Search results for query: *

  • Users: Cipher
  • Order by date

Remove this Banner Ad

  1. Cipher

    The best post/thread you ever read

    My memory doesn't extend beyond the past year so I'm overlooking years worth here, but Thylacine60's description of the mods offices was a great piece of creative writing.
  2. Cipher

    News Marc Murphy no certainty to be Captain in 2016?

    Wouldn't mind seeing Gibbs take it at all. I think Murph showed brilliant leadership in the second half of the season but I also think he would have a better end to his career by focusing just on his footy. Gibbs I can see stepping up in the role. I recall he worked a lot with Cripps last year...
  3. Cipher

    It was 6 months ago today

    I've felt it, many years. You may recall the vibe last year was the reason Judd went around again, I take more stock in that then the aforementioned examples. That's not to say the vibe isn't fantastic, let's just not pretend we've never been here before. I'm not hung up on any one point, but I...
  4. Cipher

    It was 6 months ago today

    OK. I'm interested in discussing just the topic, not getting into this.
  5. Cipher

    It was 6 months ago today

    No more so than: We've had many years over the last 10 start just as positive. All new coaches bring about positivity within the group - Bolton's ability to maintain a positive and united group, amidst the next few years of poor results is the key, and yet to be seen. Is that Robinson, Garlett...
  6. Cipher

    Retired 46. Matthew Wright Announces Retirement

    We have Tuohy, Curnow, Everitt, Gibbs and Kreuzer born in '89 and then Jones, Tutt, Whiley, Casboult born in the following three years between '90-'92. We need to replenish our senior stocks if we're to have a balanced list come time of our next charge, as this age group could certainly be a...
  7. Cipher

    It was 6 months ago today

    6 months ago we were criticising Malthouse for trading our talented forwards and bringing in recycled reserves players. Now we're praising SOS for, trading our talented forwards and bringing in recycled reserves players. We've also criticised the club for holding onto guys for too long - sort...
  8. Cipher

    Carlton Merchandise needs a complete overhaul

    Those 5% discounts look embarrassing next to the full price - but i quite like the hood, and would have thought the jacket has appeal to some. Actually the hoody is pretty cheap, might get one. Thanks :)
  9. Cipher

    Delisted 28. David Cuningham

    Love the no ****s given at 3:04 in the video.
  10. Cipher

    Senior 1. Jack Silvagni

    They do when they're getting a bargain. You're right it was smart how they handled it, but it shouldn't have mattered.
  11. Cipher

    Senior 1. Jack Silvagni

    Not sure how it matters even if it were - he's still a F/S selection, clubs should be reaching at times as well as be accepting the bargains otherwise, why have the rule.
  12. Cipher

    List Mgmt. 2015 AFL Draft - what type of players should we be looking at & who do we take? (Poll added)

    Meanwhile GWS casually pick up 3 guys in the top 16 to go with their 3 top 10 picks last year. Pretty ridiculous they're still stockpiling all this young talent.
  13. Cipher

    Delisted 28. David Cuningham

    Cuningham's break away speed looks elite, he learns to use that then he becomes elite. Have a good feeling about this pick.
  14. Cipher

    List Mgmt. 2015 AFL Draft - what type of players should we be looking at & who do we take? (Poll added)

    That break away from the centre square and goal was Judd in his prime. Pretty decent highlights.
  15. Cipher

    List Mgmt. 2015 AFL Draft - what type of players should we be looking at & who do we take? (Poll added)

    8 of the last 10 AA FB/CHBs were top 20 picks - if it were that easy to find quality at later picks Rowe wouldn't be running around with us. Which quality KPDs have been traded for cheaply? Don't assume Hawks success at attracting players will mean we can plug holes at will. Buddy and...
  16. Cipher

    List Mgmt. 2015 AFL Draft - what type of players should we be looking at & who do we take? (Poll added)

