-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
2011 Official Trade/Delisting Discussion Thread IIII
- Thread starter Fin ice Smuggler
- Start date
- Tagged users None
bomberfan101
Senior List
And now pick 29 has been on traded to Freo!
next will be jenkins to adelaide...
- Apr 26, 2007
- 4,828
- 2,701
- AFL Club
- Essendon
Can someone please explain the swap of picks between Hawthorn & Freo that just happened? I dont get it from a Hawks POV? Or is it somewhat goodwill for something else that has/will happen?
why would brisbane deal with us anyway?
i thought they said they would never deal with us again after the mal michael thing.... when we wanted to get brennan they put up the shutters..
are they over that then?
i thought they said they would never deal with us again after the mal michael thing.... when we wanted to get brennan they put up the shutters..
are they over that then?
Apparently its part of a bigger picture that we'll find out later today..
boncer34
Formerly "Dos23"
Bourman from Box Hill got traded from GWS to Hawthorn for one of the picks they grabbed from Freo.
Still can't be the whole picture.
Still can't be the whole picture.
- Apr 26, 2007
- 4,828
- 2,701
- AFL Club
- Essendon
Must have already signed off on the Caddy deal since he grew up barracking for them, his grandfather played for them etc etc..
Most teams (not you if Daniher costs a first round pick next year) have more to offer next near than this year, he may lose value or gain value next year but its likely they would get at least as much next year. On top of that next years draft is described to be stronger.
I'm worried that Essendon may do something desperate to get Caddy. Please gentlemen don't give up the farm this year. There will be more available next year and even if we finish higher we'll have a better draft pick to sell. Hoping that Daniher misses a lot of next year. I suggest the club gets him in the gym all year so he is sore each week and doesn't star in TAC and nationals.
Involved in a mediation session with GC at the moment apparently!!
This is goooooooood!
This is goooooooood!
Hutchy says he believes the Bombers have put Gumbleton and Hooker on the table in order to get the Caddy deal done #tradeweek
It's just half the farm.
Loonerty
TheBrownDog
I could see Gumbleton being offered, but Hooker... I'm not so sure.
I sincerely hope Caddy is worth it...
I sincerely hope Caddy is worth it...
vast
Hall of Famer
The way I heard it was that hutchy said hooker, gumbleton and 19 isnt enough. LOL. Plough agreed lol.
Loonerty
TheBrownDog
I think GC would only take 19 + Gumby + Hooker, might get a pick with Caddy for it...
For a player who wants to head back to Melbourne to be closer to their ill father, they'd be nuts not to take it. Surely if they screw him on this, with the Bombers already offering overs, that they will lose his commitment.
Hooker would have to be straight up, IMO. If that happened we'd want Gumby to be fit next year and to go tall defender with our first pick this year.
If plough was heading the charge at the Gold Coast we would of already gotten Caddy for 2, maybe 3 snickers bars. Dead set idiot he is.
rey del castillo
Debutant
cant wait to the HUN artictle pops up Caddy confirmed as bomber!!
Doss
Ass
- Aug 1, 2011
- 75,222
- 112,368
- AFL Club
- Essendon
It's obvious GC are trying to call our bluff. Really, if Caddy wants to come home that badly (especially with his father being sick), they almost have to trade him; they'd be cutting off their nose to spite their face keeping someone on the list when they patently don't want to be there. No point keeping a playing there whose heart isn't in it.
And I have to say, I really DON'T like the idea of giving up Hooker. Gumbleton, I'm more open to, but then I doubt GC would take him, there's too much doubt as to whether his injuries will ever allow him to fulfill his undoubted potential. Big shame.
And I have to say, I really DON'T like the idea of giving up Hooker. Gumbleton, I'm more open to, but then I doubt GC would take him, there's too much doubt as to whether his injuries will ever allow him to fulfill his undoubted potential. Big shame.
rey del castillo
Debutant
currently in mediation.. those dogs rying to extract as much as possible.. cant wait to belt them again next year!!
Just in terms of team structures.
With Joe D coming, perhaps Hurley does play as a back as Hookers replacement.
or even Hird sees Ryder as a CHB after his performance against Collingwood.
Just a thought
With Joe D coming, perhaps Hurley does play as a back as Hookers replacement.
or even Hird sees Ryder as a CHB after his performance against Collingwood.
Just a thought
surely that's correct
