am I too hyped on Riley Thilthorpe?

    Yeah, 208cms is an absolutely massive unit. Most guys that height are confined to ruck work, as they are too unco to be a legitimate full time forward. He is going to have the advantage of height to out mark his opponent. This is why I see RT as a better talent. Darcy to me is a mark and kick...
  27. Cleric

    Prediction Am I too hyped on Riley Thilthorpe?

    Darcy is one year younger and seven centimetres taller. For me Darcy is a tall mark and kick forward.
  28. Cleric

    Prediction Am I too hyped on Riley Thilthorpe?

    I posted a question in the main board about who was going to be the most dominant out of the group of young tall forwards that care coming up. Amongst them was Thilthorpe, Deer, Darcy, Andrews, Kings etc. To my surprise, the majority of the respondents were saying Darcy by a mile. Now, I...
  29. Cleric

    List Mgmt. Operation - Get Dyson Sharp 2025.

    Because I know. I was of the opinion that we kept in touch all the time, including when they were Jrs and we knew we couldn't get them in the draft, telling them we will get them home, but when I spoke to a Crows player who was recently poached from interstate, and I suggested the club would...
  30. Cleric

    Review Grade your team's trade period

    It looks like our list managers stuffed up by not putting themselves in a position to get Dobson in the draft. Outside of that, we addressed the needs in our midfield and brought in another forward cheaply. All in all, A-
Back
Top