Search results for query: *

Gubby, is that you?

What to Darwin?

The list was built by Scott Clayton and Kinnear Beatson, and Leigh is a brilliant coach.

I don't think he'd be happy with your description either. You make him sound like a mid level Finance and Admin Officer. If Lions fans think he is doing a good job who I am to complain. The decision on Marcus Allan being promoted to the senior list will be judged in time. For me Marcus...

1. Ok, so who takes responsibility for the list?The recruiting manager generally reports to the football manager. 2. So are you saying Allan was elevated over Baird? 3. Doesn't mean he is good enough. Certainly not as good as Baird. In fact I know they are different types, but why promote...

1. Gubby Allan is Director of Football. Ultimately he has to take responsibility for the quality of the list. At Collingwood FC it was Barham who took the bullett. The same appears to have happened at Brisbane with Beatson. 2. According to reports Baird only returned to Victoria after the...

No, but I'd like him back at Collingwood! ;)

This is the second time Gubby Allan has overseen the demolition of a good list. Why is he never held accountable? Is there a more over paid, over rated person in football? Last time it was Ricky Barham who was the scapegoat. Barham is now viewed as somewhat of a genius at the Swans...

What expectations did you have? :confused: Its a free service, provided by someone who is obviously trying to positively contribute to this online community. :thumbsu: Maybe you should pull your head in and thank the guy for the work he has done, not what he hasn't. :thumbsd:

Waite - more a utility/flanker Fev - genuine, but inconsistent fast leading medium forward Deluca - can he play at all? Either way certainly no leading forward O'Hailpin - can he play at all? Heaps of talent, but just as much to learn. Fisher - more a flanker Hartlett - can he play at all...

So Murphy, Ellis and Ryder have gone and you don't want a Key Forward. Who do you take?

1. Kennedy is no Judd. Not even same universe. Judd was always a freak. The injury just knocked him from 1 to 3 in a very very good year. 2. Sampi had plenty of dvelopment left. Hurn is almost fully matured. He might play early, however he might also be very close to his peak. He is also a...

Kennedy has a very serious shoulder injury. He will most likely require a full reconstruction and will miss as much time if not more than Dowler. Hurn is a very good player, but arguably the most over rated player in these draft boards. I can't believe I am reading Carlton people argue...

Adleas theyze can speak n'glish. You must be too busy and too talented to post here. Or maybe not. Think about it.

Agree completely.

I don't know how anyone can justify Looby. He was belted today by Seal.

Dowler and Kennedy were both VERY lucky to make it. They can both play, but they didn't do enough in the carnival. They were picked on reputation Anyone else think Thorpe from Tassie was very unlucky to miss?