Search results for query: *

Remove this Banner Ad

  1. W

    The same players continue to fail when we lose

    will never win a flag whilst butchers of the ball like obree, johnson play in the side. Mick you have had ten years to rectify this
  2. W

    Brendan Fevola Trade Thread

    Re: Fev trade arghh, can see it now. S O'B and Beeny J screaming through the middle and hitting a leading Fev on the left tit. The sight is just wonderful and clear
  3. W

    Delistings and retirements

    cant see two of Lockyer, o'bree and johnson being on the list next year and we are in trouble if they are
  4. W

    Liability players

    I am sorry to sound like a broken record, but Collingwood will not win a flag whilst Johnson gets a game, will not man up and will not chase as shown yesterday when he left Fraser to chase eagleton. I believe O'Bree will again be a liability in big games. Disagree with comments re Toovey and...
  5. W

    Short, shallow draft

    Clubs will scout the vfl, SANFL, WAFL etc for talent. Who would fit the criteria in the SANFL
  6. W

    Benny Johnson

    Unfortunately have to agree, dont know about the favourites thing, but I believe that the structurte of the side is poor, the key positions of ruck and midfield are undermanned and exposed, and our trade record is lamentable. Disipline within the club is questionable. I think it may be a...
  7. W

    Benny Johnson

    Surely Johnson is not in our best 22 and must be doubtful to be at the Club in 2009. Supporters have got to stop kidding themselves that Collingwood is a successful club. We have won two premierships since I was born FFS.
  8. W

    Trading or Drafting another Ruckman?

    Trade for Taylor from Hawthorn, right age and skills
  9. W

    Our young list is about to get younger

    Would it not be a smart move to retain S Burns on our coaches list should he decide to retire. He all the attributes of a coach in the making.
  10. W

    Who are the kids you are excited about?

    What about south adelaide youngester peter rolfe.. got pace, good skills and can kick a goal.. any chance.?
  11. W

    Draft Review 2005 - Redo the 2005 Draft

    Re: 2005 Afl draft Re-Done Interesting to see who got it right and who got it wrong. I think there would be a fair shake up in the order if the whole 2005 draft was redone today.
  12. W

    Malthouse must accept some responsibility

    In football clubs it all stems from the top. This has been going on for years and the administration have turned a blind eye for all of that time. The club uis there to win premierships which we are not very good at. This crap and type of behaviour will only lengthen the tome to the next one...
  13. W

    R18: Port v St Kilda review

    Watching game today felt Cassisi work rate and preparedness to get under the pack was exceptional, De Luca was very good in the ruck contest, won a lot of hitouts, needs to get to a few more contests around the ground. Carlile's work on Reiwoldt was good, Nick could have torn it up today...
  14. W

    Mike Sheahan - Pg 35 Hearld Sun

    Forget about Pendlebury, he is not the problem. The problem is the likes of O'Bree, Johnson, R Shaw_ Guys that were there in 2002/03, not good enough then , not good enough now. Talk about list management, problems we had in 2002/03 were in ruck and midfield. Prblems we have in 2008/09 ruck...
  15. W

    De Luca

    In fairness I thought he got a number of taps, and made contest to a few more, but tends to look at the opposing ruckman too much and not all that enthusiastic around the ground. For those he tapped direct to J Carr where were our midfielders?
  16. W

    Draft Targets

    What would be considered the most pressing needs for the Club going forward, having regard to current list/possible exists
  17. W

    Trade Prospects - defenders

    If the team is looking to draft a young defender, one that will stand the test of time and fit in with the team age profile, who are the nominees: Brown from Collingwood, Warnock from Melbourne, Graham and Wilkes from WC, Chaplin and Carlile from Port, Ryder from Essendon. Any other nominees...
  18. W

    Players on our list that will not take us to a flag

    Isnt it amazing that we are talking like this, with the number of players that have been mentioned in this post (and I dont disagree with the sentiment) what have we been doing with list management over the last 5 years. A number of those mentioned were there in 2002/03 and werent good enough...
  19. W

    Shane OBree has to go!!

    Obviously a premiership is not on the agenda for some people, otherwise we would not continue to argue about players with crap skills. I cringe every time OBree goes near the ball, almost put a stubby thru the plasma on Sat nite at some of the crap decisions and ball use that is continually...
  20. W

    Somebody please tell me how the HELL did this happen!!??

    Too much handball and over finessing thru the middle especially prior to halftime, should have had Brisbane buried by halftime. Except for Tredrea no reliable forward presence and the unwillingness of the midfield to work the defensive side. Basically that is why Port lost. Simon Black and...
  21. W

    Merged: WTF Egan?!?!

    Re: Soft & Weak! The name of the game is to win premierships. Does Egan, Johnson and Wakelin inspire that thought. Can u win a flag with all of these players in the best 22. If not who are the replacements and they should be on the park sooner.
  22. W

    SANFL Tipping Round 1

    Could someone indicate a site that an interstate resident can access the SANFL teams, players etc
  23. W

    South Adelaide

    :D Trial games commencing shortly, who are the newbies to watch out for
  24. W

    Is it just me?

    Cannot win a premiership without a ruckman who can hold his own in the ruck. Cannot win a premiership as long as OBree plays for the club. Turnover king
Back
Top