Matthew Lloyd: "clubs are falling themselves over to get early pics"
Last edited:
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 6 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Certified Legendary Thread 1116 SEN 2024 line up
- Thread starter Rimmer
- Start date
- Tagged users None
^ oops, wrong thread
I occasionally switch on but 90% of it is always AFL/AFLW. Saw 1 minute of an AFLW game somewhere in QLD (Cairns?). Zero crowd but gets massive coverage?
peternorth
Moderator
- May 6, 2005
- 129,739
- 77,722
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Moderator
- #25,154
aflw is an interesting situation. they have to promote it, but when key personnel in garry and watson effectively never mention it, and when it comes up garry will proclaim he's not across it/not an expert, it leaves you wondering wtf is going on. Do they and others at the station genuinely care about the W?
Do they need to care about it? They've discussed how they don't watch it, and that it's okay to not like the product. Don't think they need to say much more
nobbyiscool
Brownlow Medallist
- Aug 11, 2006
- 21,466
- 23,844
- AFL Club
- Tasmania
What an absolute cop out. In what other walk of media is it acceptable for paid experts to say "I'm not across this core element of the one thing I'm supposed to be an expert in"? That's a joke, if they don't watch it they don't deserve jobs in AFL media.
Yeah, it's ok to not like the product - but you're being paid to discuss it. Men's footy has been unwatchable at various points over the last 20 years, we never let anyone get away with saying "I don't watch it, I'm not an expert in it."
Can you imagine Peter Hitchner just ignoring the Israel/Palestine(/Lebanon) war? "I don't like it, I don't watch it, I don't care about it."
He'd rightly lose his job.
They aren't being paid to watch AFLW, they'd being paid to talk about the AFL and the footy landscape.
AFLW is better suited to have people who are interested in it, talking about it. Pretending like everyone needs to watch it because it has the AFL branding on it - is very weird.
nobbyiscool
Brownlow Medallist
- Aug 11, 2006
- 21,466
- 23,844
- AFL Club
- Tasmania
Whether you like it or not, it's a professional, top level sport that deserves to be talked about at the height of its season. It is a major part of "the footy landscape" as you call it.
Pretending the sport doesn't matter because it's a women's league is much weirder.
Not all professional sports get discussed, and it's top level perhaps for what it is, but lets not kid ourselves about where that level is. There are local leagues with a significantly higher standard of football, and there's no expectation of the media to look at that.
I really respected the fact that they went out on a bit of a limb and actually were brave enough to state this the other week. It's pretty cringeworthy when others clearly don't give a shit about it but pretend they do because they don't want to offend anyone.
Let's face it, they're there to talk footy - AFL. They don't know much about other sports and they don't really have to. The idea of the show is two pretty high end former footy players talking about footy and then whatever else they really want to. Comparing these guys to a news presenter is a bit stupid.
peternorth
Moderator
- May 6, 2005
- 129,739
- 77,722
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Moderator
- #25,162
Is the morning show an AFL show though?
For footy experts they really only cover the basics
This motor racing show I swear is a motor racing show by name only. They give supercars the biggest tounging ever up the arse, and all the time.
Supercars isn't even a genuine car racing competition. It's ******* lame.
Even when they shit on it, it's always in context. They've never go overboard or target lightweight topics.
They're ******* hopeless.
Supercars isn't even a genuine car racing competition. It's ******* lame.
Even when they shit on it, it's always in context. They've never go overboard or target lightweight topics.
They're ******* hopeless.
Ive actually tried to listen and these guys go on like the horse racing show
peternorth
Moderator
- May 6, 2005
- 129,739
- 77,722
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Moderator
- #25,165
Do they feel the average listener is into Holden vs ford style debates?
- Jun 14, 2017
- 710
- 929
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
No, it's contrived, but the engineering therein is pretty world-class....I see the BTCC every now and then and it's woefully slow and amateur by comparison - absolutely not the answer here. Darwinian thing to say, but V8 Supercars was good when the Kelly Bros had Nissans and when there was the Mercs - because they were allowed to fail
Today right now Supercars is by far the best motorsport category there is. I'd rather watch the grand final replay than watch F1 or Nascar
That Horse racing show is an absolute ear sore, and feel like it runs for 12 hours straight. Hows that bloke with the grating voice who just talks absolute unprofessional shit and runs his horse home like he's at the TAB.
Would love to see their actual ratings on the Horse race segments, surely a very small but loud minority is into that immature embarrassment of a so called sport.
The Golden Glenferrie
Norm Smith Medallist
peternorth
Moderator
- May 6, 2005
- 129,739
- 77,722
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Moderator
- #25,170
Considering supercars copies everything nascar does except race on ovals. That's an unusual opinion.
If it was the big deal you think it is, they wouldn't be trying to spruce it up all the time. And those bozos on Wednesday night. wouldn't be trying to pump it up all the time.
Bathurst is a carnival, but a percentage of regular visitors know it's shit. But they don't know anything else.
Supercars is car racing for people who think they like car racing.
toxic
Premium Gold
Legend status
I don't think it's unusual when the shit part about Nascars is the fact that they race on ovals lol.
Motorsport is the one sport in the world that gets worse the more professional and streamlined it gets, just look at F1. Those things they do to 'spruce' it up is to appease people like yourself really.
I always find myself coming back to grass roots level motorsport like speedway etc, and Supercars is the closest professional code to giving me that feeling. It's uncoventional, bumper to bumper racing to get the basic petrol head juices flowing. It ain't that deep. I actually think your statement is quite the opposite, those who like car racing (and don't take themselves too seriously) come back to it.
Blokes got T-rex arms to top off the cheese grater voice and choice in sport.
Cam Luke and the so called magic man Miles Phitzner , both flogs
