The team hasn't been announced yet? And it does have credibility otherwise you wouldn't be on this post complaining that richmond are hard done by. Taranto had a great year, was he better than some, yes. Would he make the side, absolutely not.
They're better off not even naming a squad, just...
The 2023 fan-voted AFL All-Australian team
FB: Tom Stewart, Harris Andrews, Dan Houston
HB: Nick Daicos, Darcy Moore, James Sicily
C: Josh Daicos, Jordan Dawson, Errol Gulden
HF: Christian Petracca, Taylor Walker, Toby Greene
FF: Charlie Cameron, Charlie Curnow, Nick Larkey
Foll: Tim English...
Let my bias show. Up to round 17 degoey was arguably a walk up. Then he got suspended and his form dipped. I think if he didn't have a best on that last game he's not making the sqaud.
Quaynor should make it, I will die on that hill
Merrett was never favourite for captaincy, and it's definitely not going to be Cripps.
It's only out of Bont, Moore and Greene.
Greene would be my pick
HAHAHA come on now.
You're using disposal efficiency as a reason lets go
Taranto for the season 59%
Career
Fyfe 68%
Mitchell. 71%
Danger 65%
so, you're flat out incorrect.
Taranto is ranked in the 430's for kicking efficiency this year.....garbage. Good player but lets be realistic
The more I think about it, the more as a Pies supporter I'd prefer Quaynor making it over Moore. He's arguably been the best small one on one defender in the comp and his attacking moves are nearly more effective. He won't make it but hope he gets in the squad
Sneak peak at the final side:
Sicily Weitering Stewart
N Daicos Moore Sinclair
Gulden Bont J Daicos
Rozee Walker Petracca
C Cameron Curnow Greene
Marshall Butters Serong
Larkey Libba Dawson Neale
I hate the concept of 4 mids on the bench. Langford for mine is a lock, and I would find room for another defender. Probably in place of merrett and taranto
Oh
we just picking whatever stats fit? Ok,
Rozee averages more
disposals
tackles
I50
clearances
R50
Metres gained
Tackles inside 50
Intercepts.
Is also 5th best player in the comp according to the coaches who.....shock....know more than us
Stats aside, he has helped his side win more than...
I'm picking Rozee on current form, been better in a better side. But it's who's had the better season. Langford has kicked 50 goals, and played a few games at half back. So yes, I am for real, he has been comfortably one of the best mid sized forwards this year.
Has he been better than the following: Greene, Langford, Petracca, Rozee, Curnow, Walker, Charlie Cameron as a genuine small, Jez Cameron. No, then he doesn't make it.
And no, he hasn't been better than any of them. Good year still
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.