    Even a slide from 3 to 8 isnt exactly huge nor unheard of. We may have put more work into other players based on likelihood of who would be available, but surely we've done enough work on those higher rated guys that taking the slider becomes a no brainer.
  17. Cipher

    List Mgmt. 2015 AFL Draft - what type of players should we be looking at & who do we take? (Poll added)

    Will we have the picks to be excited this time next year? We'll need more than one high pick but, there's not exactly anywhere for that to come from.
  18. Cipher

    List Mgmt. 2015 AFL Draft - what type of players should we be looking at & who do we take? (Poll added)

    Given this would have been on the cards, I would have liked the Menzel trade to have included a late swap of pick 11 and 9 provided we secured it. Likely makes no difference to them anyway but means we're not needing to second guess our picks based on who is more likely to get past them.
  19. Cipher

    Mega Thread Oh yeah ... did you know there are 17 other teams? - General AFL discussion #9 - Blues posters only

    Not really a massive sook, club seemingly became a negative environment for him so the right decision is to leave.
  20. Cipher

    List Mgmt. 2015 AFL Draft - what type of players should we be looking at & who do we take? (Poll added)

    Wasn't last years the same though? McCartin and Petracca not set, and then most of the top 20 being largely interchangeable (Laverde and Boekhorst being top 10 prospects for instance).
  21. Cipher

    Carlton in the Media (articles, podcasts etc)

    Easy enough to do that without naming people and the inference that will then draw. If Martin makes a comment on Cripps then we are on here agreeing with Gaze that he should pull his head in - better to not make those comments at all, and my first reaction also was he needs to be better than...
  22. Cipher

    Carlton in the Media (articles, podcasts etc)

    "Look at Boyd, you don't even need to stay for 2 years"
  23. Cipher

    Preview Training reports, pics, training discussion, mustachioed 80s heartthrobs

    Yeah I hope we don't. How often do we see successful teams do this - great if they can plug a hole when injury hits, or if a match up is destroying us. But third talls switching, why, where's the long term benefit? Hopefully that experiment left with Lachie.
  24. Cipher

    Preview Training reports, pics, training discussion, mustachioed 80s heartthrobs

    Early days but with so many new faces is it evident that the group are more vocal? It's been a criticism for a number of years - not sure if it is limited to game day or has been an issue at training also.
  25. Cipher

    Lets not write off 2016

    With Giles and Holman only getting an extra 12 months, they'd want to be showing decent improvement given they currently may not be rated by Bolton/SOS.
  26. Cipher

    News Carlton Rebels Plotting Board Challenge

    On this, curious as to what would be due process? Presumably the best candidates would already be heading up a clubs list, how do you attract them in an open process? Once you've identified a preferred candidate how do you approach them? Freo poached a coach and it took them to the grand - was...
  27. Cipher

    Rumour *Separated discussion* Board, Mick, Rogers, whiteanting, powerbrokers, competency or lack thereof

    Where does Trigg suggest the purpose of the meeting was to seek a bailout? I daresay our wealthy supporters bring with them skills, contacts, opportunities and ideas that may actually help the club improve its position/stand on its own two feet.
  28. Cipher

    List Mgmt. 2015 AFL Draft - what type of players should we be looking at & who do we take? (Poll added)

    Not sure we'd be wanting to load up with A graders with all first 3 picks. Reckon we'll look at bringing in at least 1 B grader for list balace.
  29. Cipher

    List Mgmt. 2015 AFL Draft - what type of players should we be looking at & who do we take? (Poll added)

    Unless so called bolters are who we are targeting. Both Carlton and SOS don't have a history of taking the consensus picks.
  30. Cipher

    Universal Love Steve Silvagni - List Manager Extraordinaire

    If Menzel's stats as a third year player were a concern, what does that say about our future prospects given none of the 6 guys brought in have any better stats for their positions. That, despite 5 of them having been in the system up to an extra 2 years. In two seasons we've brought in Jones...
Back
Top